Syracuse forced to use 4th-string quarterback in road defeat to Virginia
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe to our sports newsletter here.
CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va. — Even if Fran Brown didn’t show it, he knew the feeling too well.
It’s the cusp of midnight at Scott Stadium. Rain pours onto the metal bleachers around the venue. Most of them are empty now. The game ended almost an hour ago.
Yet Brown sits in a closet-sized room deep in the belly of the stadium, his hands outstretched in front of a microphone lined with ‘Block S’ logos. It’s time to answer some more of the same questions. Because Syracuse keeps making people ask the same questions. The penalties, the kicking game, the recurrent Atlantic Coast Conference losses and the quarterback.
Of course, the quarterback.
Since Kyle McCord graduated in 2024, Brown hasn’t enjoyed a lick of stability at quarterback. Steve Angeli showed promise before tearing his Achilles, which drastically derailed the 2025 season. Angeli didn’t quite look like himself through three weeks in 2026, so backup Amari Odom took over versus UConn. Odom looked like SU’s QB1 but suffered a shoulder injury that made him a game-time decision against Virginia Saturday.
Brown ultimately turned to third-stringer Malachi Nelson. He gave the Orange enough to have a shot, but then he got hurt. So when the Orange had a chance to embark on a game-winning drive in the final minute, the guy helming the offense hadn’t played a snap at the Football Bowl Subdivision level — Georgetown transfer Danny Lauter. It led to Syracuse’s (2-3, 0-3 ACC) narrow 28-25 loss to the Cavaliers (4-2, 2-1 ACC) Saturday night.
So Brown was asked about it. How does it feel to be doing this again? To have four quarterbacks bouncing back and forth with no certainty.
He shrugged. “It’s part of life.”
But that life isn’t one Syracuse can keep living. Not if it has any hopes of making a bowl game this season, and certainly not if it has any hopes of creating lasting success under Brown.
This year, though, Brown prepared for it. After Angeli’s injury and the ensuing fiasco, Brown said his biggest takeaway was the need for backup quarterbacks. So he went and got Odom — who led Kennesaw State to 10 wins last season — and Nelson, a former five-star recruit who saw playing time at three Division I programs.
The plan seemed foolproof until it wasn’t. After getting the starting nod over a banged-up Angeli, Odom looked like the hero Syracuse needed, totaling six touchdowns against UConn. But throughout the week, Odom appeared on the injury report. First he was questionable. Then doubtful. Then a game-time decision.
Postgame Saturday, Brown said Odom sustained a shoulder injury against the Huskies. He practiced all week but “could never lift (his arm) up completely.”
“Something might be torn or something of that nature in his shoulder,” Brown said. “Gotta see where that’s all at.”
Brown added Odom had an MRI this week but didn’t elaborate on the results. Odom still dressed fully, participated in warmups and even went to the 50-yard line for the coin toss. But Brown didn’t think he was ready to go.
“Just wanted to make sure he could completely protect himself,” Brown said. “I just didn’t feel comfortable enough with him doing that.”
The logical next step would’ve been Angeli, but Syracuse’s Week 1 starter was ruled out well before Odom. Brown said Saturday that Angeli got a platelet-rich plasma shot to the Achilles tendon he tore last season, and he was in a boot all evening Saturday.
So, Nelson was next up. He looked the part of a former five-star in the first half, leading a quick touchdown drive on his first opportunity. He hit Noah Meyers for 29 yards to set up a one-yard Ahmad Miller touchdown run on fourth down.
Syracuse quarterback Malachi Nelson takes a snap in SU’s 28-25 loss to Virginia Saturday. It was Nelson’s first start with the Orange. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor
“I thought he did a good job,” Brown said of Nelson. “He’s a good football player.”
On the next drive, Nelson uncorked a 51-yard bomb to Umari Hatcher, then went back to Hatcher a few plays later for a 13-yard score in the back of the end zone. Nelson primarily managed the game with handoffs and mid-to-intermediate throws, but he did his job. He threw for 217 yards and a touchdown with no turnovers. He helped the Orange to a 17-7 lead at halftime.
In other words, he gave Syracuse a chance to win.
But as the game started slipping late with 21 unanswered Cavaliers points, Nelson took a beating. After a handoff to Ju’Juan Johnson, he absorbed a shot to the chest. On the next snap, Lauter was in the game. Brown said postgame that Nelson was pulled due to a collarbone injury.
So Lauter, a fifth-year in his first season at the FBS level, tried to spark Syracuse. He did so with a miracle 46-yard touchdown pass to Daunte Bacheyie, a play where Lauter lofted the ball deep into the secondary. A UVA defensive back camped under it, waiting for it to drop like a snowflake. Instead, Bacheiye plucked it away and ran the distance.
Syracuse suddenly had life, and after a defensive stop, had a final shot to escape with a win. Inside its own red zone, Lauter took four snaps from the shotgun. A deep ball that should’ve been intercepted. Then another deep ball that should’ve been intercepted. Then a four-yard checkdown. Then a deep ball batted away.
All Brown and Lauter could do was watch as Virginia took back over in victory formation.
The scene was strange. If you told Brown five weeks ago he’d watch his fourth-string quarterback try to lead a game-winning drive in a potential make-or-break conference contest, he’d call you crazy. Either that, or he’d wish you were joking.
But that’s his reality now. Again. And there’s not much he and Syracuse can do about it.
“Gotta get ready,” he said postgame. “Have Danny ready.”

