For something so ‘meaningless,’ modern art gives us plenty to talk about
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.
In 1966, Barnett Newman began “Who’s Afraid of Red, Yellow and Blue,” a series of four large-scale paintings dominated by bold arrangements of the aforementioned colors. With the title, Newman dared his audience to find something objectionable about these simple primary colors.
In 1982, the fourth painting in the series was slashed with a box cutter at the Stedelijk Museum in Amsterdam, Netherlands. In 1986, the third met a similar fate at the Neue Nationalgalerie in Berlin, Germany. It seems almost absurd that something as innocuous as color on a canvas could incite such hostility. Yet the absurdity lies less in the paintings than in the intensity of the response to them.
So, who’s afraid of modern art?
Apparently, quite a few people.
Modern art sits at the crossroads of public discourse. While traditional paintings are evaluated on their execution, composition or aesthetic appeal, modern works are subjected to an entirely different question: whether they deserve to be considered art in the first place. A monochromatic canvas, an arrangement of geometric shapes or an otherwise empty exhibition space can quickly become evidence of artistic pretension. Predictably, the same criticism follows: “I could’ve done that.”
The problem isn’t necessarily the criticism itself, but the underlying presumption that technical difficulty determines aesthetic merit.
Technical mastery is worth appreciating. The ability to reproduce the human figure, capture light or construct the illusion of depth requires considerable skill. But treating these qualities as prerequisites for artistic legitimacy does a disservice to the broader definition of art. It suggests the purpose of painting is primarily to demonstrate technical ability, rather than to communicate an idea, challenge a convention or provoke an emotional response.
Art that elicits a reaction from its audience has already fulfilled one of its most essential functions: compelling the viewer to engage. It’s easy to assume this reaction must take the form of admiration, pleasure or understanding, when it can also manifest as confusion, irritation or outright contempt. The emotional response itself becomes part of the relationship between the viewer and the work.
The problem isn’t necessarily the criticism itself, but the underlying presumption that technical difficulty determines aesthetic merit.Gain Lim, Columnist
A glaring contradiction emerges when a supposedly insignificant piece becomes the subject of debate. Consider the viewer who stands before a monochromatic canvas and declares it ridiculous. In doing so, they’re questioning the painting’s purpose, its legitimacy and, often unconsciously, their own understanding of what art should be. The encounter has prompted intellectual engagement, regardless of how unfavorable the viewer’s judgment may be.
A reaction doesn’t automatically constitute artistic achievement. An unpleasant noise or intentionally offensive gesture may cause discomfort without offering meaningful commentary. But the assumption that negative reactions constitute artistic failure is equally questionable. Art doesn’t have to reassure its audience or satisfy established expectations to deserve consideration. Discomfort can be precisely what makes a work worth discussing.
This distinction becomes particularly important when we consider how readily we accept complexity in other forms of expression. Literature, philosophy and music are rarely expected to reveal the entirety of their significance upon first encounter. We recognize that interpretation requires context and familiarity. Yet, modern art is expected to justify itself almost immediately.
There’s nothing admirable about obscurity, nor does an elaborate explanation redeem an unsuccessful artwork. Still, the inability to immediately identify a work’s meaning shouldn’t be mistaken for evidence that none exists. The more difficult question is whether we’re evaluating the work or our expectations of what it should be.
A similar confusion exists between the artistic and financial value of modern art. The extraordinary prices attached to seemingly simple paintings understandably invite skepticism. Museums, collectors and critics exercise considerable influence over which works are preserved, celebrated and deemed culturally significant. These institutions aren’t immune to elitism or financial interests.
But criticism of the art market shouldn’t be mistaken for criticism of the art itself.
A painting doesn’t acquire artistic merit because a collector is willing to pay an extraordinary sum for it. It also doesn’t become meaningless when an unjustifiable price is attached. Conflating artistic merit with market value allows the institutions being criticized to dictate the terms of the conversation. The issue is less about whether a particular painting deserves its price tag and more about why financial valuation has become so central to discussions of artistic legitimacy.
There’s a crucial distinction between finding no personal significance in a piece and declaring it devoid of significance altogether. The former recognizes the subjective nature of artistic experience, while the latter assumes that an individual’s response is sufficient to establish the boundaries of artistic expression.
Returning to Newman, the most revealing aspect of “Who’s Afraid of Red, Yellow and Blue” lies less in its composition than in the hostility it provoked. Though the paintings offer no recognizable threat, viewers are confronted with an artistic practice that refuses to conform to familiar expectations of representation.
The irony, of course, is that those most determined to disparage modern art are often the ones most visibly affected by it. They ridicule its simplicity, question its legitimacy and insist it has nothing to say. Yet, the very intensity of their criticism suggests otherwise. The Syracuse University Art Museum, located in the Shaffer Art Building, is free and open to the public and offers an opportunity to reconsider these assumptions firsthand. After all, for something supposedly so meaningless, modern art certainly gives us a lot to talk about.
Gain Lim is a sophomore majoring in health & exercise science. She can be reached at glim06@syr.edu.

