Skip to content
Men's Basketball

Beat writers predict Syracuse drops 1st ranked matchup to No. 13 St. John’s

Syracuse fell to Indiana on Monday by three points. Our beat writers say SU drops its next Quad 1 chance Sunday against No. 13 St. John’s.
Syracuse fell to Indiana on Monday by three points. Our beat writers say SU drops its next Quad 1 chance Sunday against No. 13 St. John’s. Zoe Xixis | Asst. Photo Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

Syracuse-St. John’s throwback clash, calling to mind the halcyon days of the Big East. Jim Boeheim and Lou Carnesecca roamed the baseline. Derrick Coleman and Chris Mullin on the court.

That historical matchup returns Sunday when the Orange and Red Storm meet for the first time since 2022. The venue is Madison Square Garden, one of the sport’s most hallowed courts, a place where the Orange have made manifold Big East memories.

In SU head coach Gerry McNamara’s first season leading his alma mater, which he led to the 2006 Big East Tournament in Madison Square Garden, he’s trying to return the Orange to the heights of yore. After a commendable performance in its loss to Indiana Monday, SU has another opportunity taking on No. 13 SJU Sunday.

Will they notch a NCAA Tournament resume-building win and make another positive memory at MSG?

Here’s how our beat writers think Syracuse (2-1, Atlantic Coast) will fare against No. 13 St. John’s (3-0, Big East) Monday:

Noah Nussbaum (3-0)
No Freeman, no problem
Syracuse 70, St. John’s 85

This was meant to be the Donnie Freeman Bowl. The former Syracuse standout transferred to St. John’s in the offseason for a fresh start. But he’ll wait to make his Johnnies debut next year after tearing his Achilles in the offseason.

No matter, St. John’s is doing just fine without him and is two games into a rampage across New York, which began with convincing victories over Iona and Colgate. Syracuse will be their next victim, like the Grim Reaper knocking on its door with a trail of blood behind.

SU has made clear progress to start this season. Progress from the last three years, to be exact, despite its three-point loss to Indiana Monday. The Orange led for a good chunk of the game and continued improving from what McNamara felt was a bad season-opening win against New Haven.

That’s nothing to scoff at in their first Quad 1 test of the year. Last year, Syracuse dropped its first three Power Five games at the Players Era Festival in Las Vegas. It’s obvious this team’s different.

It’s just unfortunate the Orange follow up an encouraging result in Indianapolis with a matchup against a top-15 team in the country.

SU certainly isn’t bad; St. John’s is just on a completely different level. It has three players who can score in double digits any given night in Keyshawn Hall, Tounde Yessoufou and Ian Jackson. Each has been the Johnnies’ leading scorer in at least one of their three games thus far. If one is shut down, expect another to pop up like a Whac-A-Mole game at a carnival, overwhelming Syracuse en route to its second loss.

Nicholas Alumkal (3-0)
Red Storm rise
Syracuse 76, St. John’s 84

Thanks to The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, whenever I think about St. John’s, I can’t help but think of the parody Fallon performed with the team in 2025 to the tune of Nathan Evans’ “Wellerman.” So, here’s my attempt at a similar song predicting this game:

There’s a team from Queens with a statement to make,
And Syracuse may find it a difficult date.
For the powerhouse Johnnies, the Garden’s their home,
On Sunday, the burgeoning Orange will be far from their Dome.

Soon may the Red Storm come,
To run the floor and get it done.
The Orange will fight, but the Johnnies will win,
And the Garden will roar once more!

McNamara’s got his first year underway,
With a new-look Orange still finding their way.
Two wins and a loss, with Indiana close,
But the Garden’s a test that will show what SJU boasts.

Quinn Ellis will handle, Hall will score,
Jackson’s shooting could open the door.
The Johnnies have options, their attack, some bite,
And the Orange can’t defend for a full 40 minutes mite.

Syracuse has athleticism and a coach with pride,
But Indiana exposed how thin margins can slide.
With Rick Pitino’s pressure and pace on the floor,
The Orange will struggle to keep up with the score.

Freeman’s absence takes some sting from the game,
A former Orange forward now missing from the frame.
But the Johnnies have depth, and the Garden’s their stage,
While McNamara’s rebuilding a program in a new age.

The rivalry’s storied, the history runs deep,
But four straight Johnnie wins is a record to keep.
The Orange will compete, but the Storm has the edge,
And Sunday could push Syracuse close to the ledge.

So here’s the prediction, put the pick in the book:
St. John’s by eight. Take a good look.
The Orange may hang tough, but when crunch time arrives,
The Red Storm prevail, and the Garden comes alive!

Mauricio Palmar (2-1)
Nightmare on Ellis Street
Syracuse 73, St. John’s 84

I’m not going to be as creative as Nicholas here, unfortunately.

I’m also not going to be bold enough to pick a Syracuse upset again. Facing Indiana, I thought SU had a fairly favorable game script, and I wasn’t that far off. Markus Burton had a much better game than I anticipated, and Gavin Doty had a worse one. But Ryan Moesch showed glimpses of the shotmaking that made McNamara pursue him out of high school, and the Orange held the Hoosiers to a subpar perimeter shooting night.

St. John’s is not Indiana. To clarify, St. John’s is much better than Indiana.

Ellis isn’t the same brand of maverick shotmaker that Burton has been his whole career, but he’s arguably the country’s purest point guard — think Chris Paul. Ellis isn’t a great 3-point shooter, but that doesn’t matter when he averages nine assists per game, four steals per game and a 66.7% 2-point percentage. The only knock you could find is his pedestrian scoring average, seven points per game.

But he doesn’t need to score. His job is to find Yessoufou, Jackson and Hall. The three average over 16 points per game. They have more than enough shotmaking talent to outpace the Orange. Syracuse could dominate down low against center Ruben Prey, but if Ellis keeps kicking out to perimeter shooters, the paint probably won’t even matter.

On Sunday, the Englishman will lead the Red Storm to victory over the Orange.

banned-books-01