Skip to content

Defense, prosecution give closing remarks in Shaw case

In one of the final days of the Brian T. Shaw trial, attorneys for the prosecution and defense gave their closing arguments during a short morning session.

The jury has been presented with several options when issuing a verdict: the second-degree murder or first-degree manslaughter of Chiarra Seals, the mother of his 4-year-old daughter, and endangering the welfare of a child. Second-degree murder applies to a killing done in the heat of the moment; in other words, the crime was not premeditated. First-degree manslaughter includes the application of emotional disturbance, a key point in Defense Attorney Thomas Ryan’s case.

Ryan pushed for the option of second-degree homicide, which only implies recklessness on the part of the defendant, after Tuesday’s proceedings, but was denied his motion by Judge Joseph E. Fahey.

Ryan was required to speak first on his client’s behalf, and urged the jury to apply its knowledge and life experiences when choosing a verdict.

‘This is the most significant decision many of you may ever make,’ Ryan said, adding that it was certainly the most important one of Shaw’s life.

Ryan told the jury to consider all facts from his client’s point of view when coming to a decision, and not to hesitate to acquit if it could not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

‘You, as jurors, have more information than any witness,’ Ryan said.

Both Ryan and Assistant District Attorney Michael Spano stated the case comes down to two simple issues: whether Shaw did in fact kill Seals and if he intended to do so.

Spano said there could be no doubt that Shaw killed Seals, and that he hoped the jury wouldn’t spend time debating this issue. As far as intent to kill, Spano said, this case was not about premeditation, but about Shaw’s thoughts in the heat of the moment.

‘At the moment he’s squeezing the life out of Chiarra Seals, he intended to kill her,’ Spano said.

Ryan brought up Spano’s discussion of Shaw’s ‘systematic cover-up’ of the crime, as well as a ‘systematic analysis’ of the crime scenes by the police. Neither of these statements are true, Ryan said, continuing to draw upon what he viewed as inadequacies on the part of the Syracuse Police Department, including speculative video narration, a lack of mental health training and little to no follow-up on certain pieces of evidence.

‘Why did Mr. Ryan spend the bulk of his time on the police investigator?’ Spano asked the jury during his closing statements. ‘Because it’s a trick. It’s a lawyer trick to distract you from my case.’

Spano said the case involved an overwhelming amount of evidence that Shaw was staging a cover-up. He questioned why Shaw would leave the back door of the car open if all he was doing was re-entering the house to check on Seals, and why Shaw didn’t just ring the doorbell to get back in, since he knew Essence could open a door.

‘All the stars lined up for him to get away with murder,’ Spano said.

Ryan cited the text messages in Shaw’s phone, which could easily have been deleted, as proof that he was not trying to cover up his actions. He also employed testimony by Dr. Thomas Lazzaro, a forensic psychologist, who said Shaw’s ‘out-of-body’ feelings were consistent with extreme emotional distress.

‘Yes, he knows that something that happened was wrong, but he is still not able to make sense of it all,’ Ryan said.

After Fahey instructed the jury on its task, court was dismissed.

The afternoon consisted of several hours of jury deliberations, with two moments for the court to come together to clarify a few things for the jury.

In the state of New York court system, if a jury has a question, they must submit it in writing to the judge, said Celeste Shaw, mother of the defendant, who was told this information by Ryan.

The jury brought three requests to Fahey for the first submission of questions. It wanted a definition of the word intent, a chance to watch the footage of the Jasper Street crime scene and Shaw’s testimony of the fight between him and Seals. Fahey granted its request and all items were defined, shown and recited for the jury.

The second time the jury requested more information from the court, it asked again for a definition of the word intent.

At the end of the day, Celeste Shaw said she was very excited the jury would ask for the definition twice, which she said she thinks is a good sign.

Ryan could not be reached for comment after the trial because he stayed longer to speak with Fahey and court security guards asked everyone else to leave the building so they could lock up the building.

No members of the Seals family wished to comment on the trial today.

Spano said he is pleased with how the trial went on Wednesday. He was not surprised the jury asked for the definition twice and was not surprised that deliberations were extended to today.

Spano said he thinks the jury will come to a verdict sometime today.

Court will resume today at 9 a.m.