Skip to content
Elections 2026

Watch parties across Onondaga County celebrate ‘blue wave’ as GOP concedes

Attendants of Rep. John Mannion’s election night watch party await his arrival at The Palladian Hall at The Treasury.
Attendants of Rep. John Mannion’s election night watch party await his arrival at The Palladian Hall at The Treasury. Christian Calabrese | Asst. Photo Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

Politicians hosted watch parties across Onondaga County Tuesday night, anxiously awaiting the results of this year’s midterm elections.

From seats in Congress to the state assembly, The Daily Orange followed the races and candidates all night as crowds watched the results roll in live with local politicians.

Kailee Buller and the Onondaga GOP

Kailee Buller and press

Republican nominee for NY-22 Kailee Buller holds a press gaggle at the Onondaga County GOP watch party. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

Republican NY-22 candidate Kailee Buller and fellow Republican candidates in Onondaga County gathered at the Embassy Suites at Destiny USA for the Onondaga County GOP watch party.

Buller opened the watch party by taking questions from the press and spoke about the issues she felt were defining local and national elections. She emphasized wanting to make central New York a place her family and friends want to stay in.

“I want to fight to keep you here. I want to get your kids back here. I want to get my girlfriends back here,” Buller said. “I want to raise my kids the way I was raised alongside them. We have a lot of work to do.”

Buller clarified that she was thankful for President Donald Trump’s endorsement, but doesn’t agree with him on every issue, citing policies such as Trump’s universal tariff rollout, “tragic” mistakes made by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the war in Iran.

Despite falling behind early in the night, facing a nearly 50-point deficit after early votes had been counted, Buller remained confident throughout the race.

“I don’t lose, so we have no plans,” Buller said. “I’m just focused on winning tonight.”

At 9:55 p.m., The Associated Press called the race in favor of Democratic Incumbent Rep. John Mannion. Buller and her husband, Eric Buller, left the watch party shortly after at around 10:12 p.m.

Most attendees remained at the watch party after Buller’s departure. She later returned and took the stage at 10:52 p.m., thanking attendees for their support.

Buller said she still wants to be part of the Republican Party’s future despite the loss.

“They’re still raising our taxes and they’re raising our utility bills and someone has to keep fighting,” Buller said. “This is a rebuilding year for our party, and I plan to be part of that solution. Tonight doesn’t change the commitment to this community.”

When Buller was asked what’s next for her politically, she responded: “I’ll let you guys know.”

Buller spent the rest of the night speaking to the press and embracing her supporters.

Rich McCarron

Republican Nominee for State Senate in New York’s 48th district Rich McCarron takes the stage late in the evening, declares the night “a good old fashioned shellacking” for Republicans. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

Later in the night, Republican nominee for State Senate in NY’s 48th District Rich McCarron took the stage and thanked attendees for their support after his loss to Democratic incumbent Sen. Rachel May.

“It’s really time for us to look inside and try to reconnect with the public better and redefine who we are as a party,” McCarron said.

John Mannion and supporters

Attendees of Rep. John Mannion’s Election night watch ABC news election coverage. Christian Calabrese | Asst. Photo Editor

After doors opened at The Palladian Hall at The Treasury for Democratic Incumbent Rep. John Mannion’s watch party, an R&B cover band, The Blacklites, played songs including The Spinners’ “I’ll Be Around,” and Earth, Wind & Fire’s “September.”

Political analysts heavily favored Mannion over Buller before Election Day. Several guests huddled around a small TV displaying early election results from ABC News.

Syracuse Mayor Sharon Owens made an appearance shortly after 9 p.m., and said although she hoped Mannion would focus more on housing for the new term, she felt he always has the “community in mind.”

“There’s what people say, and then there’s what people do. With John, I can get on the phone,” Owens said. “I can talk to him. I can go meet him at a meeting, or just see him in the neighborhood, and he will respond, particularly when it’s been with ICE activities in our community.”

Attendee Roy Tracy said he’s personally known Mannion and his wife for over 15 years. Tracy was visiting in support of his home within District 21, hoping to witness Mannion’s reelection victory.

