Skip to content
City

Rep. Mannion, Buller exchange ‘robust’ ideas on CNY policies in 1st debate

Democratic incumbent Rep. John Mannion and Republican challenger Kailee Buller spoke to voters in their first debate Monday afternoon. In the debate, both challengers covered immigration, taxes and tariffs without traditional time limits.
Democratic incumbent Rep. John Mannion and Republican challenger Kailee Buller spoke to voters in their first debate Monday afternoon. In the debate, both challengers covered immigration, taxes and tariffs without traditional time limits. Courtesy of Dennis Nett | Syracuse.com

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

Democratic incumbent Rep. John Mannion and Republican challenger Kailee Buller spoke to voters on immigration, foreign conflicts and higher education in their first debate Monday afternoon.

Both candidates are vying for the 22nd Congressional District seat, which spans five counties and includes the cities of Syracuse, Auburn, Cortland and Utica.

The debate was hosted by syracuse.com in partnership with Syracuse University’s Newhouse School of Public Communications. Chris Baker, public affairs editor at syracuse.com and moderator, began the debate by clarifying it would not include traditional time limits.

“We’re looking for a robust exchange of ideas between two candidates with very different views on the operation of the federal government,” Baker said. “Today we’ll ask the candidates to engage with one another on the substance of this campaign and the issues facing the district and the nation.”

Buller opened the debate speaking about growing up in Auburn, her many job experiences and being a mother of three. Buller said she returned to central New York to make sure it has a representative citizens are proud of.

“I’m ready to be the leader of the next generation,” Buller said. “Central New York deserves better.”

Born-and-raised in Central New York, Mannion went to Washington, D.C. after years of teaching to be a “strong voice,” making sure constitutionally authorized institutions continue to do the necessary work.

Mannion said he’s proud of the work he’s done over the past two years in holding President Donald Trump’s administration accountable and delivering results to central New York. Mannion plans to continue the initiatives his office has accomplished.

Immigration

Trump’s crackdown on immigration in his second term has been controversial, with some claiming the raids and arrests are illegal. Baker said federal data shows 74% of people in the Syracuse area arrested by United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents have no criminal background.

Buller said as the former chief of staff to the secretary of the U.S. Department of Agriculture, she understands it’s necessary to find a path for people who come here for the right reasons under the wrong circumstances.

While Buller said ICE has made “tragic mistakes,” Congress has ultimately failed and must do comprehensive immigration reform. Buller said Mannion hasn’t reached across the aisle to fix the problems he talks about. She said he doesn’t practice what he preaches.

Buller said the U.S. needs to close the border and oppose defunding ICE. She said Mannion’s comment that ICE agents shouldn’t wear masks is “ironic” because he was “all for it” during the COVID-19 pandemic.

“We need ICE funding until we have a comprehensive immigration reform, which is on John Mannion’s desk,” Buller said. “He needs to work on that. He is your congressman right now.”

Mannion responded by highlighting the comprehensive package of legislation Trump “killed” because he didn’t want a political win for the Democrats. As a result, the country is stuck in a broken immigration system, he said.

Mannion said ICE is acting in an unlawful manner and needs to be defunded. During the second Trump administration, the Department of Homeland Security was allocated $190.6 billion over the 2025-2029 fiscal years through the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. ICE’s $74.9 billion portion of the funds allocated in the OBBBA was seven times greater than ICE’s annual budget at the time.

“(The administration) is providing funding for its lawless behavior, detainment facilities that are inhumane, and no real oversight on where those dollars are going when it comes to food and sanitation and rent contracts,” Mannion said.

Foreign conflicts

Mannion said the war in Iran is unwanted, unnecessary, unlawful and costly. He said it’s easy to start a war; it’s harder to end one.

“We’ve also lost American lives,” Mannion said. “We’ve lost American assets, and this is all happening while the Pentagon is kicking the press out of their press briefings because they simply do not want the truth released.”

