Skip to content
football

Orange grades: RBs star, WRs stay sharp in overtime win at North Carolina

Umari Hatcher finished with 103 yards on four receptions in Syracuse's win over UNC on Saturday. Hatcher and Calvin Russell III led the receiving unit as SU earned its first ACC win of the year.
Umari Hatcher finished with 103 yards on four receptions in Syracuse's win over UNC on Saturday. Hatcher and Calvin Russell III led the receiving unit as SU earned its first ACC win of the year. Tara Deluca | Photo Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

When everyone around the program desperately needed it, Syracuse picked the perfect time to deliver.

On the heels of an 11-game Atlantic Coast Conference losing streak, the Orange prevailed over North Carolina on Saturday night, erasing a double-digit deficit to capture a 31-30 overtime victory. It’s SU’s first ACC win since September 2025 and brings the Orange to 5-0 in overtime games under head coach Fran Brown.

Here are grades from each position group’s performance in the pivotal win:

Quarterback: A-

It’s been a tumultuous season for Steve Angeli. He began the year as SU’s sure-fire starter after an Achilles injury kept him out for the final eight games of the 2025 campaign. Angeli looked sharp in the season opener against New Hampshire but threw five interceptions across his next two games, leading to his benching against Pitt.

That began the revolving door of SU quarterbacks in October, with Amari Odom starting against UConn before his shoulder injury led Malachi Nelson to start against Virginia and Louisville.

Yet on Saturday, Angeli may have solidified the spot again — even if injuries mean the Orange don’t have many other options now. Angeli threw for 256 yards and two touchdowns — including the overtime touchdown and game-winning two-point conversion. And perhaps most importantly, Angeli didn’t throw an interception for the first time in ACC play this season.

Running back: A

As Brown put it postgame, Syracuse’s running backs were “amazing” Saturday night. As a team, the Orange ran for 199 yards and two touchdowns, which kept them afloat early.

Ahmad Miller turned in his best performance in a Syracuse uniform, taking 31 carries — a single-game season-high for any SU running back — for 128 yards and a score. Tylik Hill also got nine carries for 35 yards and a touchdown. Ju’Juan Johnson contributed, too, with five carries for 38 yards, including a clutch 25-yarder on an early fourth-and-1 attempt.

Receiver/Tight end: A

At this point in the season, everybody is beginning to realize how great a talent Umari Hatcher is out wide for Syracuse. He’s taken the reins at WR1 among SU’s largely unproven group. That was evident with his monster days against UConn and Louisville.

But after the past two contests, it seems Syracuse has found its true No. 2 option, too, and his name is Calvin Russell III.

Hatcher totaled four receptions for 103 yards and a touchdown, including a 76-yard reception from Angeli in the fourth quarter. Russell nabbed a career-high eight passes for 86 yards and the game-winning touchdown and two-point conversion. Russell said he asked for the ball in the clutch, and he delivered.

Overall, SU receivers totaled 256 receiving yards and two touchdowns, with Hatcher and Russell pulling most of the weight.

Offensive line: A-

Syracuse’s offensive line has recently struggled, but the numbers suggest Saturday was its best performance in ACC play thus far.

The Orange O-line paved the way for a solid day on the ground, helping Miller and Co. to 199 rushing yards. They also kept Angeli pretty safe in the backfield, limiting the Tar Heels to just one sack.

Left tackle Trevion Mack stood out in pass protection. Pro Football Focus gave Mack an 89.5 pass-blocking grade, as he didn’t allow a single pressure Saturday. That’s a major improvement from last week versus Louisville, when Mack posted a 29.8 pass-blocking grade.

Defensive line: B

Syracuse’s defensive line wasn’t incredibly active in the pass rush Saturday, sacking UNC quarterback Billy Edwards Jr. just once. But the Orange were effective at limiting the run. North Carolina mustered just 101 rushing yards on 25 attempts.

SU also totaled three tackles for loss and 21 pressures in the win.

Linebackers: B+

Like the defensive line, Syracuse’s linebackers turned in a solid performance Saturday. Chris D’Appolonia accounted for one of Syracuse’s two sacks and tied for the team lead with eight total tackles on the day. Zyian Moultrie-Goddard also had eight tackles and a pass breakup.

Secondary: B-

Syracuse didn’t defend the pass particularly well Saturday, allowing 271 passing yards to a North Carolina offense that threw 44 passes.

Chris Peal, Demetres Samuel Jr. and Nazir Ward each allowed five receptions and 43, 35 and 72 receiving yards, respectively. Davien Kerr continued his strong campaign from the slot, conceding two catches for 19 yards on three targets.

Peal had an interception negated by an offside penalty in the second quarter, so the Orange secondary didn’t create any turnovers.

Special teams: C-

For a while, Saturday’s contest had all the makings of a key get-right game for SU kicker Shay Barker, who’s had a rocky campaign thus far. Barker made his first two extra points and his first field goal attempt but shanked a go-ahead extra point with two minutes left. It would’ve won the Orange the game without reaching overtime.

Ultimately, it didn’t cost SU the victory, but it’s still a mistake that can’t happen in the seventh game of the season. Especially not when the margins are as slim as they have been for Syracuse.

Otherwise, punter Jimmy Gregg had a solid day, booting three punts for an average of 45.3 yards and a long of 54.

Coaching: B+

Considering Syracuse is undefeated in five overtime games under Brown, it’s clear SU’s head coach knows how to win tight games. Part of that philosophy has been his willingness to take game-altering risks in the extra period.

Both Saturday against UNC and against UConn on Oct. 3, Brown elected to go for two instead of sending the game to another overtime after scoring a touchdown. Despite a controversial ending Saturday, it worked both times. So Brown deserves some major kudos for taking the risk and having it work consistently.

The only thing knocking this grade is Syracuse’s penalties — again. It wasn’t SU’s most egregious day, by any means, as the Orange committed seven penalties for 65 yards. But again, it cost SU a turnover in the first half and still is a major recurring issue.

Overall, though, Brown and the Orange did enough to win Saturday. And right now, that’s all that really matters.

banned-books-01