“When we have our private conversations, we just agree on a lot of things about decency and people being good to one another,” Tracy said. “One of the most important things John has said to me is that we just need to reach across the aisle and love each other.”

Tracy emphasized Mannion’s love for the community and his high hopes for Mannion’s second term in Congress.

“No matter what he does in his policy, he’s going to advocate for the people,” Tracy said.

Rep John Mannion sings “Lovely Day” by Bill Withers to a crowd of supporters at his Election night watch party. Christian Calabrese | Asst. Photo Editor

After much anticipation, Mannion and his wife greeted the crowd after his victory over Buller. The band, playing “Lovely Day” by Bill Withers, gave Mannion the microphone as he led the crowd in song.

“Today’s a lovely day in central New York,” Mannion said, beginning his speech after the song ended.

In his victory speech, Mannion thanked his family and the Syracuse community, reciting his family’s history in the area. He also criticized inflation and Trump’s recent deal for Russian diesel.

“We know we’re not better today than we were a few years ago, but we’re all going to make it better together,” Mannion said.

Later in the night, Buller claimed during her remarks at the Onondaga County GOP watch party that Mannion hung up the phone when she called to congratulate him on his reelection. Buller called Mannion’s behavior “disgusting.”

A campaign spokesperson for Mannion responded to Buller’s claim, saying her story was false.

“We wished her and her family the best,” his spokesperson said. “The accusations are a big nothing burger.”

Maurice “Mo” Brown and the Onondaga County Democratic Committee

Rachel May

In her victory speech, Sen. Rachel May speaks to attendees of the Onondaga County Democratic Committee’s election night watch party about the importance of holding politicians accountable. Avery Magee | Development Editor

At The Mizpah, near Palladian Hall, Maurice “Mo” Brown and fellow members of the Onondaga County Democratic Committee hosted their own election night watch party. In an opening press gaggle, Brown spoke about his priorities should he be elected to state assembly, such as making the area more affordable and addressing cuts to Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits.

“I want to do a lot of things around rent and stabilizing it, but just fundamentally it’s housing, it’s energy, it’s just making sure that people are able to get what they need,” Brown said. “I think that this is a time for us to come together as a community. I think that my vision, our vision, for central New York is one that will unite us.”

Later in the night, New York State Sen. Chris Ryan gave a victory speech before his race was called as early polling put him ahead of Republican James Corl by over 20%. Incumbent New York state Sen. Rachel May followed Ryan, leading by the same margin, urging Americans to be “decent human beings,” and hold politicians accountable.

“We have been able to see up close what it looks like when Democrats are in charge,” May said. “They’ve been transparent, they’ve been accountable, they have been looking to the voters to tell them what they care about.”

After attending John Mannion’s watch party, Syracuse City Mayor Sharon Owens took the stage at the Onondaga County Democratic Committee’s election night, telling attendees to expect more Democratic wins throughout the night. Avery Magee | Development Editor

Owens was also in attendance, along with Onondaga County Legislature elect Jo Bennett, representatives from CNY Solidarity Coalition and the Onondaga County Young Democrats. While on stage, Owens, having just come from Mannion’s watch party, told the crowd to expect more wins throughout the night.

Although a few of the races were still too close to call, Democratic Legislature Chairwoman Nicole Watts announced that the OCDC had reached a supermajority, calling up the candidates onto the stage.

“One year ago, we flipped the (legislature) and look at this, we have a supermajority,” Watts said. “Let’s make this a four years that Onondaga County will never forget.”

In his victory speech, Brown called up several of his supporters onto the stage, thanking them for their hard work and dedication during his campaign.

“This was not done alone, this wasn’t a solo project. This was a lot of people who saw what was going on in their community and they stood up and they fought back,” Brown said. “What we’re seeing around the country, this blue wave, is a response, but it’s also a message: the people need government that works for them.”

While the event ended promptly at midnight, most races, including Brown’s, weren’t called until around 1:00 a.m. on Wednesday.

Staff Writer Ben Lofy contributed reporting to this article.

membership_button_new-10