Skip to content
football

Orange grades from UL loss: Receivers flourish, Kerr stars in secondary

Syracuse built an early 10-point lead against Louisville but stalled out offensively in the second half, resulting in a 34-26 loss.
Syracuse built an early 10-point lead against Louisville but stalled out offensively in the second half, resulting in a 34-26 loss. Avery Magee | Development Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe to our sports newsletter here.

Syracuse returned to the JMA Wireless Dome for the first time since Sept. 12 on Saturday but being home didn’t lead to a victory.

The Orange had highlights on offense and defense, plus some improved special teams play but couldn’t come away with a win against Louisville.

Instead, SU lost a tight one 34-26.

Here are position grades from Syracuse’s (2-4, 0-4 Atlantic Coast) loss to Louisville (4-3, 3-2 ACC):

Quarterback: B

Like last week, third-stringer Malachi Nelson, who started somewhat surprisingly for the second straight game, got off to a flying start. He found top wide receiver Umari Hatcher for 65- and 41-yard bombs on the game’s first two drives.

Nelson kept up with the breathless pace of scoring in the first half, leading four scoring drives and three touchdowns. He connected with freshman five-star Calvin Russell III from 24 yards for Russell’s first career touchdown.

However, like last week’s capitulation at Virginia, Nelson and SU’s offense cooled in the second half. He was on the end of three turnovers — one muffed handoff and two exasperating interceptions into a sea of Cardinal defenders. One came with no Orange receiver in sight.

Another parallel from Syracuse’s last outing was Nelson not finishing the game. After recording 315 passing yards, Georgetown transfer Danny Lauter again replaced Nelson, this time for a desperation drive with 1:50 to play in hopes of pushing the game to overtime. An eight-play drive ended with a turnover on downs.

Forced to play Nelson again, SU got commendable production from a backup player. But again it wasn’t enough to win.

Running back: B-

SU’s running back room has platooned who takes the lion’s share of the snaps each game. Saturday, Jackson State transfer Ahmad Miller took the reins. He had 123 yards on 18 carries and scored one touchdown — a gritty 20-yard run late in the second quarter.

Tylik Hill, who led the Orange in rushing yards in their last two outings, had a lesser role, picking up 26 yards on 11 carries.

However, after rushing for 84 yards in the first half, Syracuse mustered four yards in the third quarter, part of a scoreless stanza marred by a fumble where Nelson and Hill miscommunicated, and the ball fell to the turf on a third-and-2 at the UL 7-yard line. Back-breaking stuff from the running backs.

Receiver/Tight end: A-

Want a Syracuse positive — or at least a silver lining? Hatcher is a huge asset for the Orange and a huge problem for opponents. He has more separation power than a divorce lawyer in a room full of unfaithful spouses. He has incredible hands — he could catch a salmon leaping out of a freshwater stream.

Hatcher posted 224 yards and one touchdown on 13 receptions, serving as an escape valve or advancement tool downfield. Dare I say it: despite SU’s 0-4 ACC record, Hatcher is playing at an All-ACC First Team level alongside lauded Miami receiver Malachi Toney.

But it wasn’t just Hatcher. Russell recorded his first touchdown in Orange while hauling in six receptions. Plus, Daunte Bacheyie continued to hold his own in the tight end room with 29 yards on five catches. When you put up 339 receiving yards, as Syracuse did, you’re holding up your end of the bargain.

Offensive line: C

Yes, Nelson eclipsed 300 yards, and SU’s wide receivers had a strong day. But it could’ve been better if the Orange’s offensive line improved its protection. Louisville forced 11 tackles for loss and five sacks Saturday.

Eight SU offensive linemen played at least 12 snaps, according to Pro Football Focus, continuing a trend of rotating a normally-locked-in position group. Left tackle Trevion Mack led the way with a 70.9 grade — the third-best grade by a Syracuse offensive player — but no other consistent player on the line scored higher than 60.9.

Defensive line: B-

The Cardinals boast multiple running threats: quarterback Lincoln Kienholz and two same-surnamed running backs Keyjuan Brown and Isaac Brown.

Syracuse contained Isaac to just 11 yards on nine rushes, but it allowed Kienholz to run roughshod for 53 yards and two touchdowns on 10 carries — including an 82-yard touchdown run. Keyjuan tacked on 50 yards and two scores on 13 attempts.

The Orange defensive line did harry UL frequently, though. They had 11 tackles for loss and three sacks.

Linebacker: B

The linebacker room was the center of Syracuse’s defensive success Saturday. Keyshawn Johnson earned the highest PFF grade among SU defenders, logging an 89.7.

Syracuse’s performance was even more impressive considering 2025 All-ACC Freshman honoree Antoine Deslauriers didn’t play. In his stead, linebacker Chris D’Appolonia was a menace with seven solo tackles and 3.5 tackles for loss.

The position group helped hold UL to six second-half points.

Secondary: C+

Defensive back Davien Kerr was everywhere on defense against Louisville — recording two interceptions and one sack. It was like there were two of him out there, which is conceivable since his identical twin brother is a running back for the Orange.

But it was just Kerr carrying a heavy load. He did have some help in Chris Peal, who had a 77.2 pass-coverage grade.

But the eye test didn’t paint a pretty picture for SU’s secondary. Kienholz recorded 310 passing yards on just 14 completions. Four of those passes were 35 yards or longer.

Special teams: B+

For once, there isn’t much to write home about with Syracuse’s special teams. Past games have been marred by kicking woes, but the Orange mostly held serve on their field goals. Freshman Shay Barker knocked in bids for 26 and 24 yards when called upon. The one blotch on his record was a missed PAT after a 15-yard penalty pushed the try back.

The kicking Whac-A-Mole didn’t show its head and need to be hammered down against the Cardinals, a slight relief for the Orange.

Coaching: C+

Again, Syracuse’s offense couldn’t sustain its scoring in the second half. The Orange had three points after the break following a 23-point mark in the first 30 minutes. Granted, SU’s defense tightened the screws versus Louisville in the second half after being vulnerable in the first.

The inability to play a complete game lands on the coaches. The inability to adjust quickly enough is the coaches’ responsibility.

SU, playing with a third-string quarterback, hung tight with a capable Louisville team. But like its past defeats versus Cal and Virginia, the Orange had a 10-point lead and ample opportunities to win a game in the second half, but it couldn’t take advantage of them.

The special teams looked to be ameliorated. The rest of SU’s play — the sieve-like defense, the offensive inconsistency and the penalties, for which Syracuse had eight Saturday — still needs significant work.

banned-books-01