SU faculty condemn ‘systemic attacks’ on education at Banned Book Week panel
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.
Syracuse University Libraries and the College of Arts & Sciences’ Department of English held a Tuesday panel discussing the pressures academic freedom faces, part of SU Libraries’ annual Banned Book Week.
The panel, titled Academic Freedom Under Pressure, included three SU faculty members: Roy Gutterman, director of the Tully Center for Free Speech and professor in the Newhouse School of Public Communications, Thomas Keck, political science professor and Michael O. Sawyer chair of constitutional law and politics, and Tom Perreault, professor in the Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs.
Patricia Giles, reference and instruction librarian at SU Libraries and event co-planner, said the event was sparked by an incident at Texas A&M University. Martin Peterson, a philosophy professor at Texas A&M, was told by university administrators to remove certain Plato excerpts and other material on race and gender ideology.
Panelists opened the conversation by defining the difference between academic freedom and freedom of speech. Perreault said he feels it’s important to differentiate between the two terms when discussing academic freedom because they can be easily confused.
“There are certain things that I can say that would be protected under First Amendment protections that are not necessarily protected under academic freedom,” Perrault said.
Perrault described academic freedom as the ability to teach and do research “without fear of reprisal or punishment based on your views,” citing the American Association of University Professors’ 1940 statement as “the original source book.”
Although academic freedom isn’t synonymous with the First Amendment, Perrault pointed out the legal precedent that academic freedom is protected under the First Amendment. He cited the 1967 Supreme Court case Keyishian v. Board of Regents, which struck down a New York law prohibiting the state from hiring employees it labeled “seditious.”
Gutterman also spoke about the legal precedent of academic freedom in America, referencing the 1957 Supreme Court case Sweezy v. New Hampshire. He said the case was an important protector of academic freedom in an era of laws targeting “subversives” during the United States Red Scare.
Gutterman also quoted Supreme Court Justice William J. Brennan Jr.’s majority opinion from Keyishian v. Board of Regents, which reads “The classroom is peculiarly the ‘marketplace of ideas.’ The nation’s future depends on leaders trained through wide exposure to that robust exchange of ideas.”
Keck’s perspective focused on the modern difficulties education faces due to pressure from outside institutions. He acknowledged book banning has a long history in the U.S., but the level of censorship in education today is concerning.
“There’s been these waves of book bans where some new, controversial ideas are being written about and people kind of go crazy, but if we’re banning Plato from university classrooms, I think we’ve really jumped the rails,” Keck said.
Keck also spoke about “systemic attacks” on ideas like gender studies, critical race theory and historical teachings of racism in the U.S.
“Some of the stuff that’s being made illegal in Texas and Florida, I was teaching this morning,” Keck said.
Keck described the threats against academic freedom in the U.S. as “egregiously over the top,” again referencing Texas A&M’s attempt to ban teaching Plato in a philosophy class. He said he feels the threats are “obviously” against the principles of academic freedom.
Katherine Kidd, Arts & Sciences professor and co-planner of Banned Book Week, said she feels the goals of institutions threatening academic freedom are rooted in normative white supremacy.
“I think the goal is to use their power to enforce white supremacy and to silence and make life unlivable for people who aren’t mainstream normal,” Kidd said. “The majority of books that are banned are banned because of references to racism and racial injustice and references to non-normative gender and sexuality.”
Gutterman also commented on the modern examples of academic pressure. He said politicising the classroom is part of the “nature of politics” but is also a “scary thing.”
Maxwell Professor Catherine Herrold asked the panelists if they were concerned about academic freedom from the perspective of students or faculty with right wing beliefs of “self-censoring” because they felt their opinions weren’t welcome on campus.
Perrault acknowledged threats from all angles must be taken seriously but said he doesn’t like the “right-left binary” because it’s a very “U.S. way” to think about politics.
Keck said he’s skeptical about calls for viewpoint diversity on campus and that people have to be careful about false equivalents. He referenced the aftermath of Charlie Kirk’s assasination in 2025, which resulted in over 600 U.S. colleges and university employees being fired or punished for social media posts. Keck said there’s been no equivalent consequence for right-wing university faculty.
“There’s been lots of credible claims of self-censorship by conservatives on campuses where they perceive their views are in the minority,” Keck said. “But that’s not the same thing as being fired for a social media post.”
Keck said there’s skepticism about how courts will handle current academic freedom and free speech cases, including President Trump’s multi-billion dollar legal cases against Harvard University, Florida’s Stop W.O.K.E. Act and AAUP v. Rubio, a case concerning deporting pro-Palestinian international students. However, he said he still believes the courts will act as “effective and reliable guardrails” for these protections as they previously have.
“I’m reasonably optimistic that federal courts are gonna protect free speech and academic freedom in all three of those cases,” Keck said.

