Skip to content
Beyond the Hill

From SU students to vintage fans, Plum Coyote’s style ‘attracts everybody’

From 1990s suede jackets to antique wedding dresses, Allysa Barnaba’s business, Plum Coyote, specializes in affordable vintage clothes. Barnaba’s business gained traction when she posted a TikTok launching her studio.
From 1990s suede jackets to antique wedding dresses, Allysa Barnaba’s business, Plum Coyote, specializes in affordable vintage clothes. Barnaba’s business gained traction when she posted a TikTok launching her studio. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

From Syracuse University students looking for old Victoria Secret lingerie for a sorority party to an 85-year-old woman looking for a vintage blazer to a group of Syracuse residents buying cowboy boots for a line dance, Allysa Barnaba has seen it all at her vintage clothing business.

“I think because I’ve curated an aesthetic for the store and not a type of vintage that I sell, I attract everybody,” Barnaba said.

Barnaba officially opened Plum Coyote in September. Plum Coyote is a vintage business that sells pieces anywhere from 1990s suede jackets to antique wedding dresses. Barnaba opened a studio at CNY Vintage Marketplace in downtown Syracuse where customers can book an appointment to come and shop pieces in person.

Barnaba, who grew up in Baldwinsville, moved to New York City and then Ireland after graduating high school in 2020. In Ireland, Barnaba shopped at many thrift stores, around the time her then-boyfriend sold vintage T-shirts at local Irish markets.

Barnaba advised him to expand the range of items he was selling, which led to her selling women’s vintage clothing alongside him, she said.

When she left Ireland in 2025, she took her leftover vintage clothes back to New York City and continued casually selling them on Depop while looking for a “big girl job,” Barnaba said.

While running her Depop storefront, Barnaba landed a job at a Buffalo Exchange, which expanded her passion for secondhand clothing. There, she learned how to care for vintage clothing and authenticize pieces, Barnaba said.

Within the first month of being back in Syracuse, Barnaba continued posting pieces online and would set up shop at different local events to promote her side-hustle. And she turned a profit from her sales.

A table filled with vintage jewelry, accessories and magazines rests inside the Plum Coyote studio. Plum Studio’s homey, cozy atmosphere and affordable prices stood out for customer Amanda Horn. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

By working in different vintage environments, Barnaba noticed how much the market depends on a store’s location, she said.

She found that Ireland had an overflow of items from brands she had a hard time finding in the United States. In Syracuse, she noticed the vintage market was geared toward styles like Y2K. A lot of this is because of the young college demographic in Syracuse, which she has worked to balance, Barnaba said. She started posting more about her studio and gained traction through TikTok.

SU junior policy studies major Amanda Horn came across Plum Coyote on Instagram and was drawn in because of her love of vintage shopping and the way Barnaba styled her pieces. Since being at school, Horn hasn’t had the chance to shop secondhand, so she set up an appointment at the Plum Coyote.

Horn immediately noticed Barnaba’s bubbly demeanor and the studio’s homey, cozy atmosphere. Horn got to choose different clothing styles and try them on without feeling pressured to buy anything, she said.

For Horn, Plum Coyote’s identity is clear.

“It’s a young woman who is trying to break into a very oversaturated field, and she’s trying to make it affordable, make it compassionate, really make it a comfortable space for people to try new styles,” Horn said.

To achieve that, Barnaba searches practically all day, every day. Whether it’s scrolling online shops at 2 a.m. or going to six stores in one day, Barnaba said finding pieces is a time-consuming process.

Horn liked that pricing at Plum Coyote was reasonable, especially after shopping at other vintage stores.

Barnaba once found a beautiful vintage wedding dress which she bought for “pennies” in a thrift store bin. Someone in the shop told her she could charge a higher price for the wedding dress, but she wanted a bride to be able to come in and not worry about being able to afford it, Barnaba said.

“I’m very conscious of the fact that I’m not in New York City, and I want the people of my town to be able to shop vintage and feel like they are getting a curated, luxury, fun experience when they come into the studio without having to spend $900,” Barnaba said.


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

Y2K isn’t ‘just a trend’ for SU student-founded vintage brand Releigh Freya

What started as Orezimena “Rezi” Ubogu’s attempt to clear out her closet turned into a vintage reselling brand centered on identity and confidence.


Skylar Chilson-Wood is a model from Syracuse and heard about Plum Coyote through a friend, so she reached out to Barnaba to do some modeling at her studio for the store’s social media. Chilson-Wood appreciated the environment curated in the Plum Coyote shop.

“It’s a lot more personal which I really love,” Chilson-Wood said. “When I did that shoot with her and my friend, it was just the three of us and we were there for two hours picking out our own outfits and putting together our own pieces, working together. It feels more fun, it’s like a girl’s time.”

In the next year, Barnaba hopes to own her own Syracuse storefront so that people can visit whenever, she said.

Barnaba wants to continue to grow creative spaces in Syracuse and plans to do that by building her brand through a community.

“I do love having a connection with the girls that come in,” Barnaba said. “For some reason that’s more rewarding than just somebody comes in, buys a sweater and walks out because I don’t like feeling super transactional.”

membership_button_new-10