Skip to content
Beyond the Hill

Jeremy Garelick loves to make people laugh. So, he founded American High.

Jeremy Garelick smiles on an American High set. After moving from Los Angeles to Syracuse in 2022, Garelick has produced and directed different projects, including “Rolling Loud: The Movie.”
Jeremy Garelick smiles on an American High set. After moving from Los Angeles to Syracuse in 2022, Garelick has produced and directed different projects, including “Rolling Loud: The Movie.” Courtesy of Frank Masi

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

Jeremy Garelick said he was “never a great reader,” so he’d learn about the world around him from watching movies over and over again as a kid. From “Airplane!” to “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off,” Garelick quickly realized his favorite genre was comedy, because he’d much rather laugh than get scared.

Growing up with two older sisters in New City, New York, Garelick said he fought for the attention of his household. The only way he could get his family’s focus was to do or say something funny. When met with a chuckle, Garelick said it was always “the greatest feeling in the world.”

Now, decades later, 50-year-old Garelick’s love for comedy translated into something more than just watching movies. He created a production company dedicated to the genre.

“My first goal is I want to write and make a really funny movie that’s gonna make everybody laugh. So that was what drove me,” Garelick said. “Financial success was never ever a goal.”

That ethos is partly what kept Garelick in the industry for so long, even after moving out of Beverly Hills, California, to Syracuse in 2022. Garelick started frequently visiting Syracuse in August 2017 when he bought a former Liverpool middle school for his production company, American High, to operate out of.

Garelick founded American High in 2017, and since then, the company has produced feature films like “Pizza Movie” and “Big Time Adolescence” as well as TV series like “Minimum Wage.”

While living in Syracuse, Garelick kept himself busy as the CEO of American High while directing his own films. Garelick’s most recent directorial project, “Rolling Loud: The Movie,” released Oct. 2 and stars Owen Wilson and Matt Rife.

During his years at Clarkstown North High School, Garelick had no clue cinephiles like him could make a career out of filmmaking. Walking through the halls of his high school, Garelick said he’d wield a video camera and make movies for his classmates. When peers presented artistic, experimental films in Garelick’s high school film class, he’d show his homemade, “ridiculous films.” He remembers one short film about someone having to go to the bathroom at school, but all restrooms in the building were locked.

“I just loved the response that I would get from making people laugh. Whatever idea or whatever decisions I’ve made, it’s always ‘how could we have fun?’” Garelick said.

Being a cineaste and experimenting with storylines led Garelick to majoring in film and theater at Yale University, where he also played Division I football. In college, Garelick dipped his toes into the world of Hollywood, spending a summer interning at Disney with producer Marty Katz and another summer with writer and producer David Milch.

After his 1998 graduation, Garelick moved to Los Angeles and started working as an assistant at Creative Artists Agency. He then went on to work with director Joel Schumacher on “Tigerland,” where Garelick worked on his first set. During that time, Garelick sold his first script and met Vince Vaughn. Vaughn pitched a movie idea that would later become “The Break-Up,” which Garelick co-produced and co-wrote.

Ben Frahm (left), Daniel Goldberg, Blake Snyder, Dean DeBlois and Jeremy Garelick gather at the Warner Bros. Studios’ backlot. The five mentored each other in a writers group. Courtesy of Ben Frahm

That was around the time Syracuse University assistant professor Ben Frahm met Garelick through a writers group they were part of. It was around 2008, Frahm estimates, and Garelick had completed uncredited work for “The Hangover.”

The group of writers — Garelick, Frahm, Dean DeBlois, Daniel Goldberg and Blake Snyder — shared pages with each other, compared scripts and talked about stories over meals, Frahm said. It was apparent Garelick was a “real people person” in a room full of people in showbiz.

“I’m always trying to keep up with the dude,” Frahm said. “What I find most commendable is just his inability or unwillingness to accept ‘No.’ It just doesn’t vibe with him.”

Now, Frahm regularly works with Garelick for a “Script-to-Screen” class that he teaches in the Newhouse School of Public Communications and collaborates with Garelick and American High for. Will Phelps, American High’s president and Garelick’s former assistant, said this isn’t offbeat for Garelick.

“I’ve worked with a lot of directors who are just very all about themselves, but I’d say Jeremy spends half his time mentoring people or finding ways to give back,” Phelps said.

The business partners and friends met in 2014 and clicked instantly, Phelps said. Although Phelps lives in Los Angeles and Garelick in Syracuse, Phelps spends at least eight months of the year in Syracuse. Since Phelps met Garelick, Garelick’s directed “The Wedding Ringer,” “Murder Mystery 2” and “The Binge.”

Because the duo spends so much time together, Phelps said he and Garelick have the same sense of humor.


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

One real-life incident sparked American High’s immersive film ‘Rolling Loud’

Liverpool’s American High’s latest movie, “Rolling Loud: The Movie,” is based on the true story of a father losing his son at the Rolling Loud music festival.


“We write so much together that we’ll be on Zoom calls and we’ll throw each other layups for a joke,” Phelps said. “He’ll set up a punch to a joke, and I’ll hit the punchline, or we’ll say the punchline at the same time.”

When Garelick isn’t working — which is rare because he’s a self-diagnosed “workaholic” — he’s probably spending time with his four kids, two dogs and one fish in Syracuse. Garelick’s proud of all he’s built in Syracuse, he said.

If Garelick tells other entertainment industry members where he lives, he usually receives the same answer: “‘What the hell is wrong with you? Like, what are you doing?’”

Then, Garelick jokes that he couldn’t handle the sunshine every day in California. Moreover, Garelick said he’s fallen in love with Syracuse. Feelings or jokes like those are common with Garelick because he’s not very mysterious, Phelps said.

Among all the times with Garelick, both of Phelps’ favorite memories have been at American High’s Liverpool space when they were both overworking themselves. One day, it was the middle of the night, and the duo installed a trampoline under the school’s basketball hoop instead of working on their movie prep.

Another fond moment was when Phelps and Garelick needed to relieve stress from writing scripts; they used a vacuum cleaner to smash down a wall. That sparked an American High tradition: after every American High movie, the cast destroys the same wall with a fire extinguisher.

Although Garelick’s personality hasn’t changed much, his career goals have evolved slightly.

“When I was younger, I wanted to make a movie that was going to make people laugh,” Garelick said. “Now I want to make a company that’s going to make people laugh.”

membership_button_new-10