SU commit Kaitlin Millett adapts into Cold Spring Harbor’s ‘lockdown’ player
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe to our sports newsletter here.
Kaitlin Millett didn’t need to wait long to decide where she wanted to go to college.
Millett, a standout junior midfielder at Cold Spring Harbor High School (New York), needed just one visit to Syracuse to cement her decision. She loved Syracuse’s sports marketing program and envisioned herself participating in it.
Some old Cold Spring Harbor teammates, transfer goalie Maya Soskin and 2027 four-star Olivia Mulada, were already committed to SU. Millett immediately connected with the coaching staff, who helmed a top-tier Atlantic Coast Conference program. The coaches also carried a strong reputation among CSH alumni.
But above all, Millett’s JMA Wireless Dome trip sealed her commitment. Watching a Syracuse football game on Sept. 5, when it blew out New Hampshire, Millett began picturing herself on the field. She canceled her remaining visits.
“I was like, ‘This is where I’m going to play,’” Millett said.
Millett — a four-star and Inside Lacrosse’s No. 35 junior prospect — officially committed to Syracuse on Sept. 8, becoming the fifth member of its 2028 recruiting class. Before that, she established herself as a two-way star for CSH after transitioning from defense to midfield late in her sophomore season. That year, Millett scored 25 goals and added five assists to help the Seahawks to their third straight Class D New York State Championship.
But it was during that 2026 postseason when she found another gear, emerging as a player CSH could rely on in its biggest moments. Cold Spring Harbor head coach Danielle Castellane increased Millett’s playing time down the stretch, and the midfielder capitalized by finishing second on the team in postseason goals and assists.
“She just completely transitioned to a different type of player come the last five weeks of the season,” Castellane said.
Millett said she focused on her offense, especially dodging and fitness, while continuing to rely on defensive ability. The increased opportunity jolted her confidence, which was evident in the state championship game.
After scoring a couple goals, Millett said she realized she could continue her impact.
“Once I had a couple goals in, I was like, ‘All right, we’re winning this,’” she said. “And then I just kept going from there.”
Millett ended the game with five goals en route to CSH’s championship, and she finished her postseason with 11 goals and an assist. The numbers nearly eclipsed her regular-season totals of 14 scores and four assists.

Cold Spring Harbor midfielder Kaitlin Millett poses in her Syracuse women’s lacrosse jersey. She pledged to SU on Sept. 8, as its coaches noted her two-sided prowess with defensive roots. Courtesy of Kaitlin Millett
The postseason culminated Millett’s yearlong development. She said confidence was the biggest difference between her freshman and sophomore seasons. Millett began trusting her ability to make plays with the ball, something she worked on throughout her sophomore year.
Castellane began expecting her to dominate with the ball, earn possessions and play strong defense in crucial moments through her versatility. At 5-foot-10, she uses size and speed to cover midfield ground quickly while continuing her defensive impact.
Her athleticism extends beyond the lacrosse field. She also plays basketball during the winter and previously played tennis in the fall, allowing her to stay active and develop different aspects of her athleticism, like her speed.
“She’s a Swiss Army Knife,” Castellane said.
That adaptability is especially valuable at CSH, a school with roughly 100 students per grade. Castellane said a player who contributes in multiple areas gives the Seahawks flexibility.
“She can be used in so many different areas,” Castellane said.
That ability to impact the game in different ways also captivated Millett’s club coach, Al Bertolone. For the past three years, he’s coached her with the Long Island Yellow Jackets, where her Bert/Maget 2028 team ranks seventh in the country. While Millett became a more complete offensive player, Bertolone said her defensive ability remained her defining strength.
“She’s a four-star midfielder, but she’s a five-star defender,” Bertolone said. “She’s lockdown everywhere.”
Bertolone saw that firsthand early this past season, when he assigned Millett to defend Peyla Carcaterra, Inside Lacrosse’s No. 2 player in the 2028 class, in the Yellow Jackets’ matchup against Prime Time Lacrosse. Millett held Carcaterra scoreless, reinforcing what Bertolone saw: the ability to take and embrace the toughest assignment.
She’s a four-star midfielder, but she’s a five-star defender. She's lockdown everywhere.Al Bertolone, Long Island Yellow Jackets head coach
Initially, that defensive ability drew Syracuse to Millett. The Orange first recruited her as a defender, but her development on both ends of the field has opened possibilities of a larger role at Syracuse.
Her mother, Shannon Millett, tried leaving the decision to her daughter. But the people around Millett helped her understand what Syracuse could offer.
Bertolone spoke highly of Syracuse head coach Regy Thorpe and the program’s culture, while Millett’s visit allowed her to experience it herself.
“She was really impressed with the coaches,” Shannon said. “She loved the facilities, she loved the Dome, she loved the town. It was just everything she was looking for.”
Millett has two years at CSH before her next chapter. And if you ask Castellane, her sophomore postseason breakout was only the beginning.
“She definitely laid the groundwork,” Castellane said. “I’m excited to see what she does in the next two years.”

