Skip to content
Column

Scott Colom’s Mississippi win embodies values that led Democrats to victory

Scott Colom was shut out of his federal nomination in 2022. So his recent midterm victory, in which he flipped a Mississippi Senate seat blue, is an electoral miracle. Our columnist argues Colom’s advocacy helped him win.
Scott Colom was shut out of his federal nomination in 2022. So his recent midterm victory, in which he flipped a Mississippi Senate seat blue, is an electoral miracle. Our columnist argues Colom’s advocacy helped him win. Rozalia Finkelstein | Contributing Illustrator

Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.

On Nov. 15, 2022, President Joe Biden nominated District Attorney Scott Colom to serve as a federal district judge for northern Mississippi. Once nominated, district judges are almost always confirmed. But Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith of Mississippi used the Senate Judiciary Committee’s longstanding blue-slip tradition, which gives senators a final say on appointments in their state, to block Colom’s nomination.

Hyde-Smith cited disagreements with Colom’s positions on transgender issues as the reason for her opposition. Four years later, Colom has unseated Hyde-Smith, flipping a Senate seat blue for the first time in Mississippi since 1982. He’s also the first Black senator to represent the state since 1881. How did this happen in a historically red state where Republicans have had a stranglehold on politics for decades?

Colom first had to appeal to voters who had little appetite for partisan progressive politics. To do so, he relied on messages that emphasized issues with broad appeal.

“He’s running to lower costs for families, save our Mississippi hospitals, and bring good jobs home,” his campaign said.

He promised to work with Republicans and Democrats. He highlighted his ideological overlap with conservative voters on issues such as border security, eliminating tax on tips and Social Security benefits, and described himself as personally pro-life due to his Christian faith. These positions successfully portrayed him as a moderate to voters.

Democratic machine powerhouse Sen. Chuck Schumer described him as a candidate who could capture Mississippi’s traditionally Democratic blocks and entice red voters who were drifting from the Republican party.

The national events surrounding the midterms also gave him a lot of room to work with.

Colom’s campaign came during a historically blue electoral environment characterized by a concern with kitchen table issues. The cost of living crisis was the biggest concern identified by voters across the country as they grappled with rising costs, gas prices and inflation.

When costs motivate voters, blame often falls back onto the current administration. The United States’ involvement with the Iran War increased gas prices, while federal tariffs hit Mississippi’s agricultural sector hard.

Colom has shown his support for reversing medicare cuts from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, ending the Iran War, returning tariff decisions to Congress and increasing transparency on the Jeffrey Epstein files. All of these measures pit him squarely against President Donald Trump, whose approval in Mississippi fell to 43%.

The nationwide surge in political participation also gave him the juice to make up for a deficit in funding between his and Hyde-Smith’s campaign. Grassroots organizing meant registering voters and getting them to the polls. It even helped him raise hundreds of thousands of dollars from individual donors toward the end of the campaign.

Still, his platform and the general environment wouldn’t be enough to secure his election. He also had to focus on the large Black share of the electorate.

Colom embodies what led Democrats to a historical victory this November: a moderate candidate who is promising to bring attention back to what voters actually care about.
Declan Berry, Columnist

Mississippi’s electoral history is complicated. The state’s Black community makes up around 37% of its population, the highest proportion of any state in the U.S. Following emancipation, Black men entered public office in greater numbers than in any other state. As Reconstruction ended, however, their political participation was systematically suppressed through a combination of segregationist laws and voter intimidation.

Colom used the civil rights history of the state as an important thread throughout his campaign. He consistently reminded voters at rallies throughout the state about their place in a legacy of civil rights and their own contributions to that history.

This was seen the most in his victory speech chock full of references and callbacks, where he donned a hoodie with an inscription from civil rights leader Bob Moses reading “When you’re in Mississippi, the rest of America doesn’t seem real. And when you’re in the rest of America, Mississippi doesn’t seem real.”

Colom embodies what led Democrats to a historical victory this November: a moderate candidate who is promising to bring attention back to what voters actually care about. He is also a lifelong Mississippian who belongs to a segment of the state historically overlooked.

His ability to combine these traits when it mattered has led him to pull off an electoral miracle unthinkable just two years ago.

Declan Berry is a freshman majoring in journalism and data science. He can be reached at deberry@syr.edu.

membership_button_new-10