Skip to content
Football

Observations from Syracuse’s loss to UVA: Nelson starts, Cavs comeback

Malachi Nelson got his first start at quarterback for Syracuse and managed the Orange offense well, yet SU crumbled late in a 28-25 loss to Virginia.
Malachi Nelson got his first start at quarterback for Syracuse and managed the Orange offense well, yet SU crumbled late in a 28-25 loss to Virginia. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe to our sports newsletter here.

CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va. — From the jump, Saturday night didn’t have the makings of the statement win Syracuse so badly needed. The Orange had lost nine straight Atlantic Coast Conference games, faced a Virginia squad that had lost just one of its last 10 home games and SU rolled off the bus at Scott Stadium not knowing who’d start at quarterback.

It’d either be Amari Odom, SU’s hero against UConn, who dealt with an injury throughout the week, or Malachi Nelson, the third-stringer who hadn’t started a Power Four game in his career.

Either way, Syracuse needed a spark. Otherwise, its campaign would begin with three straight conference losses. In other words, a death sentence if the Orange wanted anything more than a low-level bowl appearance this season.

Nelson gave Syracuse a solid outing, but the Orange again lost a double-digit lead in the second half. Here are some observations from Syracuse’s (2-3, 0-3 ACC) 28-25 loss to Virginia (4-2, 2-1 ACC) Saturday:

Another QB surprise

About fifteen minutes before kickoff last Saturday, Fran Brown publicly announced his decision to start Odom against UConn, days after voicing his faith in Steve Angeli. Odom exploded for 335 passing yards and six total touchdowns in the win over the Huskies, seemingly cementing his spot as SU’s QB1.

But Odom dealt with some arm and shoulder soreness throughout the week, relegating him to questionable status and ultimately doubtful in Friday’s injury report. ESPN reported Nelson would start for SU Saturday, although Odom was labeled a game-time decision.

Nelson ultimately got the start, the third different quarterback to start a game in SU’s past three contests. Nelson finished the day with 217 passing yards and one passing touchdown.

Odom led the Orange through warmups and even appeared at the coin toss at midfield. But Nelson trotted out with the offense on SU’s opening possession, ultimately leading a 75-yard drive that Ahmad Miller capped with a one-yard touchdown run.

Syracuse primarily used Nelson as a game manager early on, prioritizing short throws and handoffs. But Nelson got to show off the arm a bit with a 51-yard completion to Umari Hatcher in the second quarter, which set up a 13-yard touchdown from Nelson to Hatcher, giving SU a 14-7 lead.

Nelson had a modest outing aside from that drive, not making any significant mistakes but not necessarily changing the game, either. He did enough to give the Orange a shot Saturday. They just couldn’t capitalize.

Cavs come roaring back

To win Saturday night, Syracuse needed to stop the run. Virginia entered the contest averaging 162 rushing yards per game, a top-eight mark in the ACC. Part of what made that a difficult task was quarterback Beau Pribula’s mobility and the transfer’s ability to throw the ball outside the pocket.

Just looking at the first-half box score, though, you would never think Pribula provided much of a threat. The Orange held him to just 38 passing yards, while holding UVA to 117 total yards of offense. Yet, Virginia’s offense came alive late, spoiling SU’s chance at a road win.

UVA marched 75 yards in eight plays to open the game, scoring on a Xay Davis run. But after the score, Syracuse held it to just 42 total yards of first-half offense.

Syracuse forced a three-and-out on the Cavaliers’ first drive of the second half, although Virginia finally broke through with a 43-yard touchdown from Pribula to Da’Shawn Martin two drives later.

That flipped a switch in its offense. Pribula found a rhythm after the Orange punted on the following drive, marching UVA 73 yards in seven plays and taking the lead on a three-yard touchdown run from Jekail Middlebrook. And after SU turned the ball over on a fourth-down punt right after, Middlebrook put the nail in the coffin with a five-yard score.

Kicking conundrum

Syracuse hasn’t had any sort of consistency at kicker this season. Initial starter Tripp Woody missed two kicks against Cal on Sept. 12 and was benched against Pitt on Sept. 17 after shanking another. Freshman Shay Barker took over against the Panthers and looked strong, nailing all three of his kicks.

Yet Barker’s season hasn’t been smooth since. The freshman went 0-for-2 on field goals against UConn and missed an extra point. He continued to struggle against Virginia, going 1-for-3 on field goals.

Barker’s two misses came from 47 and 41 yards, respectively. The first missed wide left, preventing the Orange from capitalizing on solid field position after forcing a punt. The second stalled a six-play, 69-yard drive to begin the second half.

Barker’s make came on a 29-yarder in the waning moments of the first half, giving the Orange a two-possession lead. But it didn’t last. And in a game Syracuse lost by single digits, it needed those extra six points.

The penalty war

Syracuse shot itself in the foot several times throughout its first four games of the season. The Orange had the most penalty yards per game in the country with over 100, 15 more than UTSA in second. On Saturday, the Orange got some key penalties in their favor but still made some mistakes late that hurt their chances.

Virginia committed five penalties for 65 yards, while Syracuse had nine for 65.

In the second quarter, three UVA penalties on third downs set up a Barker field goal. First, a roughing the passer call moved SU from its own 33-yard line to the 48. On the ensuing third down, Nelson trotted out of bounds well short of the sticks but was blasted by UVA’s Jacobie Henderson, prompting another 15-yard unsportsmanlike conduct call.

The Cavaliers committed another penalty in the red zone, this time a 15-yard pass interference call that gave the Orange a first down at the 11-yard line. SU couldn’t turn it into six but managed three valuable points at the end of the half.

Syracuse fell apart late, though, as the Cavaliers took the lead. A targeting call on David Omopariola pushed them down to SU’s 6-yard line in the fourth quarter, ultimately resulting in Middlebrook’s go-ahead score.

The Orange committed seven penalties in the second half alone, costing them 45 yards.

banned-books-01