Skip to content
Women's Soccer

Maya Naimoli doesn’t rely on perfect technique to stop shots for Syracuse

Syracuse women's soccer goalkeeper Maya Naimoli stands outside the 18-yard box during her shutout performance in a draw with Harvard on Aug. 30. She has posted four clean sheets this season.
Syracuse women's soccer goalkeeper Maya Naimoli stands outside the 18-yard box during her shutout performance in a draw with Harvard on Aug. 30. She has posted four clean sheets this season. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

THE MATH ISN’T FAIR. A soccer goal measures 24 feet across and eight feet high. That’s 192 square feet for 5-foot-7 Maya Naimoli, tied for the shortest starting goalkeeper in the Atlantic Coast Conference, to protect.

“If you’re good enough, you’re tall enough,” Naimoli said.

“They’re built different,” her mother, Sam Naimoli, said of goalkeepers.

Forget perfect technique for a moment. Forget where Naimoli’s shoulders need to be, how far apart her feet are or whether she’s diving with the correct hand. When a shot flies toward the corner, Naimoli knows she can’t run through a checklist.

Against Villanova, she sprawled left to deny an attacker one-on-one with five minutes remaining. Then, with 28 seconds left, she darted across the goalmouth and stuck out a foot to stop another, preserving a scoreless draw in her Syracuse debut.

“Sometimes you just gotta make the save,” Naimoli said. “You don’t have time to think about it.”

That philosophy has served her well in her first season at SU. The redshirt junior transferred from Youngstown State this spring to succeed Shea Vanderbosch, the Orange’s all-time saves leader. Through 14 starts, Naimoli has an ACC-leading 59 saves and ranks second with 4.21 per game.

But those numbers have a less flattering side. Syracuse has struggled throughout conference play with a 1-7 record, giving Naimoli ample opportunities to make saves, though some have slipped by.

Naimoli didn’t arrive at the chilly confines of SU Soccer Stadium with an empty resume. She spent two seasons as Youngstown State’s starting netminder after redshirting at Ohio State, where she never played. Naimoli recorded 196 saves for the Penguins and was named a captain. A week after earning the honor, she entered the transfer portal.

Taking over for one of Syracuse’s most accomplished goaltenders is intimidating, but Naimoli isn’t interested in becoming the next Vanderbosch. Naimoli respects her predecessor’s accomplishments. She just doesn’t see the point in imitating her.

Syracuse women’s soccer goalkeeper Maya Naimoli winds up for a goal kick during a 0-0 draw with Harvard on Aug. 30. She leads the ACC with 59 saves and places second in saves per game with 4.21. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

Vanderbosch said she finds little reason for comparison, too. With different coaching staffs, teammates and paths to Syracuse, she doesn’t believe her success at SU relates to Naimoli’s.

“You can only use what you have in your toolbox and become as much of a master as you can,” Naimoli said.

One tool is unconventional. Since she was 17, Naimoli’s clapped her gloves — not after saves, but before them. When she notices an attacker preparing to shoot, Naimoli’s sharp thud helps her set her hands and tells her mind to react.

Inside The Keeper Institute training facility in Sewell, New Jersey, where she’s spent years practicing, the sound echoes. Coach Jillian Loyden, a former United States Women’s National Team goalie, doesn’t need to look at Naimoli to know she’s training. Loyden hears her.

“For a long time, we would have loved for her to stop,” Loyden said with a chuckle.

Naimoli doesn’t mind. It’s unusual, sure. But she’s never found reason to change it. The clap is the easy part. Saves are harder.

• • •

IT’S A LOSING BATTLE in Lubbock, Texas. A dozen groundskeepers, armed with leaf blowers and towels, try cleaning up Mother Nature’s mess at Texas Tech’s John Walker Soccer Complex on Aug. 17, 2025.

Flash flooding keeps Youngstown State at its hotel for nearly two hours. First-year head coach Rich Wall isn’t sure a game will be played. When the Penguins finally arrive, warmups are minutes away. Inside, they stretch. And outside? They race to make the pitch playable.

Eventually, the field’s ready. The Penguins aren’t.

Then-No. 25 Texas Tech races to a 3-0 lead through 23 minutes, and Naimoli spends the night trying to keep it from getting uglier. She makes 11 saves — then a career high — in a 4-1 loss.

“She was possessed,” Wall said.

One shot comes from roughly 25 yards out, rising toward goal. Naimoli launches left, stretches out her hand and pushes the ball over the crossbar. It’s one of her many stops, as the Red Raiders outshoot Youngstown State 38-2.

“She was the individual that gave the team life,” Wall said.

Naimoli considers it one of her best performances. But there’s one play she’d rather forget. In the 70th minute, Youngstown State finally scores, trimming its deficit to 3-1. Five minutes later, Naimoli receives a pass and tries distributing the ball left. Instead, she sends it straight to a Texas Tech attacker. The Red Raiders capitalize.

“Oh my goodness,” Wall thought when he saw the misplay. “You played so well.”

