Skip to content
Halloween Guide 2026

Ashes of Newhouse’s 1st dean and his wife have lain in its walls for decades

Located in the Newhouse School of Public Communications, these plaques honor former Dean Matthew Lyle Spencer and his wife, Helen McNaughton Spencer. The pair's cremains are contained in a wall inside Newhouse 1's Room 305.
Located in the Newhouse School of Public Communications, these plaques honor former Dean Matthew Lyle Spencer and his wife, Helen McNaughton Spencer. The pair's cremains are contained in a wall inside Newhouse 1's Room 305. Zoe Xixis | Asst. Photo Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

UPDATE: This story was updated at 12:41 p.m. EST on Oct. 29, 2026.

It started as a typical afternoon for Professor Jay Wright in 1974. But when he left his top-floor office of the Newhouse School of Public Communications to grab his mail, some unusual activity caught his attention.

“What’s happening?” Wright asked the group standing in Newhouse 1’s lobby.

“Well, come in. What’s happening is that we’ve got the ashes for Dean Spencer, and they’re putting it literally in the wall,” Wright remembers the gatherers saying.

What now-Professor Emeritus Wright, 85, saw that day was the placement of the cremains of Newhouse’s founding dean — Matthew Lyle Spencer and his wife, Helen McNaughton Spencer — inside the professor lounge. The lounge is now Newhouse 1, Room 305, also known as the Fred M. Dressler Board Room.

Some colleges and universities — like the University of Richmond and the University of Virginia, to name a few — have their own final resting places and memorials, but Syracuse University has an academic building with a wall that holds two human cremains.

The edifice still holds those ashes today, Newhouse Dean Mark Lodato said. Matthew died Feb. 10, 1969, and McNaughton Spencer died Jan. 1, 1973, but it’s unclear when the former’s remains arrived at Newhouse. However, it was found that McNaughton Spencer’s ashes arrived at SU on Jan. 12, 1973, former Newhouse Dean Henry Schulte wrote in a document obtained by The Daily Orange.

“There was, I would say, work done that gave us all confidence that there were, in fact, remains behind the plaque and facade,” Lodato said.

Lodato wasn’t the only person to confirm that the remains exist in the walls of Newhouse. The granddaughter of Matthew and McNaughton Spencer, 65-year-old Nancy Fritch, grew up hearing the legend about her grandparents’ remains. But when Fritch’s mom died in 2019, the documents she inherited corroborated those stories.

Matthew’s final will left clear postmortem instructions.

“In accordance with permission given me in 1965 by Chancellor Tolley of Syracuse University, I direct that my ashes be inurned privately within the confines of the Syracuse School of Journalism, the precise location to be determined by the Chancellor of the University and/or the Dean of the School,” Matthew wrote in a document obtained by The D.O.

Then, Matthew wrote that his wife’s ashes were to be interred in “the same crypt” as his, if she chose to. McNaughton Spencer directed her cremains be interred privately with her husband’s “in or near the confines of the Syracuse School of Journalism,” McNaughton Spencer wrote in her will, which was obtained by The D.O.

While Newhouse is not quite a mausoleum, there is a wall that holds two sets of ashes. The wall is about four feet deep and to the right of the doorway stands a collection of trophies and accolades. In the middle of that collection exists a wood panel with two tombstone-like placards: one for Matthew and one for McNaughton Spencer.

Another Spencer descendant, 70-year-old Chris Spencer, said he saw the plaques and portrait himself during a visit to Newhouse in the early 1970s. Although Chris can’t remember the exact year he saw the portrait that held the urn behind them, he estimates he was in sixth grade.

“It was one of those things that unless you knew his ashes were behind his portrait, you wouldn’t even know to look,” Chris said. “It was literally in a little trophy case.”

Susan Nash, director of administration at SU’s Institute for Democracy, Journalism and Citizenship, said that the portrait was removed from the wall in 2022.

