Skip to content
Arts

Stars of Peacock sitcom ‘The Paper’ capture evolving journalism landscape

The second season of “The Paper” picks up from the success of the show’s fictional newspaper, the Toledo Truth Teller in season 1. The show highlights the dwindling state of local journalism across the country.
The second season of “The Paper” picks up from the success of the show’s fictional newspaper, the Toledo Truth Teller in season 1. The show highlights the dwindling state of local journalism across the country. Maria Masek | Contributing Illustrator

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

A sitcom about a newsroom may seem like a journalist’s dream show, but “The Paper” addresses serious concerns, like corporate oversight and digital transformation, that local newsrooms are currently facing around the United States.

“It’s really important, because these places need to stay open,” actor and writer Alex Edelman said. “But ultimately, you provide a service and you give your community a distinctive voice, and the flattening of that is really scary.”

On Oct. 8, The Daily Orange sat down with Edelman and actor Oscar Nuñez in a virtual conversation about “The Paper” and the premiere of its second season, which was released on Sept. 9. Created by Greg Daniels and Michael Koman, the show was released in 2025 as a spinoff of the critically acclaimed TV show “The Office,” which aired from 2005 to 2013.

“The Paper,” a Peacock mockumentary sitcom, follows a group of reporters at a dwindling, small-town Ohio newspaper: the Toledo Truth Teller. The second season picks up from the success of the newspaper’s accolades, when it won several awards at a state journalism award conference.

Edelman, who plays an accountant and reporter (Adam Cooper), and Nuñez, who plays the publication’s head accountant and Arts and Leisure reporter (Oscar Martinez), bring different experiences to their roles. Edelman is also a writer for the show, and Nuñez reprises his role as Martinez, the only returning character from “The Office.”

Growing up in Boston, Edelman said local and alternative newspapers were integral to his childhood — the “community-focused” newspapers are “good fodder for a comedy show,” he said.

For college journalists, Edelman said “The Paper” can teach reporters “nobility to a job that is its own reward.” The Toledo Truth Teller mirrors the struggles local newsrooms around the country face in a loss of local news publications and a shrinking news ecosystem.

However, Nuñez anticipates the show signals something positive for the state of local journalism.

“I hope they take some optimism,” Nuñez said. “I hope we serve as a win for their sales, and you know they charge into stories again.”

“The Paper” also highlights contemporary issues media outlets are facing, like corporate ownership and newspapers being bought by private equity firms. In the show, the Toledo Truth Teller is owned by media conglomerate Enervate, the same company that acquired Dunder Mifflin, the office supply company from “The Office.”

While “The Paper” and “The Office” feature a returning character and share similar story elements — Daniels was the executive producer and showrunner for “The Office” — Nuñez said the projects are two separate storylines.


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

One real-life incident sparked American High’s immersive film ‘Rolling Loud’

Liverpool’s American High’s latest movie, “Rolling Loud: The Movie,” is based on the true story of a father losing his son at the Rolling Loud music festival.


“The Paper” also shows how the media landscape has evolved over the years, looking back at the Toledo Truth Teller’s glory days when the newsroom was filled with enough reporters to investigate local issues.

“It’s a good thing, and it can only exist in a small town,” Nuñez said. “Hopefully, people will be inspired to pick up the gauntlet or keep fighting the good fight. That’s all we can do.”

The show’s love letter to journalism is a big part of what drew Edelman to star and write in “The Paper.” Edelman said the show is a reminder that print journalism is not entirely commercial.

“The position of print journalism in the world has nothing to do with the characters’ desire to make good print journalism,” Edelman said. “I think it has to do entirely with their desire to build something menschy and valuable for their community and for themselves.”

membership_button_new-10