An overview of Syracuse University’s Title IX investigations process
Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.
Last week, Syracuse University Chancellor Mike Haynie announced a team would review SU’s response protocols amid national attention around sexual violence on college campuses.
A rape lawsuit filed against Cornell University and its Chi Phi fraternity chapter led to widespread scrutiny of the school’s Title IX proceedings. Weeks after the case gained a national audience in October, Cornell announced a university-wide review regarding its policies on responses to sexual assault.
The Daily Orange interviewed lawyers who advise parties in Title IX cases about how cases are processed, investigated and adjudicated. Here’s what they had to share.
What Title IX investigations look like
Title IX offices can investigate and adjudicate claims of sexual assault and harassment. The office can recommend and carry out disciplinary action, which can include suspension or expulsion.
In Title IX cases, credibility, corroboration and narrative inconsistencies are often scrutinized, Jeremy Saland, a criminal defense lawyer defending one of the men accused in the Cornell case, said. He’s represented both complainants — people who bring allegations — and respondents in Title IX cases.
Generally, Saland said Title IX investigations, which typically take 60 to 180 days, are built to favor those who bring cases.
“The tie goes to the complainant in these cases,” Saland said. “It’s more difficult for an accused person to win a case once it’s brought, but it is more emotionally difficult for a complainant to bring a case.”
A Title IX investigator acts like a law enforcement officer, gathering evidence independently on cases, Melissa Swartz, a defense lawyer who handles Title IX cases among others, said. A hearing officer, on the other hand, writes an outcome letter based on the evidence found in those investigations and examinations during the case proceeding, and acts like a judge, Swartz said.
Depending on the university, attorneys, professors and administrators can be Title IX case officers and investigators. At SU, hearing officers and investigators are exclusively attorneys, a university spokesperson wrote in a statement to The D.O. SU began using attorneys as Title IX officers in 2020, the statement said.
Federal changes to the Title IX process
Federal standards on Title IX policies and investigations have shaped how cases are handled.
Under former President Barack Obama’s administration, the U.S. Department of Education issued a 19-page letter in 2011 that outlined how colleges should respond to reports of campus assault. The letter argued that Title IX, as a federal gender-equity law, required colleges to use their resources to prevent assaults, punish perpetrators, conduct investigations and protect complainants while cases were open.
Title IX cases under the Obama administration placed all responsibilities in the hands of a single investigator, who would investigate cases and make final decisions.
The universal standard of evidence in Title IX investigations was a “preponderance of the evidence” standard under the Obama administration. This standard is common in civil suits.
In 2020, during President Donald Trump’s first term, the Department of Education changed its policies on case investigations. Now, schools can choose a “clear and convincing evidence” standard if they wish, which is a higher standard of evidence.
This evidentiary standard isn’t usually applied at schools, Saland said. Schools are allowed to have their own policies on the matter, and at SU, like most other schools, the standard in cases remains preponderance of the evidence, the university spokesperson wrote.
Another Trump policy change to Title IX allows cross-examination of complainants, which Saland said brings more due process to the cases by giving respondents an opportunity to confront their accusers.
Cross-examination is limited, Saland said — it doesn’t resemble a trial setting. A lawyer can ask a question and the hearing chair will decide whether the witness or party needs to answer or reformulate the question, he explained. The purpose of cross-examination in these cases is to evaluate consistency of stories, Swartz said.
Lawyers can act in advisory capacities for parties in a Title IX case, but advisors don’t have to be lawyers.
At SU, all hearings are held on Zoom, and advisors don’t approach witnesses in person for the cross-examinations. The university statement said that SU provides both parties with attorneys to serve as advisors that are specially trained to conduct cross-examinations.
“If you are found responsible for sexual assault and expelled, this could destroy your life going forward,” Saland said. “If you’ve committed an offense, that’s the consequence you should bear, but if you’re going to have these consequences, then the case needs the hallmarks of due process.”
WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT
SU organizations respond to Cornell University sexual assault lawsuit
SU student organizations have released statements responding to a 2024 Cornell University sexual assault lawsuit, condemning sexual violence.
Challenges in evidence gathering
In a court case, there’s a discovery phase where both parties can gather evidence for trial. Courts have the power to subpoena for evidence and subpoena witnesses to force them to appear before the court for testimony.
The evidence gathering process in Title IX cases is done through the school’s Title IX investigators, and they don’t have the same authority that a court would have, Swartz said.
A Title IX officer can’t compel witnesses to testify or subpoena evidence gathered by a third party, like a bar with surveillance cameras. Investigators can only gather third-party evidence that is voluntarily brought, such as texts or pictures, Swartz said.
The university can also gather evidence through its own mechanisms, like security cameras operated by campus police, Swartz said.
Challenges in gathering evidence impact both sides of a case, Saland said.
“You might have a witness that might totally corroborate or exonerate an accusation, but there’s zero mechanism to compel that witness to come forward,” Saland said.
The rules of evidence are different in a Title IX proceeding, and rules around witness testimony are more lenient. If a complainant tells another student about an assault that happened to them, the other student can testify about the complainant’s story, which in criminal cases would be considered hearsay and inadmissible as evidence, Swartz said.
Hearsay is defined as a statement made out of court by a witness that is brought in as evidence of a fact. In Title IX cases, hearsay testimony is often considered as evidence, Swartz said.
In New York state courts, there is a “prompt outcry” exception that allows for hearsay testimony to be submitted as evidence if the accuser told the witness at the first available opportunity they had, Swartz said. This exception applies if the testimony would complete the accuser’s narrative of events and corroborate their story.
But in Title IX cases, any testimony, even one that would be hearsay in criminal cases, can be included, regardless of the timeliness of the report, Swartz said. A prompt outcry exception doesn’t necessarily need to be applied.
For example, a complainant could have told a friend their story two weeks after it happened, Swartz said, and it would still be admissible as evidence in a Title IX case even if it would be inadmissible in a U.S. court.
“This is not good proof in any other case, but it is good proof in a Title IX case,” Swartz said.
Appeals go back to the school
In a criminal prosecution or civil suit, parties can appeal the result of the case to a higher court if they have a valid legal reason. These may include a lack of sufficient evidence, irregularities in case proceedings or a conflict of interest, according to the U.S. Department of Education’s Title IX Summary.
Grounds for an appeal of a Title IX case at SU include procedural errors, new evidence that could affect the outcome, an unfair hearing process or an inappropriate sanction or punishment, the university statement said.
Parties can appeal a Title IX case, but the appeal stays within the school. Appeals also must be made quickly, within five or 10 days depending on the institution.
At SU, there is an official Title IX appeals board that reviews and decides on appeals, the university statement said. The group is composed of faculty and staff, who are trained and have legal advisors.
The Title IX appeals process is different from a court appeals process because it’s a self-evaluation, Saland said. Appellate courts are different from lower courts, with different judges and juries evaluating cases, but in Title IX appeals, different people at the same institution are evaluating the cases.
“The school is evaluating its own process in a case,” Saland said. “And schools have an interest in the outcomes.”