When Nash began working in Newhouse in 1987, she recalled rumors about the Spencers’ columbarium being located in the school. Then, in the late 1990s, Nash was sitting in the Dean’s Suite when a Spencer kin showed up, asking to see the room where their relatives’ ashes were stored.

“Oh my gosh, it’s true,” Nash thought.

The cremains of former Dean Matthew Lyle Spencer and his wife, Helen McNaughton Spencer, rest behind these wooden panels in the Newhouse School of Public Communications. Matthew wrote in his final will that his ashes would be inurned within the confines of the building. Zoe Xixis | Asst. Photo Editor

Then, she brought them to the room and showed them Matthew’s oil painting and plaque.

After that, Nash tried to find evidence that SU documented this, but it was nowhere, she said. Flash forward years later, it wasn’t until 2022 that the rumor of human cremains in Newhouse could be confirmed, Nash said.

Both Lodato and Nash verified the location of the ashes: in Room 305 of Newhouse 1, behind a wooden panel.

One initiative of Lodato’s tenure was to upgrade the Newhouse 1 lobby and Room 305 to make them more contemporary and appealing to prospective students. So, he and Nash consulted with an architectural firm to begin renovation plans. Nash said when the architects brainstormed designs, they inquired about removing the wall panel containing the urns.

“Well, can we take down that middle part? Can we relocate that plaque?” Nash remembers the architects asking.

“I don’t know,” Nash said. “I think that the dean is in there.”

The architects were confused, to say the least, Nash said. Their project manager from the Campus Planning, Design and Construction team brought SU Facilities Services to remove the wooden panel that the plaques and portrait were affixed to. Once extracted, they found the wall’s contents included two containers of ashes: one for Matthew and one for McNaughton Spencer.

Without disturbing the remnants, the ashes were documented with photos and the panel was quickly reinstalled. Nash said it was like “you had just opened a grave.”

“Once we made that confirmation, it was clear to me that the right decision was to work around the ashes and the memorial,” Lodato said. “In essence, underscore the importance of that decision at the time it was made, and preserve something that is unique about Newhouse.”

The wall around the panel has since been renovated, but the wood slab has stayed. Now, the cremains are honored with two rectangular epitaphs for each of their remains, which were added during the renovations in 2022.

For a student worried that their studies may be interrupted by Newhouse 1’s macabre feature, Lodato would tell them to look at the bigger picture of what wanting to be laid to rest in one’s workplace really means.

“It really speaks to one person’s love and dedication for the school and the university,” Lodato said.

Chris said he’s always been surprised that SU knows his grandparents’ cremains actually exist in the walls. Although some family members like Nancy have never visited the Spencers’ cremains, Nancy said the choice of being buried at SU made sense for her grandparents, given Matthew’s role at SU.

“I always knew that their connection to this university was strong because it was always very, very proud,” Nancy said. “My mom was always very proud of him.”


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

Syracuse University’s spookiest story? Human remains may be stored in a wall in Newhouse 1.

The remains of Matthew Lyle Spencer, the first dean of the School of Journalism, may be stored on a shelf behind a wall in the building.


According to the same 1973 document addressed to “Mrs. Robert Fritch” — meant for the Spencers’ daughter, Helen Spencer Fritch — Henry Schulte never met McNaughton Spencer. However, they had corresponded through letters for the past year.

Henry Schulte assured Fritch that her mother’s ashes would be treated with respect and “placed next to your father’s and an appropriate plaque will be added,” according to the document obtained by The D.O.

Matthew served as Newhouse’s dean from 1934 to 1950, which was a long time for him to live in one place, Fritch said.

However, most people touring Newhouse and spending time in Newhouse 1’s Room 305 probably don’t have a clue that there are ashes behind the plaques, Wright said. But if Wright happened to be in Newhouse 1 Room 305, he’d say the same fact to whoever was with him.

“Do you see that plaque? You know what’s behind that?” Wright would ask.

“I would tell them, but I’d never gotten more than a nod,” Wright said.

membership_button_new-10