Gov. Hochul’s win is a manifestation of anti-MAGA sentiment, not popularity
Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.
The New York state midterm election polls closed at 9:00 p.m. on Tuesday. Kathy Hochul was projected to win the governorship at 9:01 p.m.
An outsider may see this and believe Hochul is a beloved governor. That the people wanted her to return to her post. And while the outcome of her seat was never in much doubt, there’s a large portion of New York state — primarily rural areas — that have a multitude of gripes with the reelected incumbent.
This partially comes from the fact that four of New York state’s five main upstate cities — Syracuse, Rochester, Albany and Buffalo — are in the top 100 among United States cities for child poverty rates. And yet, Hochul decided the best course of action was to spend 850 million taxpayer dollars on the Buffalo Bills’ new stadium.
Some may argue Hochul signed the 2021 Child Poverty Reduction Act to halve child poverty within 10 years. But that was just a statute. Its only action was creating a new advisory council.
Even with additional state funding to combat child poverty in these areas, only a measly $50 million was given, split among Syracuse, Rochester and Buffalo.
Many hoped Hochul’s reintroduction of congestion pricing would generate revenue to revitalize infrastructure throughout the state. While congestion pricing has reduced greenhouse emissions and traffic while increasing MTA ridership, state law limits the money to projects within New York City and surrounding areas.
It’s left most upstate and rural areas high and dry when it comes to public transit infrastructure. In fact, about 95% of New York’s geography lacks public transportation.
While Hochul won the race, no one's really cheering for her. New Yorkers aren’t enthusiastic about her second term — she was a defection rather than a passionate selection.Kaelen Kinsella, Columnist
Even with its plethora of benefits, many New Yorkers are frustrated that they can’t enter an area of their state without paying a fee. It furthers the divide between New York City and New York state. Hochul has failed to address these concerns by not pushing for state legislation that would allow portions of congestion pricing funding to be allocated to upstate.
Hochul’s taxpayer-funded priorities have become an issue for her support across New York state. She’s good at getting money but can’t distribute it equitably. Hochul generally can’t seem to prioritize upstate infrastructure enough, despite being the first governor from upstate New York in over a century.
Making upstate regions feel represented is necessary to govern all of New York state.
You may have questions about her cruising to victory over Bruce Blakeman in the midterm elections. It comes down to two reasons: the magic “D” on the ballot and Blakeman’s MAGA loyalty. These core factors in New York state’s electoral outcome came from the blue rogue wave seen nationwide during the midterms.
When asked about which party’s candidate someone would be more likely to vote for, polling shows the Democratic Party was up by 14 points. This meant that regardless of who the candidate was, the average likely voter was inclined to choose one with a “D” next to their name.
This phenomenon can be seen at the local level. Onondaga County Court Judge Matthew Doran lost to his Democratic challenger, despite being a well-known moderate who’d channeled bipartisanship for a decade.
Although he kept more voters than most of his fellow Republicans, he too was swept by the unstoppable Democratic force. When it came to Hochul, despite her shortcomings, many voters cast ballots for her as a rebuke of the Republican Party.
The Republican Party has become increasingly scrutinized, as its reputation is dragged down by President Donald Trump. In New York state, his approval rating hovers around 30%, so it’s no surprise New Yorkers were put off by Blakeman embracing the Trump Administration. As Trump’s unpopularity soared to new heights, Blakeman’s good standing quickly evaporated.
While Hochul won the race, no one’s really cheering for her. New Yorkers aren’t enthusiastic about her second term — she was a defection rather than a passionate selection.
But Hochul now has an opportunity to restore the broken trust between herself and upstate communities. She’s been handed this term, but if she wants to continue her tenure in four years’ time, she must earn it.
Kaelen Kinsella is a freshman majoring in journalism and political science. He can be reached at kaelenkinsella@gmail.com.

