Skip to content
On Campus

Panelists evaluate ‘State of Democracy’ in Maxwell lecture ahead of midterms

A virtual State of Democracy Lecture Series hosted by SU’s Maxwell School featured a discussion between professors and national journalists.
A virtual State of Democracy Lecture Series hosted by SU’s Maxwell School featured a discussion between professors and national journalists. Lars Jendruschewitz | Senior Staff Photographer

Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.

Syracuse University’s Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs held a virtual State of Democracy Lecture, hosting professors and national journalists to discuss polling numbers, states to watch and the issues driving voters to the ballot box on Nov. 3.

The event is part of the State of Democracy lecture series, supported by the Maxwell School’s Dean’s Office and co-sponsored with the Institute of Democracy, Journalism and Citizenship. Moderators included Margaret Talev, the Kramer director of INDJC, and Chris Faricy, director of the Campbell Public Affairs Institute, who began the event by posing questions surrounding the midterm election.

With the polls favoring Democrats come Election Day, the panel discussed what the United States might look like following President Donald Trump’s second term.

“We’re getting a massive test of how transferable MAGA energy is, and we know that MAGA is not a worldview or a set of policy principles,” Mike Allen, co-founder of Axios, said. “MAGA is Donald Trump, and we don’t know how transferable it is. We’re about to find out.”

Allen took Axios Senior Political Reporter Marc Caputo’s place on the panel, who left to work on a breaking news story.

Questions about how many people will vote in the upcoming election were an early topic of discussion. Only 46% of those eligible voted in the 2022 midterms.

Chris Jackson, senior vice president and civil society division lead for SSRS, broke voters down into three groups: ideological Democrats, ideological Republicans and those without strong party ties. The latter group is the one to watch, Jackson said.

“That’s really the group that Republicans are really scared about right now because it is the group that voted for Trump in 2024 because he promised to reduce prices back down to essentially 2019 levels,” Jackson said. “He’s not delivered on that.”

Kadia Goba, a political reporter for The Washington Sun, pointed to the war in Iran and spikes in gas and grocery prices as “letdowns” for Trump voters. Caputo agreed, citing those issues as ones that plague the everyday lives of Americans.

Trump’s shortcomings in lowering prices combined with the impact of the Jeffrey Epstein files have resulted in very few wins for Trump during his time in office, Caputo said. Grant Reeher, an SU political science professor, also noted domestic issues like the economy and international issues like the war in Iran and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

Across the country, Republicans are losing their grip on states like Texas and Kansas and each panelist is watching different states as indicators of where the country stands on the party’s policies.

Goba said she finds the Texas race “fascinating,” and Jackson shouted out the Florida Senate race. Reeher said he’s interested in the Michigan Senate race and Allen framed Maine as the Republicans’ last hope.

Some panelists said they don’t believe “dummymandering,” when the party in control of a state with redrawn districts loses the state election, will have an impact on the midterm results. California, Florida, Texas, Missouri, North Carolina, Tennessee and Ohio have each redrawn their districts to the advantage of the state’s controlling party, with Louisiana, Alabama and Utah’s districts redrawn due to litigation, according to a Harvard study.

Allen said Ohio is a state to watch as an indicator for the future of data centers and artificial intelligence legislation at large. Through his reporting, Allen said he spoke to many people across the country who fear AI, citing job security worries, concerns about water and environmental degradation and the general unsettling nature of the technology.

“I think that’s going to be a lot of the postgame is going to be based,” Allen said. “There’s going to be a bunch of candidates coming out who have very specific views on AI. I think that’s going to help to set the national agenda.”

Republicans’ spending choices and Trump’s travel choices, including his recent Syracuse visit, indicate that the party is extremely worried, Reeher said. There’s a shift to individual candidate support rather than party support, leading to more money coming from a large number of small donors who’ve favored Democrats this cycle, Jackson said.

“The money no longer equals a guaranteed win,” Jennifer Stromer-Galley, professor in the School of Information Studies, said. “It’s hard to predict election night and who the winners will be. That’s what makes this one kind of fun. Also, I’m sure, for some, kind of scary.”

Local elections in New York state may yield some shocking results, Goba said, as some national issues may not resonate with local audiences. In 2022, Goba found that abortion was resonating with voters around the country. New Yorkers, however, felt abortion rights were protected in their state and were more concerned about local crime. The New York Democratic Party lost four House seats that year.

In this election, Goba looks at Rep. Mike Lawler’s district and sees the “rhetoric” around communism hitting home for New York voters in that district. Jackson said a California ballot initiative about a wealth tax will be a precursor for what 2028 will bring for corporate-friendly Democrats like Gov. Gavin Newsom.

The panelists believe Trump will be on defense no matter how the midterms pan out.

“Whatever happens, (Trump) is not going to blame Donald Trump,” Allen said.

membership_button_new-10