Skip to content
Ice Hockey

SU ice hockey upsets No. 4 Penn State 5-4 in OT for 1st time since 2024

Syracuse upset No. 4 Penn State 5-4 in overtime Friday. The back-and-forth affair marked SU's first win over PSU in nearly 1,000 days.
Syracuse upset No. 4 Penn State 5-4 in overtime Friday. The back-and-forth affair marked SU's first win over PSU in nearly 1,000 days. Kaitlyn Galeazzi | Staff Photographer

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe to our sports newsletter here.

On Jan. 19, 2024, Syracuse defeated Penn State 3-1 at Pegula Ice Arena in State College, Pennsylvania.

It was a seemingly normal win, bringing the all-time series to 31-11-8 in favor of the Orange. Earning wins against the Nittany Lions weren’t special; they were expected.

What makes that win special, though, was that it was Syracuse’s last win against PSU for nearly three years. In that time, Penn State beat the Orange 11 straight times. These games weren’t close, including an 11-2 drubbing in Happy Valley last November.

So when Syracuse faced Penn State Friday for the first time under Brian Idalski, it seemed it’d be more of the same. Just another loss against a team that’s had the Orange’s number for years.

But in a back-and-forth affair, Syracuse (4-1-0, 2-1-0 Atlantic Hockey America) prevailed 5-4 over No. 4 Penn State (2-3-0, 2-1-0 AHA) in overtime for its first win against the Nittany Lions in 994 days. Jocelyn Fiala scored twice, including the sudden-death winner, while Ava Drabyk stopped 40 of Penn State’s 44 shots for a season-best save mark.

“We always want to beat Penn State,” Fiala said. “We’re determined to continue to play better.”

Early on, it seemed everything went Penn State’s way. A Stella Costabile tripping penalty put the Nittany Lions on the attack early, but Syracuse weathered the storm, killing the penalty without allowing a shot on goal.

Through the first 10 minutes, each team had no more than two shots on goal. SU’s lack of shots became a theme, but not for Penn State. Syracuse only had five first-period shots on goal compared to the Nittany Lions’ eight.

Still, Syracuse got on the scoreboard first, thanks to its two scoring leaders.

Midway through the first, Emma Gnade and Jackson Kinsler broke through the blue line, forcing a two-on-one. Gnade slid the puck from the right of Penn State goalie Morgan Stickney, where Kinsler, as she’s done all season, rifled it in on Stickney’s glove side, giving Syracuse a 1-0 lead.

“When you can play with the lead, it helps relax some of those nerves,” Idalski said postgame.

Following the goal, Syracuse went dead silent. For the rest of the first period and nearly all of the second, it had sparing chances. For a stretch of a little more than 17 minutes, it couldn’t record a shot on goal.

“We’d like that to be better,” Idalski said of the shooting drought. “We also acknowledge where we are and the fact that we defended really well.”

Penn State spent almost the entirety of the second period in its offensive zone, peppering Drabyk with shots from every angle imaginable. With the Orange clinging to a one-goal lead, Drabyk stood tall, blocking 17 shots before a timeout allowed her to catch her breath.

Shortly after, Syracuse not only got a shot on goal, thanks to Rylee McLeod, but scored, as Jordan Blouin cleaned up the rebound.

Up 2-0, the game seemed firmly in Syracuse’s control, but before the public address announcer finished narrating the goal, Penn State finally solved Drabyk. Sophie Morrow let a shot fly from the point. Drabyk eyed it, but Kylie Amelkovich had other plans, deflecting the puck into a small opening between Drabyk’s glove and the side of the cage.

Things went from bad to worse for Syracuse, as Penn State leveled the game three minutes later. Mikah Keller scored from point-blank range to make it 2-2.

It took Penn State scoring twice to wake up the Orange. With under five minutes remaining in the middle frame, Syracuse threatened several times but never seemed close to lighting the lamp.

Then came the start of the third. With Penn State outshooting the Orange 25-3 in the second period, it seemed it would likely run away with the game.

Less than a quarter into the final frame, Syracuse broke the deadlock again. Nea Tervonen caught up to a puck cleared out of the defensive zone, and with no one in front of her but Stickney on the break, she put Syracuse back up with 16 minutes to play.

Things spiraled for Penn State almost immediately after SU’s goal. McKenna Walsh didn’t come to the circle in time for the faceoff following the goal and was assessed a delay of game penalty, putting the Orange on the power play immediately after scoring.

After Syracuse set up in its zone, Fiala pulled back for a one-timer from the point, but Blouin passed the puck for Kinsler in the slot. Kinsler’s shot was unsuccessful, and the second time, Blouin saw Fiala preparing for the one-timer again. Fiala didn’t miss, blasting the puck toward Stickney, scoring and ending the Nittany Lions netminder’s day.

“It was a really nice pass from Jordan,” Fiala said postgame. “I just had to rip it home.”

With a two-goal lead, Syracuse retreated into its defensive zone for the final 15 minutes of the play to stop Penn State from scoring.

But Alara Murphy putting Penn State on the power play gave it life in desperation time. Like Syracuse, Danica Maynard scored within the power play’s first minute, cutting the deficit to 4-3.

Down one with about three minutes remaining, it seemed PSU pulling backup goalie Maddy Campbell for an extra skater was imminent, but Nicole Hall scored with 2:54 remaining, tying the game and ensuring overtime.

Once overtime began, it didn’t take long for a winner to be decided. Syracuse cleared the puck out of its defensive zone to Fiala. She found space in the slot and buried a shot past Campbell, earning mass celebrations from her teammates.

Before the season, Idalski didn’t make predictions or comparisons about Syracuse. What he did say, though, was that he viewed Penn State as AHA’s “gold standard.” Beating his gold standard only adds to Idalski’s dream start at SU, but he deferred passing judgment postgame.

“If we’re doing that in March, that’s different than doing it in October,” Idalski said.

banned-books-01