How an ex-SU student, now Florida retiree welcomes life as Palm Beach Pete
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.
NEW YORK — It’s 9:30 p.m. on a Thursday night in October. Peter Simel, 71, just appeared on the UpDating Show at City Winery at Pier 57. Before Simel can make it down the venue’s stairs and out the door, he’s met by throngs of fans. Whether they’re asking for a selfie or congratulating Simel on his feature, about 10 groups of fans swarm Simel before he can escape the venue.
When Simel finally exits the building onto the sidewalk, he’s surrounded by more crowds — but it’s just another day in Simel’s retirement life as an influencer.
“I was a little bored, and this whole influencer thing kind of fell in my lap,” Simel said. “How many people at my age can say they make fun content, hang out with the coolest influencers, make money from it and have a blast? I don’t think many people can.”
Before Simel was known by the sobriquet Palm Beach Pete, he was a recent retiree living in Palm Beach, Florida, who had briefly attended Syracuse University.
One day in March, Simel was driving from Palm Beach to Boca Raton, Florida, to play tennis. Wearing a backwards baseball cap and driving with the top down in his convertible, an observer filmed Simel unbeknownst to him.
With an on-screen caption that said “Epstein out here in South Florida,” the video blew up, amassing over 10 million views. But it wasn’t the disgraced Jeffrey Epstein — it was Simel.
When the video first gained traction, Simel said his phone was dead. After he finally opened his phone, he was met with several texts from friends and family, including his “honorary” nephew, Justin Friedman.
Friedman told Simel they were “going to make a brand out of this,” Simel said. Months later, he’s accumulated over 385,000 Instagram followers and 1.2 million TikTok followers.
When Simel attended SU in the 1970s, his friends, like Michael Lewis, described him as “a happy-go-lucky guy.” Since turning into Palm Beach Pete, that persona hasn’t changed, Lewis said.
Simel originally attended Temple University for tennis, but he didn’t enjoy it. So in January 1974, he transferred to SU — his mom’s alma mater — where he lived in Watson Hall. At SU, Simel joined a fraternity and studied accounting, but he left early before he could graduate in 1977.
“I spent almost three years there, and I wasn’t taking my studies seriously enough. So I came home, and I studied at home,” Simel said. “I was popular.”

After attending Temple University to play tennis, Peter Simel transferred to Syracuse University in January 1974. Despite leaving before he could graduate, Simel said his outgoing personality flourished during his time at SU. Courtesy of Peter Simel
Simel and Lewis have known each other since their days at SU, when they met in an egg fight between their rival fraternities. Lewis, who graduated from SU in 1976, said he and Simel instantly became friends and have talked every day since.
Lewis has been with Simel when crowds gathered next to their dinner table at a restaurant or when passersby ask Simel for a selfie on the sidewalk. Before the viral video of Simel, Lewis said he had never made the connection between Simel and his lookalike.
“I know he’s not Epstein,” Lewis said.
However, other longtime connections, like 32-year-old Friedman, said Simel’s resemblance to Epstein has been a running joke in his family for years. March wasn’t the first time that Simel had been chronicled as an Epstein doppelganger.
A few months before Simel went viral, Friedman said he was out with two people. Friedman and one of the others both claimed they knew an Epstein lookalike: Simel.
In the early days of Simel’s virality, he played into his lookalike — even coining the handle “Not Jeff Epstein” on Instagram. Soon after, Simel was deplatformed by Instagram. He posted a TikTok addressed to Mark Zuckerberg in response to clarify his creative intentions.
The day after the video went viral, Simel was contacted by producers from “Jimmy Kimmel Live!” about appearing in a segment on the show, which he did in March.
After that, Simel’s Instagram account was back up, but he and Friedman wanted to steer away from the Epstein references.
“We distanced and always denied that I was not him, that I’m just Palm Beach Pete living my life,” Simel said. “So we do a little rage baiting because that’s what draws eyeballs, obviously, but we totally stay away from that whole Epstein vibe and whatnot.”
That’s why Simel prefers being called Palm Beach Pete.
“There’s a level of satire to the page, by him saying he’s not him, he’s ultimately playing into it, and that’s naturally the correlation is gonna exist,” Friedman said. “There is a bit of natural rage baiting that comes from it.”
Friedman, who lives in Brooklyn, is not only Simel’s “nephew,” but his manager, too. When Friedman saw the viral video, he knew Simel had influencer potential.
Other friends of Simel’s, like Nadine Marder, have mixed feelings about Palm Beach Pete, especially since people associate him with Epstein.
“He’s the only person I know who could probably enjoy that kind of attention,” Marder said. “I’m upset with the fact that he’s aligned with not a great person.”
Marder has known Simel for over 40 years, since they both met at SU. Even after Marder transferred to another school, the pair remained friends and found themselves both working in the fashion industry.
Before retiring, Simel owned a denim showroom and then worked in commercial real estate in New York City. However, creating videos and interacting with fans fits Simel’s “social and outgoing” personality, Friedman said.

Peter Simel smiles while walking on a New York City sidewalk. Also known as Palm Beach Pete, Simel has amassed more than 385,000 Instagram followers and 1.2 million TikTok followers. Paul Hakimain | Staff Photographer
After his UpDating Show feature, some fans couldn’t get enough of Simel. Groups of college-aged kids followed Simel as he walked about seven blocks to his after-party. It wasn’t because they were invited; it was because they wanted more photos of him.
But Simel didn’t mind.
He sported green Adidas Gazelles, navy trousers, a blue button-up, a gray vest and a bright red Supreme phone case, to relate to his primarily “Gen Z audience.”
Since March, Simel’s been featured on The Nicky Gordo Show (also known as “Fat Nick”), The Alex Jones Show, cameos and brand deals. He even decided to run for mayor of Palm Beach, Florida.
Free Botox. Expanded pickleball and tennis courts. Free to use tennis courts. Free tennis lessons. These are among some of Simel’s goals for his mayoral race platform.
After interviewing Palm Beach residents, Simel hopes to address the needs of locals. Simel, who will be running as an independent for the 2028 mayoral election, said transparency is the most important part of his race.
The idea to run for mayor came about one day when Simel was filming on the beach. He said Friedman had always referred to him as Palm Beach’s mayor because of how many people he knew, so Simel thought, why not make it official.
Although SU didn’t play a major role in Simel’s career trajectory or Palm Beach Pete’s journey, Simel said it was the place where his amiability flourished.
WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT
I went to see Clavicular live (so you didn’t have to). It was weird.
Internet personality Clavicular hosted a livestream Friday at Jammer’s Sports Bar & Restaurant.
“The first day, he called me and told me this craziness, and I immediately looked at the picture of him driving in the convertible and saw the video,” Lewis said. “Only you, Peter. Couldn’t happen to a nicer guy.”
Becoming an influencer wasn’t part of Simel’s life plans. At SU, he dreamt of retiring at 35-years-old on the French Riviera, he said. Still, Simel said he hasn’t changed much.
“My personality is like how you see me: outgoing, friendly, curious,” he said. “I like aesthetic culture. I was well into that from an early age, so it really hasn’t changed much. Now it’s on a bigger scale.”

