Trump’s implemented changes to mail-in voting are manipulative, untimely
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.
On Sept.14, an unsigned emergency order from the U.S. Supreme Court put an end to the proposed changes President Donald Trump ordered the U.S. Postal Service to make to mail-in voting standards.
This comes after years of comments questioning the nature and integrity of federal and state elections by the president, dating back to his first term.
“Get rid of ballot harvesting, it is rampant with fraud,” Trump posted on X in 2020. “The USA must have voter I.D., the only way to get an honest count!”
While his past rhetoric had a large impact on public trust in officials, Trump’s recent attempts to change the system have had a far greater effect since his reelection in 2024.
“USPS lacks the technical or operational capability needed to effectively implement the EO’s provisions in a way that safeguards every citizen’s right to vote in the upcoming midterm elections,” read a report sent by Sen. Richard Blumenthal on behalf of an anonymous whistleblower. “Despite this, the Trump Administration appears intent on USPS moving forward with its flawed plans, no matter the chaos they may create.”
The order mentioned in the letter, “Ensuring Citizenship Verification and Integrity in Federal Elections,” ordered the Department of Homeland Security to compile a list of eligible voters and transmit it to election officials. It also directed the Postal Service to enforce new standards for mail-in ballots.
The main concern of the whistleblower memo was that the Postal Service wouldn’t be able to finalize changes and provide ballots to voters and election officials, potentially leaving millions disenfranchised.
Trump said the changes would prevent ineligible and noncitizen voters from accessing ballots, safeguarding elections from fraud.
But these changes are unnecessary and would drain time and money away from an already cut and underfunded federal workforce far too close to the midterms.
The executive order failed to clear the courts for numerous reasons.

Zoey Grimes | Design Editor
Elections Clause powers are split between the states and Congress. States set their own regulations while Congress can override any decision.
The Postal Service can adopt rules governing its operations, and this would fit many of the postage rules in the order. But voter lists kept by the Postal Service that exclude voters on state lists would contradict the preexisting order that used state-made lists to order mail-in voters.
Timing was much more damning than the provisions to implementation. The Purcell Principle is a legal doctrine under which federal courts avoid changing election standards close to an election to avoid confusing voters and election officials.
Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh said applying these changes to the 2026 elections would be “arbitrary and capricious.” But he also left room for reconsideration after the election, claiming Trump’s proposals may be within the capabilities of the Postal Service.
Kavanaugh is correct. While there may be a way to implement some of these changes in the future, enforcing them this close to the midterms is ridiculous.
This legal battle isn’t the first time the president has brought attention to voting. Since the 2020 presidential election, Trump has voiced serious concerns about the integrity of voting, specifically via mail. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, absentee voting excuses were expanded, making it considerably easier to access absentee ballots.
Trump’s election fraud claims focused on coordinated attempts by political opponents to register noncitizens to vote, yet the evidence is weak. Statistics on the topic are hard to find, and most are heavily disputed. The largest audited figure is provided by the Associated Press, which found 475 potential cases among 25.5 million ballots cast in six battleground states.
This means fraudulent ballots cast by noncitizens would represent 0.0002% of ballots cast, hardly the endemic problem of 250,000 noncitizen voters that Trump’s DHS continues to claim.
The narrative that Trump continuously purports is part of his larger strategy to never admit defeat or concede the truth despite evidence to the contrary. Now in power, this narrative affects our system.
The president’s recent focus on mail-in voting isn’t an effort to curb fraud. It’s a tool of confusion meant to aid the Republican Party in upcoming midterms slated to be a turning point against the Republican trifecta.
Narrative building also plays a crucial role. Statements made now could later be used to challenge election results. This tactic was used in 2020 and culminated in 60 lawsuits targeted at throwing out ballots, calls to state election officials and a request to have former Vice President Mike Pence refuse to certify the 2020 election results on Jan. 6.
The dismissal of the executive order adds fuel to the narrative fire. Unimplemented changes are a perfect springboard for potential recounts and litigation, further complicating our electoral process.
Trump’s decision to discredit and bog down our electoral system is a major issue. The worst consequences of untimely changes to mail-in voting have been avoided, but his battle against the system isn’t over. With two more years left in his second term, you can expect a continued verbal assault on integrity and fresh legal challenges around the corner.
Declan Berry is a freshman majoring in journalism and data science. He can be reached at deberry@syr.edu.