Maya Naimoli lunges right for a save on a penalty kick while playing for Youngstown State. The redshirt junior stopped 196 shots across her last two seasons with the Penguins after a year at Ohio State. Courtesy of Sam Naimoli

These days, Naimoli distinguishes between conceding goals and making mistakes. She can do everything right and still watch the ball sail past her. But when she sends a pass straight to an opponent? That’s on her.

“It feels bigger when you’re a goalkeeper,” Naimoli said.

So she gives herself a day. Twenty-four hours to be upset, replay the mistake and figure out what went wrong. She picks apart the bad pass, considers what could’ve been different and reminds herself of everything she’d done right beforehand. The pass won’t change, no matter how many times she revisits it.

Months later, when Power Four programs contact Wall about Naimoli’s transfer portal entrance, he knows exactly what to tell them.

“All you need to do is watch Texas Tech,” Wall says.

The diving saves are on that game’s film. So is the giveaway. Wall recommends it anyway.

• • •

THE ADVICE WAS SPECIFIC. As the Naimolis eventually discovered, it was also completely useless.

“Whatever you do, don’t let Maya be a goalkeeper.”

That’s the warning a family friend offered at Naimoli’s first travel tournament. The friend said goalkeepers carried too much pressure and took too many hits, but when coaches asked for volunteer goalies, Naimoli raised her hand.

“And here we are,” Sam said.

By 15 months old, Naimoli was already dribbling along the sidelines at her brother’s games. In elementary school, she practiced punts at recess, occasionally sending balls onto the roof. Years later, she kicked a hole in the ceiling at an indoor training facility.

“Don’t worry, they have insurance,” Naimoli told her parents.

At 8, Naimoli began training with Scott Nixon at FC Europa. Nixon recognized her potential and began working with her individually, introducing skills most goalkeepers her age weren’t ready to attempt.

One was the high-hand parry, used to tip shots sailing over goalkeepers’ heads and above the crossbar. It demanded precise footwork, timing and positioning. Most players didn’t learn it until age 10 or older; instead, they’d knock the ball into their own net, but Naimoli caught on quickly.

“She’s going to go places,” Nixon remembered thinking.

For all the time she spent protecting goals, Naimoli wasn’t half bad attacking them. As a freshman at Episcopal Academy (Pennsylvania), Naimoli scored 12 goals as a forward, tied for the team lead, while also playing goalie. Head coach Andy Fraggos remembers Naimoli scoring one of the finest strikes he’s seen: a volley off a cross on slippery turf.

But she wasn’t meant to play up front. Naimoli preferred being the last line of defense, even if that meant putting herself in harm’s way.

During a club tournament in Haddonfield, New Jersey, at 13, Naimoli charged toward an attacker and dove for the ball. It was kicked directly into her left eye. She finished the game. Later, when she complained of blurry vision, a specialist discovered a bruised retina. Naimoli missed a couple weeks before returning in protective glasses.

Her mother hoped the scare might encourage more caution the next time an attacker charged toward her. No such luck.

“She just goes straight back to 100 miles an hour,” Sam said.

• • •

COACHES SPEND YEARS waiting for a certain kind of player to walk through their door.

The one who doesn’t need to be chased down for extra training. Who seeks out criticism instead of avoiding it. Who’s thinking about tomorrow’s practice before today’s finishes.

Sometimes you just gotta make the save. You don’t have time to think about it.
Maya Naimoli, Syracuse goalkeeper

Former Youngstown State head coach Brian Shrum likens it to sitting in an office with the light on and the door open, hoping somebody serious enough eventually comes knocking.

“Maya was that kid,” Shrum said.

At Youngstown State in 2024, Naimoli wasted little time proving it. She commanded her penalty area, challenged attackers for crosses and regularly sought extra training with goalkeeper coach Josh Green.

It was a welcome change from Ohio State, where the lack of a dedicated goalkeeper coach frustrated her. At Youngstown State, she received the attention she wanted, trust from coaches and, most importantly, a chance to play.

But Naimoli had professional aspirations. She wanted another crack at Power Four soccer, even if she abandoned a situation she’d spent two years building.

“I might regret leaving Youngstown, but I’ll always regret not trying to go back to Power Four,” Sam recalled her daughter saying.

So Naimoli left. At Syracuse, she reunited with former Youngstown State goalkeeper coach Michele Barletta. They studied film, broke down technique and debated finer details of a position Naimoli’s spent much of her life mastering. And when ACC play arrived, competition didn’t disappoint.

“This is what I came here for,” Naimoli thought.

Back home, one of Naimoli’s old soccer balls sits beside the couch. It’s an Adidas replica match ball she saved up for as a kid.

For years, the Naimolis forbade soccer balls upstairs after too many bounced down the brown oak staircase, threatening light fixtures. Naimoli started leaving hers in a little nook beside the bottom step. If Sam saw it there, she knew her daughter was upstairs.

“I miss seeing her ball there,” Sam said.

These days, the nook belongs to Shelby, the family’s 86-pound goldendoodle. Sam could put the ball back where it used to go. She’d just have to move the dog first.

Besides, the ball has somewhere else to be. It’s flying toward a goal 24 feet wide and eight feet tall. Nobody’s offered to make it smaller, and Naimoli hasn’t asked.

banned-books-01