Have a drink with John, the man behind Marshall Street ‘pillar’ Harry’s Bar
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.
“Say you know John behind the bar.”
John Shahin, 63, couldn’t guess how many times he’s given that instruction to his customers over the years. How many students are even in a Syracuse University graduating class? Thirty-seven of those classes have come through the doors of Harry’s Bar.
That doesn’t stop John from greeting customers like friends. He never knows who’ll walk through the door on any given night, and that’s why he loves it.
“It’s fun, right? You’re meeting people. You’re making tips. You’re drinking after hours, and you wake up in the morning, do it all over again,” John said.
SU’s nightlife scene is ever-changing, with Pitch Social replacing longtime favorite Lucy Blu Island Bar & Club this fall. But Harry’s and its owner have occupied the corner property on E Adams Street and S Crouse Avenue since 1990.
John has watched new bars on Marshall Street come and go. They don’t stick around for long if they’re not from the area, he said.
If you ask John why his bar has stayed a constant on Marshall Street, he wryly jokes that it must be his great personality. When John breaks his earnest eye contact for a sarcastic wisecrack, it catches you off guard; that’s what makes him so funny.
When John’s son and bartender ZJ Shahin, 24, starts to explain the bar’s success, the answer walks out from behind the bar.
“That guy himself,” ZJ says.
The proof is in the clientele. Mike Vamo, a longtime family friend and John’s former employee, is sitting on a barstool before Harry’s opens on a Tuesday night for exactly that reason.
ZJ won’t go into too much detail about exactly why people come to visit his dad, but he describes John as “a very fun guy, to say the least.” Maybe it has something to do with John’s signature shot combination: chilled Grey Goose and orangeade.
John is a magnet for people, his younger son Xavier Shahin, 23, said. Businesses and storefronts change, but Xavier said his dad just doesn’t.
“Faegan’s and John Shahin are the two last pillars of Marshall Street of the past,” Vamo said.
To Vamo, that means giving students the experience of Syracuse as a whole, not just SU. Marshall Street businesses like Harry’s give students a break from classes and a home away from home, he said.
Opening a bar was John’s childhood ambition. Now, he owns two — Harry’s and Saltine Warrior Sports Pub downtown. That’s what happens when you start hanging out at Syracuse bars at 15, he said, joking he often showed up to high school hungover.

John Shahin, owner of Harry’s Bar, stands in his Syracuse University-themed bar. Over the years, his bar has become decked out with SU memorabilia like a large photo of the JMA Wireless Dome and signatures from past and current SU students. Tara Deluca | Photo Editor
Without an appealing offer from a wealthy bachelor neighbor, John’s bar wouldn’t have been in Syracuse at all.
“I was on my way to San Diego to bartend in the southern sunshine,” John said. “And he goes, ‘You’re gonna break your mother’s heart. So, find a bar for sale, and I’ll back you up for that.’ So he gave me a $110,000 loan to buy Harry’s, and I paid him back probably five or six years later.”
Thirty-seven years later, John has no regrets about staying home. He recalls the opening dates of his two bars like children’s birthdays — Harry’s on June 5, 1990 and Saltine Warrior Aug. 24, 2011.
Now, John is looking to purchase a third bar. The biggest risk is not taking one, he said.
The bar was already named Harry’s when John bought it. He thought it was funny when customers approached him asking if he was Harry, so he kept the name.
John originally purchased only the smaller left side of the property with a capacity of 36. In 1998, John got a sledgehammer and knocked the middle wall down to make way for the current 200-person capacity.
Xavier thinks of another reason for his dad’s success as he walks through the bar.
“It’s because he’s a f–cking Marine,” Xavier calls out.
Without his experience in the Marine Corps, Harry’s probably would’ve been closed in a year, John said. His five years in the Marines gave him the discipline he needed to stay on track in the chaos of a college bar. John is on the clock 24/7, ZJ said.
Sometimes, John doesn’t leave Harry’s until 3 a.m. and is back up at 7:30 to restock the bars and prepare for another night.
John expects that same discipline and focus from his employees, most of whom are SU students. He makes his expectations clear when he hires them.
“You’re not on your phone. That’s my time. Put your phone away,” John said. “If I want you to watch that door there, you watch that door there. No one comes in, no one leaves with a drink. And if someone can’t do that, which I don’t know how they can’t, they get fired on the spot.”
WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT
Pitch Social revamps ‘Blucy’s’ to unleash club energy on SU’s bar scene
Lucy Blu Island Bar & Club, which closed in July, will be replaced with club-like bar Pitch Social at Syracuse.
