Skip to content
THE DAILY ORANGE
‘One is too many’: Decades of sexual abuse lawsuits allege SU’s negligence amid national scrutiny

‘One is too many’

Decades of sexual abuse lawsuits allege SU’s negligence amid national scrutiny

Content warning: This article contains mentions of rape and sexual assault.

S

ixteen civil lawsuits filed against Syracuse University alledge negligence or other misconduct in its handling of sexual abuse cases, The Daily Orange found.

The alleged incidents occurred from 1980-2021, and include ongoing, dismissed and settled lawsuits. Several were filed under the New York state Adult Survivors Act and the Child Victims Act, which both created a one-year window for survivors to file past the statute of limitations.

Seven of the lawsuits were filed against former SU employee Conrad Mainwaring, a resident advisor at Brewster Hall and athletic assistant coach. The other nine lawsuits were filed against various others affiliated with the university, including students, professors and coaches.

The lawsuits include:

1980-86
The D.O. identified seven lawsuits filed against SU for negligence, alleging the university ignored signs of predatory behavior from Conrad Mainwaring.
It includes May, De Santo, Druger, Shapiro and Lunney v. SU which allege incidents occurred 1980-86. It was filed in 2023 and the case’s status is active.
Lunney and Kriesberg v. SU alleges incidents occurred 1980-86. It was filed in 2021 and the case’s status is active.
Robert Bender v. SU alleges incidents occurred in 1980. It was filed in 2023 and the case’s status is active.
Robert Druger v. SU et al alleges incidents occurred from 1980 until Druger’s graduation. It was filed in 2020 and the case’s status is active.
John Doe v. SU alleges incidents occurred from 1982-84. It was filed in 2023 and the case’s status is active.
Shapiro, Sweet and A.A. v. SU et al alleges incidents occurred from 1981-82 at SU but references other incidents at Camp Greylock in 1973-79. It was filed in 2020 and the case’s status is active.
JMBMNY Doe v. SU and John Doe v. SU and Mainwaring were originally filed separately but have been officially consolidated into one case, according to legal documents.
JMBMNY alleges the incident occurred in 1981 and was filed in 2023. John Doe alleges the incident occurred 1981. It was filed in 2020 and the consolidated case’s status is active.
1984-97
Three former members of SU’s women’s tennis team said they experienced sexual abuse by the head women’s tennis coach Jesse Dwire. The plaintiffs allege SU was negligent in its handling of the investigation and its retention and supervision.
Carolyn Mahoney v. SU alleges the incidents occurred from 1984-88. It was filed in 2023 and the case’s status is active.
Ericson v. SU alleged that incidents occurred from 1994-97. It was filed in 1998 and the case was settled.
1986
Timothy Kearns v. Theodore Wallin and SU alleges that incidents occurred from 1986. It was filed in 2023 and the case was settled.
1987
Jane Doe v. SU and Board of Trustees of SU alleges the incident occurred in 1987. It was filed in 2023 and the case’s status is active.
1991
Jane Doe v. SU et al alleges the incident occurred in 1991. It was filed in 2023 and the case was settled.
2008-11
Floyd Van Hooser v. SU et al alleges incidents occurred 2008-11 at SU but references other incidents when the plaintiff was a child and experienced alleged abuse from the defendant Bernie Fine. It was filed in 2023 and the case’s status is active.
2020
Jane Doe v. SU et al alleged that incidents occurred from 2020-21. It was filed in 2021 and the case was settled.
Jane Doe v. Cohen and SU alleged incidents occurred 2020-21. Filed in 2023, Doe and SU agreed that her claims against SU were discontinued with prejudice, meaning the case is permanently closed and cannot be refiled in that court.
2021
Julia Killcommons v. SU et al alleged the incident occurred in 2021. Filed in 2022, all parties agreed to a stipulation discontinuing action, which is a formal written agreement signed to voluntarily end the case before a final court judgment.

In a statement to The D.O., an SU spokesperson wrote that the university unequivocally condemns any type of sexual misconduct and highlighted the policies and procedures in place to support the reporting, investigating or adjudication of allegations.

“We work diligently and intentionally, along with our community members, to create a campus environment that is dedicated to the prevention of sexual violence and supportive of survivors who come forward to report any act of sexual misconduct,” the spokesperson wrote.

Colleges and universities across the country have faced scrutiny regarding their handling of campus sexual assault after the Cornell University rape lawsuit gained national attention.

Timothy Heaphy, chief investigative counsel for the United States House Select Committee on the January 6 attacks and former general counsel of the University of Virginia, stressed the importance of separating the Title IX process from lawsuits against a university.

At UVA, Heaphy oversaw all legal affairs of the institution. He explained cases usually follow an internal process governed by an investigation with an accusation, a fact-finding process and a mini trial. He said cases almost never leave the Title IX process.

“These cases rarely get litigated in court. At UVA, we had very few of those cases that went outside of the Title IX process,” Heaphy said. “If Syracuse has had (16) cases where victims have said, ‘I don’t feel like the Syracuse process complied with the law or protected my rights,’ that is unusual.”

Several of the lawyers The D.O. spoke with said the ASA and CVA likely increased the number of lawsuits filed against SU. Of the 16 lawsuits, 12 were filed under these acts.

The SU spokesperson noted that several of the lawsuits that happened decades ago are no longer pending, some having been dismissed in court. Over 3,000 civil lawsuits were filed under the ASA and over 10,000 were filed under the CVA within their respective windows.

