Skip to content
Food and Drink

Owners infuse Italian flavors, pizza passion into new Westcott spot ioli

Damien Vallelonga drizzles olive oil onto a pizza pie at ioli's pizza. Vallelonga and Syracuse University graduate Jonathan Durand launched the Westcott Street pizzeria Sept. 9.
Damien Vallelonga drizzles olive oil onto a pizza pie at ioli's pizza. Vallelonga and Syracuse University graduate Jonathan Durand launched the Westcott Street pizzeria Sept. 9. Kedar Nair | Contributing Photographer

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

Pizza is in Jonathan Durand’s blood. His great-grandfather was a “pizzaiolo,” or pizza maker, at a pizzeria in Utica. That family history inspired the name of the product of Durand’s recent career change: ioli pizza.

“We both grew up just having pizza made in our homes, ” Durand said.

That Italian heritage influenced Durand, who graduated from Syracuse University in 2005, and his co-owner and longtime friend Damian Vallelonga to launch their first restaurant venture, ioli Pizza, on Westcott Street. The pizza joint opened Sept. 9 in the old Dorian’s Gourmet Pizza & Deli storefront, and offers Neapolitan pizza, salads and desserts.

Outside, strings of glowing lights stretch above the parking lot, welcoming visitors to ioli pizza. Inside, warm light falls across dark wooden counters as customers settle into their seats. Along the windows, tall chairs face Westcott Street while the restaurant’s open kitchen offers a front-row view of pizzas being prepared.

“We can just have conversations,” Vallelonga said. “And then people can ask us questions about the process, about the ingredients, all that.”

Planning for the restaurant began in January, Durand said, including planning the space’s renovation. But crafting the right pizza took longer than fixing up the building.

Durand and Vallelonga spent months perfecting their dough recipe, which uses a pre-fermentation technique called poolish, a process that can take two to three days. Compared with traditional New York-style pizza, which generally has a thinner, denser crust, ioli’s contemporary Neapolitan pies feature lighter dough.

“Our dough is what we are very, very proud of,” Durand said, “My mother is gluten intolerant. She has no problem having our pizzas.”

The restaurant seeks authentic Italian and high-quality ingredients, sourcing its Caputo 00 flour and San Marzano tomatoes from Italy, and other produce from local farms. Currently, ioli offers a variety of different pizzas, including Margherita, Scarole, ‘Nduja and Marinara.

An ioli pizza employee grates pecorino onto a pizza. Co-owners Damian Vallelonga and Jonathan Durand source ingredients, like Caputo 00 flour and San Marzano tomatoes, from Italy. Kedar Nair | Contributing Photographer

Vallelonga said he hopes the restaurant becomes a place where neighbors can gather, meet new people and enjoy themselves.

“I want people to feel real comfortable and like it’s upbeat and inviting, and you can meet friends or strangers,” Vallelonga said.

That welcoming atmosphere extends to the employees.

Kara Williams, who has worked at ioli since its opening, joined the staff at the cash register after visiting during the restaurant’s early dough-testing sessions. Williams, who works full-time as director of strategy at the Allyn Family Foundation, now spends most Friday evenings helping at ioli simply because she enjoys it.

“They wanted kindness, courtesy, a supportive environment, and that’s totally what it is,” Williams said.

When a pizza is accidentally burned or develops a hole, it becomes what the staff calls a “house pizza,” shared among employees during quiet moments. Williams said Durand also makes sure employees have food at the beginning and end of their shifts, sometimes sending them home with a pizza.

The staff’s connections extend beyond the kitchen. Many employees, including Vallelonga, Durand and Williams, attended Nottingham High School, strengthening the restaurant’s ties to Syracuse’s East Side.

Some neighboring businesses also share a sense of camaraderie with the pizza joint.

Williams said local business owners have welcomed ioli, offering advice and support rather than treating the new restaurant as competition. Johanna Yorke, owner of neighboring Alto Cinco, has offered guidance about small business ownership.

For Williams, those relationships reflect the character of the Westcott neighborhood.

“It is very tight-knit,” Williams said. “It’s very generally environmentally focused, and people who really care about giving back and community, neighbors taking care of neighbors.”

Ioli’s opening is particularly meaningful because of the history of its location, Williams said.


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

Campus food trucks, DoorDash orders satisfy SU students’ late-night cravings

After a night out, Syracuse University students often turn to food trucks or DoorDash for a late-night meal — a common campus tradition.


Customers regularly express excitement about seeing the property occupied again, Williams said. Some have already become weekly visitors, returning every Friday and greeting employees by name.

“We can be part of the community again,” Williams said.

Although opening a small restaurant comes with challenges, like finding trustworthy employees, Vallelonga said he’s optimistic about ioli’s future. The owners have relied heavily on friends and family to build a dependable team, while emphasizing careful planning and consistent quality.

For Williams, ioli represents something larger than another dining option. She believes that seeing locally owned businesses succeed can strengthen the way Syracuse residents view their city.

“It’s always wonderful when locally owned businesses from people who live here and grew up here thrive and are successful,” Williams said.

membership_button_new-10