Skip to content
City

Environmental panelists criticize Micron’s local impact at ArtRage Gallery

panel
“The public demands accountability.” Environmental advocates spoke out against Micron Technologies’ $100 billion semiconductor plant in Clay, New York, during a panel hosted by SU’s NPR affiliate WAER at the ArtRage Gallery on Wednesday. Logan Weyant | Contributing Photographer

Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.

Local advocates spoke out against Micron Technologies’ $100 billion semiconductor plant in Clay, New York during a Wednesday panel discussion at ArtRage Gallery.

The event, hosted by Syracuse University’s NPR affiliate WAER, included four panelists, who each mentioned environmental concerns, job promises and community benefits. Micron’s Clay plant has faced ongoing criticism over rushed regulations and energy concerns.

Bonita Siegel, president of Neighbors for a Better Micron, who’s been a vocal opponent of the plant, said the group started small with Clay residents who were concerned about the project’s environmental impacts.

Days after Micron broke ground in January, the group, along with national labor organization Jobs to Move America, filed a class-action lawsuit against Micron and the Onondaga County Industrial Development Agency, calling for a reassessment of the project’s final Environmental Impact Statement.

“We are now up to 179 members of the association,” Siegel said. “We’re eager to have people who share our concerns join us.”

A retired neurologist with a chemical engineering degree from SU, Siegel said her experience working on semiconductor chips early in her career gave her first-hand knowledge of the industry’s “intense demands.”

“It is an extremely delicate, intricate process,” Siegel said. “Living so close to Micron just elevates all my concerns.”

First announced in October 2022 and scheduled to be operational by the end of the decade, the plant will consist of four fabrication computer chip factories, producing memory chips crucial to electronic devices and AI’s development.

Catherine Landis, a science advisor at the center for Native Peoples and the Environment at the SUNY College of Environmental Science and Forestry, mentioned the region’s environmental history. She cited past memories of industrial pollution in Onondaga Lake.

“I went through what happened with Onondaga Lake. I see deja vu with Micron coming, like ‘Here we go again.’ What did we learn? Did we learn anything?” Landis said.

At the first concrete pouring event in July, Micron President and CEO Sanjay Mehrotra announced the plant was months ahead of schedule and required an increase of $50 billion for domestic manufacturing spending. In June, the company announced a partnership with construction company Bechtel to build the four factories.

Don Hughes, a member of Sierra Club and professor of chemistry at Le Moyne College, said when he first heard of Micron’s arrival to Syracuse, he welcomed the giant for the potential economic benefits.

“I’ve lived through 30 years of economic decay in this community,” Hughes said. “My initial reaction to Micron was, ‘Wow, this sounds pretty cool.’”

Landis is a plant ecologist, so she said she sees herself as a “voice” for ecosystems that aren’t present in developmental discussions.

“It always irks me when I hear the 1,400-acre Micron area is vacant land. Because if you ever went out there before it was destroyed, it was anything but vacant,” Landis said.

In comparison to a giant sponge, Landis described how some of the area was a giant wetland, and 200 acres of it was plowed through for the facility. She said current construction requires lowering water levels through a process called dewatering, which would impact wetlands past the Micron project’s boundaries.


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

As Micron’s semiconductor project accelerates, community pushback persists

Despite facing two environmental lawsuits from locals, Micron Technology asserts its semiconductor project is “ahead of schedule.”


After further research into the plant’s environmental footprint, Hughes’ view shifted to wanting to see change from the future plant.

“Semiconductor facilities are really just giant chemical plants,” Hughes said. “They have a huge appetite for chemicals.”

Hughes raised alarms about the semiconductor plant’s use of polyfluoroalkyl substances, a broad group of “forever chemicals” known to contaminate water and ecosystems.

PFAS are widely used within semiconductor manufacturing, mostly during etching and heat transferring processes. Hughes said because semiconductor manufacturing is a novice industry in the United States, existing state and national regulations won’t be enough to firmly oversee Micron’s remediation of the chemicals.

Hughes pointed to Micron’s other semiconductor plant in Boise, Idaho, for inspiration on how Micron could handle its upcoming facilities. He also called for transparency from the company on the lack of toxic chemical identifications.

Micron’s Boise campus features a recyclable plant that reuses the waste it emits. The panelists mentioned the Syracuse facility may have similar features, but the panelists said there’s no proof of that happening here.

Local environmental experts warned of the ambiguity surrounding Micron’s environmental commitments, stemming from a lack of specific regulation around manufacturing chemicals to a shift in language from 100% “renewable energy” to “carbon-free energy” in its most recent posts.

“When this thing gets going at full speed, you’re looking at 200 tons a day, every single day of the year,” Hughes said.

Dick Kornbluth, a board chair at the Urban Jobs Task Force, focused his remarks on whether Micron’s promised benefits of jobs for local workers will actually benefit the city. He specifically mentioned Syracuse’s high poverty rates.

Although Kornbluth acknowledged Micron’s investment in semiconductor education at Onondaga Community College and the company’s investment in new bus routes to the plant, Kornbluth questioned whether those commitments were enforced.

Most workforce goals outlined in agreements tied to the project rely on voluntary compliance rather than legally binding requirements.

“Micron’s only required response was, ‘We will make a good faith effort to do any of that,’” Kornbluth said.

He compared the billion-dollar project to the I-81 viaduct project, which created local hiring targets after years of negotiations among labor groups and government agencies in the city.

“The big problem is that the organizations I represent are not concerned about the workforce in general but are concerned about the disadvantaged communities in central New York,” Kornbluth said.

In concluding remarks, Siegel encouraged the public to become more involved against the “behemoth” the community faces.

“The public needs to demand accountability,” Siegel said. “This is not a partisan problem, it’s a community one.”

membership_button_new-10