Beat writers predict whether Syracuse can earn 1st ACC win vs. Louisville
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe to our sports newsletter here.
Syracuse is in disarray, so much so that it’s unclear who will start at quarterback in its upcoming matchup with Louisville. Steve Angeli, Amari Odom and Malachi Nelson all entered the week with injury designations.
SU is coming off a 28-25 loss to Virginia, where it squandered a double-digit first-half lead for the second straight week. But this time, it cost the Orange. Third-stringer Nelson got the start and finished with 217 yards and one touchdown before being pulled for injury.
The quarterback situation isn’t a great sign entering the Orange’s toughest game yet. Syracuse faces a Louisville team that recently dropped two unranked matchups but got back on track with a dominant win over Florida State last weekend.
The Cardinals have one of the best offenses in the conference but have a defense SU can exploit, no matter who’s under center.
Here’s how our beat writers think Syracuse (2-3, 0-3 Atlantic Coast) will do against Louisville (3-3, 2-2 ACC) Saturday:
Noah Nussbaum (4-1)
Slippery slope
Louisville 35, Syracuse 21
I’ll be honest, this game is tough to predict with Syracuse’s quarterback fiasco. Odom will be a no-go after he was ruled out on Wednesday with a shoulder tear. Angeli is the most likely to play after it was revealed Tuesday that he, Danny Lauter and Zaid Lott were the only quarterbacks to run drills in practice. But as we’ve seen the last two weeks with late quarterback announcements, anything can happen.
Based on recent success, I think Nelson starting gives the Orange the best chance to win. His start against Virginia looked better than either of Angeli’s ACC starts, where he tossed five interceptions in two games.
But it doesn’t look like he’ll be available despite being questionable on Wednesday’s ACC injury report, and SU might be forced to turn to fourth-string Lauter again. Lauter did chuck a 46-yard touchdown after entering in the fourth quarter against UVA, but he also failed to even get one first down on the ensuing series, which ended the game. I don’t have much faith in Syracuse winning if he starts.
Either way, I’m picking Louisville — whichever quarterback starts would only change how much I think SU will lose by. The Cardinals are the most potent offense the Orange have faced yet, averaging nearly 40 points per game, and I don’t see Syracuse stopping Lincoln Kienholz, Isaac Brown and Co. enough for its offense to keep up. Even with Odom at his full potential, Syracuse eked out an overtime win over UConn.
I wrote before the Virginia game about the importance of that matchup and this week’s versus Louisville in changing the program’s direction. From the looks of it, SU is headed down a slippery slope back to irrelevancy. A win against the Cardinals can change that, but I don’t see it happening.
Nicholas Alumkal (4-1)
QB quandary
Louisville 38, Syracuse 21
Here we go again.
For the second year and the third game in a row, Syracuse has a quarterback quandary. There is no clarity on who’ll start versus Louisville Saturday. You have to credit Brown for bolstering the QB room in the offseason; the Orange have just had rotten injury luck this season. But when your third-string Nelson and fourth-choice signal-caller Lauter nearly lead you to a road ACC win, you have to give them credit.
Yet, that wasn’t a win. The word “nearly” carried a lot of weight in that previous sentence — almost as much weight as the stupendous Umari Hatcher has carried in the Orange’s receiving game. SU is still 0-3 in conference play, and now the promising Nelson is injured. So if you’re heading to the JMA Wireless Dome this Saturday, make sure to bring your sneakers and a helmet — you might just get called upon under center.
In all seriousness — which is hard to be with the risible lacklusterness of this team — the realistic options to throw the ball for the Orange are the previously benched Angeli, Lauter and freshman Lott. That won’t cut it against the Cardinals, who are in the upper echelon of the ACC. Yes, UL allows the second-most points per game in the conference, but it also scores the second-most.
Whoever pilots the Orange’s offense, I don’t trust him to keep up with a dynamic Louisville squad with a capable quarterback in Kienholz. And with SU’s intractable field-goal-kicking woes, points will be left on the board. Oh, and don’t forget about Syracuse’s nation-high penalties per game. If that carries over to a sixth game, it won’t help the Orange’s hopes.
The Cardinals will cruise. Syracuse will lose.
Harris Pemberton (4-1)
Cardinal win
Louisville 31, Syracuse 16
Very, very few things are certain about this Syracuse football team right now.
The Orange still don’t have a kicker who can consistently make field goals; they’re still making hoards of mistakes in the second half and, for all we know, could be starting a fifth-year FCS transfer this weekend.
If Brown’s Monday presser and Wednesday’s injury report are truly a tell-all, then the Orange have three quarterbacks who could start Saturday. And, based on how he’s handled the last few weeks, he probably won’t show his hand until game day. Or even the first drive of the contest.
These days, the one thing that feels like a guarantee is that Syracuse will lose an ACC game, as it’s now lost 10 in a row dating back to last September. It’s certainly gotten close this year, with three-point losses to both Cal and Virginia. You could look at the positives, sure — the Orange defense looked sharp at points in both of those games, and against Virginia, SU schemed up a great first half for Nelson, who looked sharp in his first Power Four start.
But the bottom line is that SU led by double digits in both of those contests and snatched defeat from the jaws of victory. And even though this Louisville team certainly doesn’t look as strong as it did a few weeks ago, Syracuse hasn’t shown me enough to believe it can get back in the win column at home. Each step of progress for SU recently seems to come with two steps back.
If Angeli or Nelson can go for Syracuse, I think it has a shot. But again, the Orange haven’t shown they won’t fall into the same mistakes week in and week out. So it’ll be a Cardinal win at the Dome Saturday.

