Syracuse collapses at Virginia 28-25 en route to 3rd ACC loss
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe to our sports newsletter here.
CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va. — Syracuse was playing better than anyone could’ve imagined. It had an unexpected quarterback under center, dealing deep, accurate passes and building an early multi-score lead. It looked well on its way to a comfortable and composed victory.
Then, the Orange got bit by their own bug. Field goal self-immolation left points on the board. Penalties seeped into their game. SU’s defense went from vice-tight at the line of scrimmage and the secondary — meeting at the quarterback with abandon — to being looser than a screen door in a hurricane.
Stop me if you’ve heard this story before — maybe even seven days ago.
SU survived a 27-0 UConn run to vanquish the Huskies in overtime on Oct. 3 behind surprise starter Amari Odom’s six touchdowns. Saturday, with Odom ruled doubtful and then a game-time decision, third-stringer Malachi Nelson played above par in the first half, building a 10-point Orange lead. Yet SU faltered in the second half, giving up 21 unanswered points.
Syracuse (2-3, 0-3 Atlantic Coast) had no miraculous comeback Saturday in Charlottesville, losing 28-25 to Virginia (4-2, 2-1 ACC). Nelson threw for 217 yards and a touchdown but exited with a shoulder or collarbone injury, SU head coach Fran Brown said. In his place, fourth-string Georgetown transfer Danny Lauter threw a touchdown to keep it interesting before tossing three incompletions on a potential game-winning drive.
So, despite allowing only one sack, having no turnovers and outgaining UVA 430-288, the Orange’s search for a first conference win extends past 385 days and 10 games.
“Our guys fight. We just got to keep fighting a little bit more,” Brown said postgame. “Try to get a couple more points than they had. They won just from a tough football game. They came out the second half and truly established the run, and it was good. It was a good, hard, tough game.”
The Orange thought they had the answer at quarterback when Odom piloted them to victory at UConn after Steve Angeli threw five interceptions in three games. But in that win over the Huskies, Brown said Odom suffered a shoulder injury, got an MRI and couldn’t lift his right throwing shoulder all week.
“Something might be torn,” Brown said of Odom’s injury.
“(We) just want to make sure he could completely protect himself,” Brown said of his decision not to play Odom. “Just didn’t feel comfortable enough with him doing that and just didn’t want to look ahead and fall on his shoulder.”
So, Nelson stepped up to start Saturday. And the former five-star 2023 recruit at his fourth school impressed early. Nelson held his own on the Orange’s first drive, shrewdly dropping a 29-yard pass to Noah Meyers to put SU on UVA’s 5-yard line. The drive ended in a touchdown.
The second Syracuse drive also led to a touchdown. Umari Hatcher, coming off three touchdowns last week, led the Orange’s airborne success with 126 yards. He hauled in a 51-yard pass and beat the defender to the square, like a kid cheating at checkers, for a touchdown grab.
The Orange’s defense stalled UVA’s offense and quarterback Beau Pribula, forcing three punts to end the first half. SU’s defensive effort was largely without former Freshman All-American Antoine Deslauriers, whose absence was “personal,” Brown said.
“Focus and finishing in the second half and continuing to carry the momentum that we built in the first half,” SU linebacker Chris D’Appolonia said of the defense postgame.
After throwing 142 yards in the first half, Nelson managed a mere 75 in the second half. His day ended when he fell to the turf with Syracuse trailing 28-17 with under four minutes left.
Lauter came in and found Daunte Bacheyie for a touchdown and Justus Ross-Simmons for a two-point conversion, making it a three-point game. But Lauter couldn’t produce a first down when the Orange had the ball with just over a minute to play.
For the second straight season, the Orange quarterback position has resembled the Spın̈al Tap drummer’s stool, its occupants disappearing with doom and damage soon after taking the spot.
Brown emphasized replenishing the room in the offseason after the Orange lost eight straight games when Angeli suffered an Achilles tear in 2025. Angeli promised he fully recovered from the tear to start the season. But he was out Saturday and is unavailable for “another week or so” because of a platelet-rich plasma shot to the Achilles tendon he tore last year to aid his recovery, Brown said.
Now, SU’s signal-caller depth will be tested.
“It’s part of life, it’s part of the game,” Brown said. “You got to get ready. So just get ready for Danny as we move on.”
Syracuse’s quarterback drama did produce commendable results for a stretch Saturday. Hatcher stressed his trust in any signal-caller, saying receivers take practice reps with all quarterbacks.
“We got our starting quarterback, but we still would take some reps with the secondary guys just to get them in motion, just to feel it,” Hatcher said postgame Saturday.
It doesn’t matter who’s throwing the ball; Hatcher said he just has to catch it.
Despite dominating for most of the game, SU’s same issues surfaced Saturday. Freshman kicker Shay Barker missed two field goals, pushing his season conversion mark to 3-for-7.
“It’s tough,” Brown said of Syracuse’s kicking. “Two tough field goals missed again. It’s similar to what went down in our last game. They’re young kids. I feel for those guys.”
Freshman punter Jimmy Gregg also ended a detrimental fourth-quarter turnover on downs when his knee touched the ground trying to field an errant snap.
The Orange, who held the most penalties per game in the FBS, played clean in the first half with just two flags. They committed seven in the second.
Virginia broke a spell of five punts on six drives to score three straight touchdowns. Pribula and the Cavalier running game got going. SU had no answer. Again.
“Just continue to keep playing,” D’Appolonia said of the defense. “It’s something that we’ve struggled with in the second half the past couple weeks and something that we got to continue to focus on moving forward.
Different week, different quarterbacks, same second-half collapse, same struggles. Most of all, the same result for Syracuse — a third conference loss.
“We’ll be fine,” Brown insisted. “Just gotta go talk to them and keep going. I think the (head coaching) job is hard, whether it’s losing or winning. It’s all still a tough job. But I signed up for it, and we’ll make sure that we keep fighting.”