The expectations are no different for ZJ and Xavier, who both work as bartenders at Harry’s. If anything, John’s standards for his sons are even higher, Xavier said. Having your dad as your boss can be “frustrating,” ZJ said. If he’s not giving 100% behind the bar, ZJ said he gets yelled at like any other employee.
Xavier has been a bartender for seven years but worked in and around Harry’s since his childhood. He got “fired” at age 12.
He opens up as he recounts the memory — the Orange were playing Duke University, back when SU was a No. 1 team. He had to run around grabbing beer from an outside cooler, fending off guys trying to steal drinks.
John promised Xavier he could go to the game later. But when Xavier tried to leave, John told him he had to stay and work, causing a fight.
“He’s like, ‘You want to get fired?’ I’m like, ‘I’m not fired, I f—cking quit.’ And then I walked home, then the next day, came back to work, did the same thing,” he said.
That’s just his dad, Xavier said. Even if they fight, Xavier will still show up and do what he has to do for John. Xavier owes it to his dad to work hard, he said.
An SU theme sets Harry’s apart. Just like Mulrooney’s is an Irish pub and Sassy-Cuse Saloon is western themed, Harry’s embodies SU, Vamo said, pointing to the large picture of the Dome on the wall behind him as an example. Another of SU legend Jim Brown takes up the wall adjacent to a recently installed Zyn vending machine.
SU students decorate the bar in their own way. Once the plexiglass on the interior walls cracked, students started chipping it off to write their names. After that, John just let the walls go. The graffiti of signatures adds “flavor,” he said.
A shirt framed on the wall reads “You can take the girl out of Harry’s, but not the Harry’s out of the girl,” signed with Kappa Kappa Gamma’s Greek letters. They were a great group of girls, John says; he still remembers them clearly, though they graduated in 2008.
The walls are decorated with framed photos of championship-winning SU sports teams and SU football players who made it to the NFL. John’s favorite saying, “Duck Fuke,” is displayed proudly on a sign near the original front bar.
Some of John’s favorite memories of the bar center around championship SU sports teams. His bar’s “walls were bursting” when SU men’s basketball won a national championship in 2003.
After the 1995 men’s basketball team beat Georgia to go to the Final Four, the team walked right off their bus into Harry’s, jerseys still on. John Wallace still had the net around his neck.
Sports teams don’t come in as often anymore. John remembers the “glory days” of the 1980s and ‘90s, when it felt like every SU team was in the top 10. But nothing lasts forever, John said.
“There’s no commitment to excellence anymore,” he said.

A black-and-white photo of Syracuse University football legend Jim Brown is framed on the walls of Harry’s Bar with SU students’ signatures above it. Sports memorabilia and student signatures have become an integral part of the identity of Harry’s Bar. Tara Deluca | Photo Editor
If the football team isn’t winning, coming to Harry’s just isn’t as fun, John said. But SU’s sports track record isn’t the only thing that’s changed about the party scene.
To start, kids don’t drink like they used to, John said. As marijuana has become increasingly popular, beer distributors have started complaining that business is down citywide.
In the past, Harry’s has had the stigma of being an “underage bar,” ZJ said. He said changing that reputation was a stressor for John — now he has to pay an annual fee for ID scanners.
“The bar business is never straight up, right? It’s more of a roller coaster, up and down, up and down, up and down,” John said. “And sometimes you got to do what you got to do to survive the down times.”
Out of his 37 years owning a business, five or six have been “down years.” But, you pull yourself up by the bootstraps, John said — just like in the Marines.
Despite the challenges, John said he only gets tired, not tired of it. People don’t ask John if he’s getting too old for the business. They’re probably too scared of him, he said.
Don’t repeat it too loudly, but Xavier sees himself taking over the bar someday. It’s in his blood, he said. He wants to carry on his dad’s legacy. It’s been 37 years, he said, why not go for another 37?
Whenever Xavier talks to John about taking over, John says he’s not dead yet. Don’t push it.
John loves to see old employees come back to the bar with their kids. They ask him if he’ll ever leave — but Harry’s definitely isn’t broken, so John feels no need to fix it.
“He’d probably die here, to be honest,” ZJ said. “He’d probably be buried somewhere in here if it was possible.”
But things aren’t winding down at all, John says, and it’s past 10 p.m. on a Tuesday night.
Someone asks the bartender why the music isn’t on yet. ABBA then starts blasting, accompanying the colorful lights flashing across the bartenders’ faces.
Customers start to file in, girls pointing out their signatures in the expanse of Sharpie scribbles that have turned into an abstract wallpaper.
Bouncers take their places at the back door, and the music is audible from across the street. Patrons will tell them they know “John behind the bar.” Another night is swinging into motion, just like 37 years of nights before it.

