Observations from SU’s 34-26 loss to UL: Hatcher’s hot, QBs inconsistent
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe to our sports newsletter here.
Last week, Syracuse’s losing streak in Atlantic Coast Conference games — which dates back to Sept. 27, 2025 — reached 10. Down to their fourth-string quarterback, the Orange attempted to cobble together a late comeback, but it wasn’t enough to avoid a 28-25 loss.
A week later, the venue and the opponent changed. Unfortunately for SU, the outcome didn’t.
Louisville (4-3, 3-2 ACC) gashed Syracuse’s (2-4, 0-4 ACC) defense early in its 34-26 victory over the Orange Saturday night, rebounding from an early 10-0 deficit to outscore them 34-16 from that point on. Now, SU’s ACC losing streak is up to 11 games, and the Orange are heading back to the drawing board once again.
Here are some observations from Syracuse’s 34-26 home defeat Saturday:
Hatcher’s on a heater
On the first play of the game, Malachi Nelson dropped back. Nelson, who began the season as Syracuse’s third-string quarterback, was looking for an easy target to get things started.
He found him. Of course he found Umari Hatcher.
Hatcher, SU’s sixth-year receiver, has been a beacon of consistency for a Syracuse offense that’s seen four different quarterbacks under center this season. He entered Saturday leading the Orange with 560 receiving yards and six receiving touchdowns.
So, on the first pass of Nelson’s second Syracuse start, it’s no surprise he found Hatcher streaking down the sideline, getting loose for a 65-yard completion. That drive stalled out after that, ending with a 26-yard Shay Barker field goal, but Hatcher didn’t have to wait long to cash in. On the next drive, Hatcher was bombing down the sideline again.
This time, when Nelson found him, he gave Syracuse a 10-0 lead with a 41-yard touchdown. That score set the tone for Hatcher’s 224-yard day.
Lincoln logs first-half TDs
Louisville quarterback Lincoln Kienholz got off to a mightily rough start in the Dome on Saturday, going three-and-out in his first drive, throwing a panicked lateral on his second drive and tossing an interception directly into Davien Kerr’s arms to set up SU’s first touchdown of the game.
He wasn’t going to remain down for long. He entered Saturday with 1,534 passing yards, eight rushing touchdowns and nine passing scores to just one interception. It wasn’t a matter of if Kienholz was going to get comfortable in this game, but when.
The answer was at about the 6:35 mark of the first quarter. That’s when he connected with Lawayne McCoy for a 40-yard pass, setting up Louisville’s first touchdown of the game a play later.
On his next drive, Kienholz didn’t even need his arm to do the work for him. He did it all with his legs, scampering past Syracuse’s defense for an 82-yard score. When SU responded with a touchdown to make it 16-14 in the second quarter, Kienholz bounced right back with a 48-yard completion to Tre Richardson. Kienholz then punched in a one-yard score for a 21-16 lead.
But in the second half, he reverted to the version of himself he displayed in the game’s first few drives. He had one completion in the third quarter, leading the Cardinals to one first down and 10 yards of offense in the frame. He didn’t settle back in until the fourth, when he led Louisville on a touchdown drive that extended its lead to eight late.
In the end, that was all he needed to give the Cardinals the win.
Malachi’s wild ride
After exiting Syracuse’s loss against Virginia late with a collarbone injury, it remained to be seen exactly how healthy Nelson would be entering Saturday’s matchup against Louisville. The signal-caller impressed in his SU debut — throwing for 217 yards, one touchdown and zero interceptions — but on Monday, SU head coach Fran Brown was noncommittal about his status.
“We’ll just find out when they talk to the doctors, go through stuff,” Brown said, referring to Nelson’s availability.
Ultimately, Brown decided his quarterback was healthy enough to play against the Cardinals.
Nelson rewarded Brown’s faith in him with a performance best described as a mixed bag. He began his outing with that aforementioned 65-yard strike to Hatcher, and followed it up with that aforementioned 41-yard touchdown — also to Hatcher. He had a run of eight consecutive completions — with a touchdown to Calvin Russell III — sandwiched between them and finished the first half with a 194.6 passer rating.
But Nelson lost his composure in the second half. On the Cardinals’ 5-yard line, he fumbled a snap — and SU’s best scoring opportunity of the third quarter with it. After Kerr rewarded him with a second interception of Kienholz, Nelson threw an interception to Kaleb Beasley on a pass that wasn’t particularly close to any Syracuse receiver.
He added another interception later on, this one on a tipped pass to Cam White, and Louisville capitalized with a Keyjuan Brown touchdown. Syracuse’s chances at victory ultimately ended in his hands when he got sacked on fourth-and-21 with three minutes left.
Isaac loses his motion
Isaac Newton, the English physicist, posited that an object in motion stays in motion unless acted upon by an unbalanced force. Conversely, he posited that a stationary object will remain stationary unless acted upon by an unbalanced force.
Newton has since died, unfortunately, but another Isaac was present at the Dome to prove his theory correct.
Entering Saturday, it had been a few weeks since Cardinals running back Isaac Brown met a force strong enough to prevent him from staying in motion. Two weeks ago, he gashed NC State’s defense for 125 rushing yards on nine carries. Last Friday, he erupted for 235 rushing yards and two touchdowns in the Cardinals’ win over Florida State.
But in the Dome, his motion came to a grinding halt, met by a mightily imbalanced force: Vince Kehres‘ Syracuse run defense. On Isaac’s first rush of the game, SU linebacker Chris D’Appolonia tackled him for a two-yard loss, setting the tone for his difficult day. He finished the game with 11 rushing yards. Despite his 46-yard receiving touchdown, Isaac did little else on the ground.
His longest run of the game was 10 yards. He only had one carry of more than five.