“The volume of cases and the circumstances surrounding them don’t reflect the current conditions or prevention protocols on our campus today,” the SU spokesperson wrote.

Heaphy explained that universities have an obligation to conduct an investigation before a lawsuit is filed. When an institution receives a complaint of any kind, he said they have to investigate and create a process that provides fairness to all parties.

If someone says the university’s process wasn’t fair, Heaphy said the complaint then goes to court, where the university’s interest shifts from the student to self-protection.

The Title IX process is difficult for schools to get right due to unreliable information, Heaphy said. At UVA, he said the university had a robust process that protected victims and provided supportive measures, but the quality can vary across the country.

Mitchell Epner, a former assistant U.S. attorney who’s handled sexual abuse cases, said no college or university is immune to the problem. He said although there’s been some improvement, it’s important to remember how society used to treat survivors and that better is “far from good enough.”

Epner said the standard of care should be significantly higher than most universities practiced when he was in college.

“Until very recently, there was an enormous amount of shame and secrecy that surrounded these issues, which made it much less likely that somebody would file a lawsuit like this,” Epner said.

There were 10 rapes reported in SU’s campus residential facilities in 2025, four more than the year prior, according to an Oct. 1 campus safety report from SU’s Department of Public Safety.

News10NBC examined the number of sexual assault cases at nearby college campuses in October and found Nazareth University had the highest number of reported sexual assaults in 2025, with more than 160 cases. University of Rochester’s website had 20 reports of sexual assault during the 2023-2024 academic year, News10NBC reported.

Prevention is as important as punishment.
Timothy Heaphy, former general counsel of the University of Virginia

Mark Boskovich, who’s litigated sexual abuse lawsuits involving institutional negligence, said he thinks poor leadership and lack of accountability from staff and professors often lead to an increase in lawsuits filed.

Boskovich said through his nearly 15 years in the field, he’s learned sexual misconduct and abuse are prevalent everywhere. Due to the commonness of these cases, Boskovich said seeing lawsuits doesn’t surprise him anymore.

“Unfortunately, a lot of sexual deviants are out there, and they are in every context. They find their way everywhere,” Boskovich said. “That’s why we always suggest that all these organizations who are dealing with young kids and young adults take precautions because this could be you.”

Kat Thomas, an attorney for several plaintiffs in the Mainwaring cases, said it’s important to shift the blame off the victim and onto the institutions that should’ve “done the right thing” in the first place.

Although Thomas said 16 lawsuits are “way too many,” she added “even one is too many,” saying she’s sure more people have experienced abuse but haven’t reported the instances. Thomas explained SU’s 16 cases only represent those that had the courage to come forward.

Thomas emphasized how difficult it is for victims to speak up, especially at universities, for fear of blame and retaliation. She said in her experience, the default is to not believe survivors, especially college-aged students.

“It’s very upsetting to me that this is still going on. I mean, look at (SU’s) budget for athletics,” Thomas said. “Look at what they will spend money on, right? Why aren’t we doing better trainings? Why aren’t we vetting people? Why is this still an issue?”

Thomas said the issue of sexual abuse on college campuses is an epidemic and, based on her experience as a litigator, she said SU “definitely has a problem.”

In his professional background, Epner said sexual harassment and assault incidents are much more likely to occur when there’s excessive use of alcohol and other intoxicants. He explained that an institution being widely known as a “party school” also contributes to the frequency of these instances.

Boskovich agreed and said in cases of assault between students, he expects to see an increase at party schools with heavy drinking and fraternity systems. He said some of the worst tendencies unfortunately come out in those situations.

Although certain cases, like the Cornell lawsuit, can make it feel like the problem is getting worse, Boskovich said over time things are “definitely getting better.” He said today, these incidents are in the news cycle much more than in the past, bringing more attention and awareness.

“I think you are seeing a cultural shift in the right direction,” Boskovich said. “I would say there is a gradual improvement in this because there’s just so much more awareness.”

Heaphy said as these high-profile cases prompt conversation, schools look at their own process, more victims come forward and more attention is drawn to the problem.

“That is a healthy conversation that we need to have,” Heaphy said. “Prevention is as important as punishment.”

The SU spokesperson said the university’s approach to prevention, reporting and response has “changed a great deal over the years.” They also wrote that federal guidance and requirements, including Title IX regulations, have evolved over the decades, and SU has changed its policies and programs accordingly.

The spokesperson mentioned the mandatory training required for every student at the start of each academic year and highlighted that executive leaders of recognized student organizations, including fraternities and sororities, complete additional training.

The spokesperson also highlighted SU’s direct engagement with student organizations, clear reporting options, support and ongoing review as work that is constant.
“We regularly review our protocols, processes and services related to preventing and responding to sexual violence,” the spokesperson wrote. “We align them with current law and best practices, so that every member of our team understands their role and is prepared to act.”

Thomas said SU and other universities should offer more training for students and teachers, saying they need to be trauma-informed.

In addition to greater exposure and accountability, she said it’s vital to know that, as a survivor, you’re not alone.

“I think it’s very impactful because we need to put light on it. This stuff grows in the dark,” Thomas said. “They should not be able to get away with allowing students to be harmed like this in some of the most egregious forms of assault you can imagine.”

Design by Adelaide Guan | Presentation Director