Skip to content
Guest Column

SU’s psychology department must relay age requirement for research studies

Syracuse University offers research credits for psychology students under 18, but doesn’t clarify age restrictions beforehand. Our guest columnist argues SU must be transparent with their guidelines.
Syracuse University offers research credits for psychology students under 18, but doesn’t clarify age restrictions beforehand. Our guest columnist argues SU must be transparent with their guidelines. Tara Deluca | Photo Editor

Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.

My psychology professor asked if anyone in my class was under 18 years old.

I glanced around the room, embarrassed but relieved I wasn’t the only one raising my hand.

The Syracuse University Department of Psychology’s guide states students 17 years old or younger can’t participate in SONA studies, the system SU psychology students use to earn course credit through research studies.

For students like me, that means we’re often steered toward an alternative: writing essay summaries. But this option requires more effort for the same credit, which shouldn’t be the case.

A requirement meant to introduce us to real research has, unfortunately, turned into a tedious writing assignment simply because of our age.

On Oct. 2, I signed up for an 11 a.m. essay summary. When I arrived at the building, I was directed to a desk and given an article, a pencil and a few pages of notebook paper. Students who were over 18 years old and completing online studies for SONA credit were seated in the same room, working right by my side.

My article was several pages long, with small lettering that was difficult to read. It included methods, results, limitations and more, most of which I had to cover in my summary.

I looked behind me and saw a student who arrived around the same time and was participating in an online study. As I skimmed the article and began my second paragraph, I watched the girl smile and tell the instructor she’d finished.

I was shocked. Her study took about 20 minutes, while I was still trying to dissect my article’s methods section.
Her study was worth half a credit. My summary was worth one credit, but it took me an hour. Even with that math, I have to spend about 20 extra minutes per credit carefully reading and rushing to include important information.

When I opened SONA after the fact, every half-credit online study I saw required participants to be at least 18 years old. The only listing without an age requirement was the article review, worth one credit.

SU’s psychology guide says 17-year-olds have “the opportunity to earn the same number of points.” That’s true. The same number of points, but not for the same amount of effort.

I did learn from the articles I read, but I shouldn’t have to spend more time and effort than others to meet the same requirements.
Alejandra Cuellar, Guest Columnist

Zoe Papaseraphim, a freshman psychology major who’s 18 years old, chose research studies for her SONA credits because they seemed easier. She said she’d rather participate in studies than write essays. Each of her studies have taken her less than an hour.

My summaries each took a full hour and felt more demanding. I had to read closely, analyze the research and explain the findings in my own words.

I understand why the age restriction exists. Researchers need participants who can legally agree to take part, and the rule keeps minors out of studies they can’t legally consent to.

Reading academic research teaches students how studies work. I did learn from the articles I read, but I shouldn’t have to spend more time and effort than others to meet the same requirements.

College Tuition Compare lists 33 of SU’s roughly 22,500 students as under 18 years old. That’s a small enough group that giving us a fair option would take very little effort.

Other universities already offer alternatives. The University of Michigan-Dearborn exempts students under 18 years old without requiring a replacement assignment. At the University of Massachusetts Amherst, students who can’t participate in studies can attend in-person research talks, with one credit awarded per 30 minutes of participation.

I don’t believe the age restriction should disappear. But students should know about it before enrolling in the course, not when their professor asks who’s under 18 years old. The Psychology Department must clearly communicate with students about the age restriction and essay options before enrollment. For those who still wish to take psychology classes, the department could offer a half-credit summary that matches the time of the online study, or research talks like UMass Amherst’s.

When my professor asked if anyone was under 18 years old, I raised my hand and immediately felt embarrassed. But I shouldn’t have. Nothing about my age should leave me with only one option.

Alejandra Cuellar is a freshman majoring in psychology and law society and policy. She can be reached at acuell01@syr.edu.

membership_button_new-10