Skip to content
Baseball

Surrounding himself with baseball made Gage Davey J-E’s go-to clutch hitter

Jordan-Elbridge’s Gage Davey swings at a pitch. Davey hit .315 with a .444 slugging percentage last season for the Eagles to help them secure the school’s best record ever.
Jordan-Elbridge’s Gage Davey swings at a pitch. Davey hit .315 with a .444 slugging percentage last season for the Eagles to help them secure the school’s best record ever. Courtesy of Shots by Silas

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

Just hours ago, Gage Davey was sitting in a math class at Jordan-Elbridge High School. Now, it’s May 3, 2024, and Davey’s standing at the plate, game tied, bottom of the seventh, runner on third and a Hannibal High School pitcher staring him down. He plants his feet, preps his stance and takes a swing at the heater coming his way. He connects; the ball flies into left field, and no one’s there.

The man on third scampers home. The rest of the dugout makes a beeline to Davey.

“That’s just the biggest dopamine rush you could ever get in your life,” Davey said. “You get a head rush, and all you can do is just scream and have fun and get hyped about it. It’s just one of the greatest things that you can experience.”

It’s an experience that Davey’s grown accustomed to across his time in baseball. The senior’s had many clutch hits for Jordan-Elbridge. Last season, he hit .315 with a .444 slugging percentage. In the Eagles’ second game last season against Marcellus Sr. High School, he smacked two doubles and drove in a run to secure both a win and Jordan-Elbridge’s best record in program history.

“He’s won us a bunch of games at the plate,” Jordan-Elbridge coach Russell “Rusty” Cooper said. “He’s the kind of guy that can take over a game with the bat.”

For all the success Davey has had with Jordan-Elbridge, his beginnings were far from it. His mom only introduced him to baseball to keep him in check while growing up in California.

“It was just something I could take out my emotions on,” Davey said.

Gage Davey prepares to catch a ball for Jordan-Elbridge. Since getting called up to varsity in eighth grade, Davey has blossomed into a star for the Eagles. Courtesy of Shots by Silas

From there, Davey surrounded himself with baseball, playing up through all levels of Little League and joining travel ball squads. In eighth grade, he took a major risk and tried out for Jordan-Elbridge’s baseball team.

Not only did he make varsity as a middle schooler — he became the team’s starting catcher. Cooper saw plenty of promise in Davey. When Cooper first saw Davey, the coach said he was as good a defensive catcher as he’s ever seen in high school.

But he still had plenty of work to do.

“His first year, his swing was as bad as I’ve ever seen a swing,” Cooper said.

Davey had just one hit across 18 at-bats that year. After the season, the two had a conversation about his swing, and he spent the offseason doing drills to improve it.

The following season, Cooper said, Davey returned with one of the “best swings on the team,” a title he still holds.

“In one offseason, he fixed all of that,” Cooper said. “I’ve never seen that done before by anybody.”

Davey’s swing wasn’t the only issue with the team in his eighth-grade year. It won just three games all season, and Davey said the group’s chemistry wasn’t good. There was a lot of in-fighting and personal issues between teammates.

Just as he did with his swing, Davey took it upon himself to correct the issues he saw. At one point, Cooper recalled, he called out a senior who was “bringing the team down,” loud enough for everyone around him to hear it.

“You see the effect it has on his teammates,” Cooper said. “He’s always been strong like that.”

With a revamped swing and culture, Davey helped push Jordan-Elbridge into the playoffs as a No. 16 seed in his freshman year.

Matched up against Holland Patent High School, a dominant No. 1 seed, Jordan-Elbridge wasn’t expected to have a chance. But as the game progressed, the Eagles noticed their opponent’s laziness on defense and half-hearted pitching. Holland Patent had seemingly written off its opponent, and before he knew it, Davey’s team led 2-0 in what was supposed to be a blowout.

“Once we realized how lackadaisical they were, and how easily they thought they could beat us, that kind of clicked,” Davey said.

The upset shocked even Jordan-Elbridge’s players. But Cooper wasn’t fazed; he knew his players just needed to believe they could win. Once they did that, the playoff runs followed, as Davey helped push the Eagles to consecutive quarterfinal appearances.

Physically, I’ll have to stop playing. But mentally, (baseball) will stay with me forever.
Gage Davey, Jordan-Elbridge baseball player

But there was still work to do. Davey’s catching was strong, and his swing was sharp. The final piece of the puzzle was building a strong relationship with his pitchers.

“Growing up, I never really played on the same team with him,” Jordan-Elbridge pitcher Shannon Ahern III said. “He was always on the other team.”

While the two were always opponents in junior leagues, once Ahern arrived on the mound, the connection was instant.

“When you’re set up on a count, and you know what you want to throw, and your catcher’s on the same page, it’s just another level of baseball,” Ahern said.

That connection immediately elevated the team to another level. The Eagles went 16-4 and had their best season in school history. They were beating teams they hadn’t defeated in the past two decades, Cooper said.

But the team’s dream of a sectional championship was cut short by a semifinal loss to Bishop Ludden-Grimes Junior-Senior High School. Now, Davey’s fixated on helping this team win at all costs.

It’s an all-or-nothing year for Davey, and his teammates are right beside him. His absence after this season looms large over all of them. He doesn’t plan to play baseball after high school. Ahern says he’ll miss the bus rides to games with Davey and his jokes. Cooper says that, when Davey leaves, it’ll leave a big hole in his program.

But Davey knows he’ll miss the sport just as much as they miss him.

“Physically, I’ll have to stop playing,” Davey said. “But mentally, it will stay with me forever.”

banned-books-01