Online media bias is to blame for negative partisanship
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.
Political parties are failing at their job: building coalitions around ideas.
Parties today are labels held together by a common dislike of the other side, kept alive by media that gives each party its own reality.
Negative partisanship is rooted in competition. Republicans might not support everything President Donald Trump does, but they absolutely detest his Democratic rivals and their ideas, pushing them to vote for Trump anyway. This relationship goes for both parties.
Such hostility expands past simple disagreement. A 2022 survey found 72% of Republicans view Democrats as more dishonest than other Americans. Similarly, 64% of Democrats believe Republicans are more dishonest.
This divide is the result of where Americans get their information. The Pew Research Center found that trust in media outlets falls along party lines. Republicans are far more likely to trust Fox News, while Democrats trust outlets like PBS and NPR. Each group views the other’s favorite outlets with suspicion.
When people can’t agree on which information to believe, they can’t agree on what happened. This doesn’t leave room for discussion, and arguments about ideas get replaced by ones about what occurred in the first place.
The 2021 United States Capitol riots show how an event can be viewed differently between the two parties. Outlets like CNN and MSNBC described the event as insurrection, mob action or domestic terrorism. Fox News also covered the unrest but suggested left-wing conspiracies started the riot.
When every side has its own sources, commentators and versions of events, the division between parties becomes stronger than disagreement.Peyton Tapp, Columnist
Depending on where someone was getting news, they could’ve thought the riots were a protest that went too far, or evidence of a much larger political conspiracy.
This makes for an extremely difficult environment for political parties to function. They’re meant to bring people together over a shared set of ideas and goals, but when members of the same country can’t even agree on the basics, parties start to live in two different worlds.
Social media has only added fuel to this fire. People are shown information tailored to social media algorithms. Instead of seeking out news themselves, users are presented with clips similar to what they’ve already watched.
At the same time, out-of-context clips and edited videos reinforce political skepticism. People find themselves in echo chambers that reinforce their beliefs. This makes it difficult to distinguish between facts, misinformation and disinformation.
When every side has its own sources, commentators and versions of events, the division between parties becomes stronger than disagreement. It evolves into distrust and difference in what people believe is reality.
Americans shouldn’t agree on everything. Disagreeing over politics isn’t inherently a problem. A healthy democracy is full of competing ideas and productive discussions. The problem comes when Americans can’t agree on the basic information that’s needed for debate.
When facts become partisan, compromise becomes much harder, and distrust becomes second nature. If you associate your political party with who you’re against instead of what you stand for, negative partisanship becomes the norm rather than genuine political understanding.
Peyton Tapp is a junior majoring in philosophy and political science. She can be reached at petapp@syr.edu..

