Amid QB fiasco, Syracuse drops 11th straight ACC game to Louisville 34-26
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe to our sports newsletter here.
There were two minutes left, and Syracuse was running the ball. No, the Orange hadn’t put the game away, and they weren’t out of it either. They were down by eight to Louisville, a one-possession game.
But that’s just how it goes when you’re on your fourth string quarterback — again.
Syracuse’s quarterback room is consistently inconsistent. The week leading up to Saturday’s matchup, Fran Brown couldn’t pinpoint which of four quarterbacks would start.
Steve Angeli had an injection in his Achilles, Amari Odom tore something in his shoulder and Malachi Nelson had a collarbone issue. Danny Lauter wasn’t injured, but he’s still SU’s fourth string.
Nelson started against Louisville after being cleared, and he kept Syracuse in it. Then, he got hurt again. Lauter was forced in. Instead of passing the ball like he did in his late cameo last week against Virginia, Lauter took a backseat and handed the ball off.
“He’s a fourth-string guy. You don’t want, ‘Hey, Danny, come and throw it,’” Brown said postgame. “So it’s just something to help him.”
The decision — and Syracuse’s quarterback carousel — epitomizes the Orange’s struggles as they navigate one of the program’s worst stretches ever. In his second straight start, Nelson threw for 315 yards yet had three turnovers, leading to Syracuse’s (2-4, 0-4 Atlantic Coast), 34-26 loss to Louisville (4-3, 3-2 ACC). It marked SU’s 11th straight conference loss dating back to its win over Clemson last September, the second-longest conference losing streak in program history behind a 12-game skid from 2005-06.
“I’m a fan. I want to win. We gotta make another play,” Brown said. “It’s one or two plays away from it.”
Syracuse’s players insisted on Tuesday that little has changed internally despite the quarterback roulette. Both Lauter and Brown emphasized that they’re all prepared to play each week.
But it made a difference against the Cavaliers when Lauter was forced to enter in the fourth quarter following Nelson’s injury. Sixth-year receiver Umari Hatcher, who’s been SU’s consistent No. 1 target no matter the quarterback, said he’d only caught about three passes from Lauter in practice last week before Lauter closed the game at UVA.
WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT
Observations from SU’s 34-26 loss to UL: Hatcher’s hot, QBs inconsistent
Both Malachi Nelson and Lincoln Kienholz had inconsistent days under center, throwing four combined interceptions Saturday against Louisville. But Kienholz’s three total touchdowns sealed Syracuse’s 11th consecutive ACC loss.
Syracuse is certainly better positioned in terms of its backups than last year. SU isn’t getting blown out anymore, Brown emphasized, it’s now played three one-possession games in ACC play.
“We played with the third-string quarterback today, two weeks in a row we’ve been able to play with him, and we’ve been able to function,” Brown said. “That’s growth from last year.”
Still, a third-string quarterback is a third-string quarterback. Nelson may be the former No. 1 overall recruit in the 2023 class, but he’s third on the depth chart for a reason, and he showed it with his turnovers Saturday.
Angeli and Odom’s injuries have backed Syracuse into a corner and forced it to stick by Nelson, though. Brown said postgame he didn’t know if they’d be back. Nelson was also unavailable to the media while undergoing treatment on both leg and shoulder injuries.
The only thing SU had going for it was Louisville also having no clue who the Orange were starting. Head coach Jeff Brohm said postgame the Cardinals prepared to face all four of Syracuse’s signal-callers.
“We knew one was going to be a little bit more of a runner. We knew Malachi could do both. He could throw the ball accurate, but he could get outside the pocket as well and scramble and make plays, and he did that,” Brohm said.
Like he did against UVA, Nelson started hot. Just over six minutes in, he’d already connected with Umari Hatcher twice, the second a 41-yard touchdown on a go ball down the left sideline. That grab, part of Hatcher’s 224-yard day, gave SU a 10-0 lead.
But the Orange couldn’t hold. They’d already blown double-digit advantages in back-to-back games, barely surviving UConn and falling at UVA. This was a third.
Initially, Nelson wasn’t the issue. Syracuse’s defense was, failing to stop a Cardinals offense that averaged the second-most points in the ACC. Louisville took a 14-10 lead after Lincoln Kienholz housed an 82-yard quarterback keeper.
It was just about whether Nelson could keep up. In other words, would Syracuse pay for its injuries under center?

Syracuse quarterback Malachi Nelson readies for a shotgun snap in Saturday’s 34-26 loss to Louisville. The typical third-string signal caller threw for 315 yards, two touchdowns and two interceptions. Avery Magee | Development Editor
Nelson led two touchdown drives to enter halftime down 28-23, but that’s when he capitulated. He was labeled a bust after one-year stops at USC, Boise State and UTEP. That version of Nelson flared up with his second-half giveaways.
Two were interceptions, the Orange’s eighth and ninth this year. Angeli threw five to kill momentum in losses to Cal and Pitt, and Odom tossed two that almost led to a defeat at UConn. The Orange keep hurting themselves like they have all season.
“We just got to make better decisions, them as players, us as coaches,” Brown said when asked about Nelson’s turnovers. “There’s better decisions on both ends, not just as a player, but as a caller, just everything that we’re doing.”
Louisville didn’t even need much in the second half — it scored six points. It didn’t even establish a two-score lead.
But with Nelson struggling and Brown forced to turn to Lauter again, Syracuse made sure Brohm didn’t even break a sweat on the final drive. The game ended unceremoniously when Ahmad Miller was stuffed on a fourth-down run with 45 seconds left.
Though Brown should get praise for obtaining backup quarterback options from the portal and staying in games with them, SU needs wins at some point. And so far, it isn’t happening.
That will get harder the further the Orange go down the depth chart. It proved true on Saturday.