He said Iran is now in a more leveraged position as they control the Strait of Hormuz and that the recent incident of bombers in the United Kingdom is cause for concern. Mannion said preventing Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon is crucial, but noted that Trump didn’t come to Congress seeking authority, nor did he build a coalition of allies.

Buller agreed with Mannion, saying she wants to make it “extremely clear” she is not a fan of the war and doesn’t want to see a long-term effort. She said she’s unhappy with the price of gas and how much people are struggling, making it clear she’s not “a rubber stamp” for the president.

Buller said Mannion’s record on Israel is inconsistent, citing his acceptance of campaign funds from pro-Israel PACs but later voting to defund Israel and continue funding Ukraine.

She said she knows of many Jewish leaders throughout the central New York community who are “beside themselves” that Mannion has left them behind. Buller said she’s “extremely concerned” about Gaza and October 7.

“A two-state solution isn’t possible or viable. That’s been tried, and it’s not even an option at this point,” Buller said. “We have to take this threat seriously, and we have to continue funding Israel at this point.”

Mannion said it’s a complex issue and while Israel is an American ally, it doesn’t excuse the over-response from the Israeli government and the “atrocious devastation” in Gaza.

He said the answer to this complex problem is a two-state solution that involves international oversight and American leadership, allowing Palestinians to have autonomy rather than be ruled by a terrorist organization.

Additionally, Mannion said he doesn’t think the role of higher education is to boycott Israel and said doing so can bleed into a surge in antisemitism.

“We have students here at Syracuse University that are Israeli citizens,” Mannion said. “I don’t think that those students that came here as part of educational and cultural exchange programs should be banned from attending our universities.”

Higher education

Buller attended SU for one year but couldn’t afford to return for a second, adding that she finished paying off her SU loans about five years ago. After college, she said she had to move away from New York state in order to find a job and doesn’t want that to happen to others.

“I was devastated when I left this incredible school. But I could not afford it,” Buller said. “We have a whole generation of kids who are saddled in debt and their skill set doesn’t match what the job opportunities are.”

Buller said she wants SU students to know she sees them and has been in their situation. She said she wants students to fully understand debt and their career path options, aiming to prioritize transparency from universities and parents.

“I don’t have all the answers. I don’t care what political party you’re with,” Buller said. “Everyone deserves to have the same services and the same help.”

Mannion said he wants young people to have opportunities for home ownership, so everybody can meet their “American dream.” He also said what’s important to young people is sometimes hard for older people to understand, which is why his campaign and official team have a “robust” representation of young people.

He spoke directly about the budget cuts SU and other universities are facing, adding that he directly opposes the cuts that “came with the indirect costs for research.” Mannion said he spoke with researchers at the University of Rochester who have been in the U.S. for over 15 years and found when research cuts are made and followed by changes to immigration policy, those researchers end up leaving the country.

“I hate to see that,” Mannion said. “This is what makes the country what it is. Our research, our innovation, we’re a leader.”

Looking forward

Throughout the debate, Buller criticized Mannion’s policies and behavior in Congress, arguing he’s too partisan to effectively lead.

When questions were raised about Buller’s stance on Trump, she said her relationship with the Trump administration would only be advantageous in representing the 22nd district.

“If you’re not at the table, you’re on the menu,” Buller said.

Buller said Mannion’s relationships with politicians across party lines aren’t strong enough.

Buller has accepted Trump’s endorsement and showed support for New York Gubernatorial Candidate Bruce Blakeman.

Mannion said truth and positive conduct as an elected official are critical. He explained he’s never talked negatively about his opponent and only contradicts mistruths and exaggerations.

He said several Republicans have thanked him for his representation and for pushing back against the Trump administration’s “unlawful and unconstitutional actions.” Mannion said he works with Republicans all the time, including ranking members of his committee.

Both candidates said they were thankful for the opportunity to speak to voters.

Buller said she’s a candidate who has a proven track record of bringing down costs, lower taxes, lower energy prices and is running for the right reasons. Mannion said it’s an honor to represent the place he loves and be the best reflection of the district he can be.

Mannion and Buller will face again in an Oct. 22 debate hosted by News Channel 9.

membership_button_new-10