Skip to content
men's basketball

Beat writers split on whether Syracuse can win 1st Quad 1 game vs. Indiana

Syracuse men's basketball gathers on the sideline during its win over Central Connecticut State. The Orange defeated the Blue Devils and now take on Indiana on Monday.
Syracuse men's basketball gathers on the sideline during its win over Central Connecticut State. The Orange defeated the Blue Devils and now take on Indiana on Monday. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

It only took two games to do it, but the Orange has shown what they can do when they maintain a high level of intensity for 40 consecutive minutes.

The Orange left Gerry McNamara disappointed in their season opener, giving up 41 second-half points to New Haven and allowing a 22-point halftime lead dwindle down to a 74-58 win by the final buzzer. Against Central Connecticut State, however, SU left McNamara satisfied with a dominant 53-point victory on Thursday.

It came at an opportune time, as Syracuse now turns its focus to a much more formidable opponent in Indiana. The Hoosiers have won both of their games this season, but both wins came against Quad 4 opponents. Coming off their strongest performance of the year, the Orange have the chance to secure an early Power Five victory.

Here’s how our beat writers think Syracuse (2-0, Atlantic Coast) will fare against Indiana (2-0, Big Ten) on Monday in Gainbridge Fieldhouse:

Noah Nussbaum (2-0)
Not there yet
Syracuse 68, Indiana 74

And so it begins. These are the types of games that will truly prove whether the Orange have made strides from the last three years under Adrian Autry.

There’s not much to gauge either team by, with both having played two Quad 4 opponents, so I’m just going with my gut. I don’t think Syracuse has the players to keep up with Indiana.

SU looked refreshed in the second half of the Central Connecticut game, but that’s also Central Connecticut. Syracuse still has a point guard problem to solve, with neither Ryan Moesch nor Garwey Dual showing much in the scoring category across the first two games. Moesch, however, has created chaos on the court and shown he can be a facilitator, despite being prone to turnovers.

Like everyone, Indiana dipped into the portal and grabbed players from Power Five schools, like Duke transfer Darren Harris, Villanova transfer Bryce Lindsay, Notre Dame transfer Markus Burton and Alabama transfer Aiden Sherrell. All four are averaging over 10 points across the first two games.

Syracuse has had several players impress scoring-wise over these first two games, particularly Gavin Doty and Mark Morano, while Sadiq White Jr. and Luke Wilson look like other viable options.

I just don’t see that group overwhelming Indiana like they did CCSU. Maybe I’m wrong, but I need to see more before I pick the Orange against a Power Five team.

Nicholas Alumkal (2-0)
Gauntlet gut check
Syracuse 70, Indiana 78

Syracuse had a cakewalk to start its schedule against two Northeast Conference minnows. Now, the gauntlet begins at Gainbridge Fieldhouse. In basically an away game against Indianapolis, the Orange will be put to the sword.

The Hoosiers’ backcourt features two former ACC starters in Burton and Jaeden Mustaf. Burton particularly has shown to be a prolific scorer who can light the stat sheet up. He’s done it before against SU in a 28-point showing in the 2024-25 season that ended in an Orange win over Burton’s former team, Notre Dame. Even if he doesn’t light up the box score, IU has guards who can in transfers Mustaf, Lindsay and Harris.

Syracuse, on the other hand, hasn’t found consistent guard play through two contests, albeit against inferior competition. Dual hasn’t lived up to the stratospheric hype McNamara’s bestowed upon him as one of the best defenders he’s ever seen. And Moesch grabs your attention but can’t knock down his shot consistently. There’s promise for the freshman Moesch, but it’ll be a baptism by fire Monday.

You could say the same about the post. Wilson was a passenger on the court, McNamara said in the Orange’s opener versus New Haven. The Chargers’ tallest starter was 6-foot-8. Good luck contending with Indiana’s 7-foot-2 Turkish man mountain Samet Yiğitoğlu. The already-weak SU interior defense will take another hit.

Will Syracuse battle and keep it close? Probably. Doty will scrap and grind on both ends. White will show flashes of his out-of-the-world athleticism. Morano may even knock down a few triples with his smoother-than-a-trombone-slide release.

But McNamara has admitted it: the Orange have much to improve on, but the potential is there. Monday will be an upswing but will result in a defeat.

Mauricio Palmar (2-0)
Zagging
Syracuse 75, Indiana 68

I’m taking a risk. There’s still a lot of season left to go, but I see an opportunity to take an early lead.

The logic here is simple: Indiana is just not that good. The Hoosiers have won two straight games against weak opposition, just like the Orange, but they haven’t put together a performance nearly as impressive as the game SU put together against Central Connecticut State.

Burton isn’t the same Burton he was at Notre Dame. He’s shifted his game to be more of a facilitator, a stark departure from his previous role as a high-usage maverick for the Irish. Lindsay is solid, but he’s not an alpha scorer. Neither is Sherrell. Harris is technically IU’s leading scorer with 15.0 points per game, but it’s uncertain whether he can maintain his production.

I think the Orange can get the best of Yiğitoğlu down low. I think Dual can shut down Burton’s creation. I think Doty is the best scorer on either side. And I think, in a frontcourt battle between Sherrell and White, the advantage goes to the Orange. Syracuse showed how scary it can be when it plays a complete 40 minutes, and I think McNamara won’t show up to Indianapolis with a team that isn’t ready to do that.

My fellow scribes decided to zig. I’ll opt to zag.

banned-books-01