Skip to content
Column

Who will be the men to condemn, abolish the structures that protect them?

Our columnist challenges frequent institutional protection of fraternities, like Cornell’s Chi Phi. He says members must confront harmful behavior and hold one another accountable, even when it means standing against their peers.
Our columnist challenges frequent institutional protection of fraternities, like Cornell’s Chi Phi. He says members must confront harmful behavior and hold one another accountable, even when it means standing against their peers. Kendall Thompson | Contributing Illustrator

Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.

On Oct. 19, 2024, seven men allegedly drugged and gang-raped a 20-year-old Cornell University student known as Jane Doe. Earlier that night, Doe had been drinking and partying when a friend suggested a threesome with fraternity brothers, CBS reported. What began as a sexual proposal turned into an infliction of emotional and physical violation.

The idea of a threesome was cast aside by Doe and her friend as the night gave away, but the men didn’t comply. Instead, they allegedly groped, drugged and gang-raped Doe while documenting and communicating their actions through social media.

Since The Cornell Daily Sun released its initial article on the incident, it’s received national attention, shedding light on Title IX processes at universities across the country.

Seven men and Cornell’s Chi Phi Fraternity were placed on disciplinary suspension, some eventually facing expulsion. But Doe was still left to face trauma and additional online scrutiny that criticized possible narrative inconsistencies, credibility and identity.

The disconnect between support and retribution of alleged assault survivors shows how some Greek life establishments keep cases of sexual abuse within their own walls.

On many Greek-life affiliated campuses, fraternities are notorious for having a morally ambiguous structure and behavior. They allegedly partake in hazing and are villanized as enablers of mental and physical distress.

At Cornell, a former Chi Phi member stated they and others have been subject to hazing rituals that include, but aren’t limited to, sexual battery and assault. They argued that beyond the individual punishments, it’s negligent to ignore the alumni endowments and status that protect fraternities.

Cases like Cornell’s don’t universally embody Greek life. Yet it’s disingenuous not to acknowledge the overwhelming, recognized pattern of degenerative actions enabled across nationwide charters.

Doe’s alleged experience isn’t singular. It’s rhymed against decades of experiences where people within and outside Greek life have been subject to harassment or invalidation.

The disconnect in support and retribution to alleged, assault survivors represents the systems of containment present in Greek-life affiliated cases of sexual abuse.
Albert Alvarado, Columnist

On occasion, there are many instances where women can feel uncomfortable around fraternities, their parties or their members. On occasion, there are many instances where women feel the words and actions of fraternities or members don’t match their character and behavior.

It isn’t only women who feel this way. But it has and always will be women who disproportionately experience harassment and assault.

When fraternity members who are aware of reported and unreported activity only condemn these incidents through social media and not action, it’s insincere. When universities give disciplinary actions that don’t repudiate alleged perpetrators and dismiss their pasts, it’s violence.

It attacks the severity of these topics and creates continuous atmospheres of unsafety. It reaffirms that no matter what corroboration a plaintiff provides, there’s a wall of power that seems insurmountable to climb.

So, who will be the men to acknowledge these structures and break them? Who will be the men who won’t let their friends or fraternity brothers be absolved from consequence?

Doe may be your friend, partner, sister, brother, parent or someone else you care about. The grounds for change aren’t a one-time Instagram like or repost.

The call to action extends beyond doing the right thing once. We can’t be discouraged by potential reprimand or ending relationships. This responsibility won’t come today or tomorrow.

It arrived yesterday.

Albert Alvarado is a junior majoring in English and television, radio and film. He can be reached at aalvar38@syr.edu.

membership_button_new-10