Skip to content
Screentime Column

Fraud or fact? Fielder’s meta ‘You Can See Everything’ dares you to decide

In Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s documentary, “You Can See Everything,” Fielder follows convicted fraudster Elizabeth Holmes 34 days before going to federal prison. “You Can See Everything” uses real footage and reenacted scenes to create a shocking documentary.
In Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s documentary, “You Can See Everything,” Fielder follows convicted fraudster Elizabeth Holmes 34 days before going to federal prison. “You Can See Everything” uses real footage and reenacted scenes to create a shocking documentary. Sarah Yudichak | Contributing Illustrator

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

Comedian Nathan Fielder and his co-director Lance Oppenheim spend the first 1.5 hours of their Elizabeth Holmes documentary, “You Can See Everything,” following Holmes and her family’s lives for 34 days before Holmes serves her 11-year prison sentence. After around 20 days, Fielder brought his suitcase to the Holmes home and moved in for the rest of the 34.

What happens after those 90 minutes is almost more insane than Holmes’ crimes.

I expected to be confused by Holmes, her lies and her fraudulent claims. What I didn’t expect is that Fielder would be guilty of defrauding audiences too.

Like many others, I was first introduced to Holmes during her fall from grace. The Stanford University dropout founded Theranos, a blood testing biomedical technology company in 2003, making her one of the richest women in America in 2014.

After 2015, Theranos began to fall apart after claims that the company put its patients in danger. In June 2018, Holmes was indicted by federal prosecutors on 10 counts of wire fraud-related charges.

I was first introduced to Fielder through his Comedy Central show “Nathan for You,” where Fielder attempts to help struggling small businesses. Fielder’s proposals are obscene, like opening a coffee shop called “Dumb Starbucks.”

Fielder’s comedy show toes the line between fraud and fact, satire and solemnity. “You Can See Everything” is no exception.

The documentary opens in 2023, when Fielder introduces Holmes, her partner, Billy Evans, and their two children in their San Diego rental home. The couple is working on a second version of Theranos, on the basis that the machine “can” work, claiming the first version of Theranos was sold on an idea, not a complete product.

Evans and Holmes met in 2017 and quickly built a life together. At the beginning of the documentary, Fielder questions Evans instinctively, asking if Evans believes Holmes has a reason to lie to him. Evans maintains Holmes’ innocence and the sanctity of their relationship. The audience is led into almost believing Evans’ claims — that is, until Fielder points out Evans comes from a wealthy family. Fielder makes viewers wonder whether Holmes could be marrying him for his money. My entire theater burst into laughter.

Fielder increasingly grows more suspicious that Holmes and Evans are withholding the truth from him about Theranos. They insist that they aren’t, with Holmes asserting that she has “never lied” once in her life. Fielder is highly skeptical and continues to question Holmes, who says she may have lied once in her life, but never significantly.

The relationship between Holmes and Fielder blurs the line from a documentarian to a friend as Holmes asks Fielder to swim in the ocean with her, which he rejects. Fielder’s uncomfortable, awkward style of comedy often puts Holmes on the spot while exposing her inability to interpret humor. After Fielder shows Holmes the famous Abbott and Costello comedy sketch “Who’s on First,” Holmes laughs, then admits she isn’t sure why the sketch is funny.

This moment becomes an anchor for Holmes’ character as the documentary continues. Holmes’ inability to distinguish humor from seriousness is shown as a possible reason for her downward spiral. When Fielder shows Holmes an episode of Hulu’s “The Dropout,” based on the beginning of Holmes’ career, she begins to cry seeing actress Amanda Seyfried’s portrayal of her.

Holmes then bids Fielder goodbye with a long hug as she travels to Bryan, Texas, to report to federal prison in 2023.


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

‘The Social Reckoning’ is messy, but its questions on social media matter

Uneven pacing and a convoluted plot overshadow the thought-provoking questions raised in Aaron Sorkin’s “The Social Reckoning.”


Holmes’ report to prison is emotional, and the documentary almost morphs into the style of a narrative movie. The documentary isn’t objective — it feels like another A24 film. The warm lighting and deeply personal questions asked throughout the documentary present Holmes as a human, not the monster the media has made Holmes out to be.

Fielder and Oppenheim do a fantastic job of showing all sides of Holmes, even if it leans heavily on empathy. The film allows confusing moments — like Holmes’ stumbling over her lies or Evans berating Holmes over small mistakes — to breathe instead of cutting them for clarity. On any other project, I wouldn’t believe this is the correct choice. In “You Can See Everything,” the little moments matter, and these seemingly mundane parts reveal the multifaceted identity of the subject.

After the farewell, the documentary resumes two years later in 2025. Evans is still working on the second version of Theranos and Fielder now visits Seyfried at her home and asks her to reenact Holmes in moments where Fielder’s crew couldn’t film for the documentary. Actor Christopher Abbott plays Evans opposite Seyfried.

The documentary details Seyfried’s process of getting into the role of Holmes, and then cuts to fully imagined scenes of her and Abbott acting as the couple. Those acted scenes come from Fielder’s memory of what he remembers Holmes saying, whether that be at a prison visit with no cameras allowed or a moment before they started production.

Through these scenes, the audience learns that Evans made a deal with the documentary’s distributor, A24, to get a cut of the profits of “You Can See Everything” while Holmes was in prison. Allegedly, Holmes had no idea about Evans’ actions, though Seyfried and Fielder struggle to believe Holmes’ manipulation didn’t extend to Evans. My theater gasped at the reveal. As an audience member, I felt almost disgusted knowing my ticket contributed to Evans’ bank account.

Back to reality, Evans now becomes the villain instead of Holmes, as it’s uncovered that he made posts on Holmes’ X account without her permission, ran billboards about her innocence with Holmes’ likeness and held her power of attorney. He even reveals himself as a fan of podcaster Charlie Kirk. As Fielder and Seyfried confront Evans about his controlling behavior, the editing becomes increasingly surreal as Evans falls apart.

At the end of the documentary, it’s revealed that A24 negotiated away from Evans taking a cut of the profits, to my theater’s audible relief.

The film’s choice of using reenactments alongside real footage was genius. It immersed the audience in Fielder’s brand of documentary satire and blended a factual documentary into a narrative film. The two opposite experiences highlight the absurdity of the situation and point toward the possibility that Holmes could’ve been manipulating the audience and Fielder all along.

“You Can See Everything” ends with a scene of Fielder and Holmes swimming and playing in the ocean together, a callback to when Holmes asked Fielder to do so earlier. By not including this scene previously, the audience thinks of Fielder as an unbiased source that presents all sides of the story. This clip changes everything.

Ending with that scene completely changed my view of the film at the very last second. Suddenly, the empathy-heavy approach made sense, and Fielder’s increasingly close relationship with Holmes was put into perspective. My theater gasped, again.

One of the best parts of “You Can See Everything” is its commitment to confusion. Fielder is an unreliable narrator and Holmes doesn’t even know when she herself is lying. This documentary doesn’t have the answers to Holmes’ crimes or even a conclusion that leaves the audience satisfied. In a film full of lies, Fielder and Oppenheim’s radical honesty of not knowing the answers is what makes it so beautiful.

In that way, the title is also genius. Just like Holmes and her Theranos machine, Fielder and Oppenheim never promised the public the truth — just a possibility. You can see everything, but that doesn’t mean that you will.

membership_button_new-10