Hot Takes: Anthony could start, Syracuse misses 6th straight March Madness
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe to our newsletter here.
Syracuse men’s basketball has revitalized its entire team for the 2026-27 season. Head coach Gerry McNamara came from Siena, and the Orange only returned two players on scholarship and added seven from the transfer portal.
SU will look to make the NCAA Tournament for the first time since 2021, ending its longest drought since 1966-72.
Here are five hot takes for Syracuse’s first year under McNamara:
Gavin Doty finishes as SU’s best player
Hot Take Meter: 1/5
A few players look poised to take the mantle as Syracuse’s No. 1 threat with its five leading scorers from last year gone. Some options include Temple transfer Aiden Tobiason and returning sophomore Sadiq White Jr.
Then, there’s Gavin Doty. Doty averaged 18.0 points per game on a 45.8% clip as a sophomore at Siena last year. His 3-point shooting was spotty — 32.6% — but he only averaged four attempts per game. Doty did that in 36.8 minutes per game last year under McNamara and logged a full 40 minutes in 10 matchups. It didn’t matter who he was playing; he led the Saints with 21 points against Duke in the NCAA Tournament First Round.
Doty has already flashed his motor, playing a team-high 30 and 37 minutes in SU’s two exhibition matchups with UConn and Siena, respectively. He paced the Orange with 20 points versus the Saints. If Doty lights up the stat sheet early this season, expect him to be the offense’s focal point all year.
Syracuse misses 6th straight NCAA Tournament
Hot Take Meter: 2/5
Syracuse has heavily dipped into the portal the last two years to fill spots left by graduating seniors and departing transfers. Each time, it hasn’t worked, and SU has missed March Madness as a result. Players who brought promising resumes to the Orange didn’t live up to the hype, namely Jaquan Carlos and Naithan George.
The same went for highly-touted freshmen. Donnie Freeman starred when healthy, but that was rare. Four-star guard Elijah Moore never got much going, averaging just 5.2 points despite starting over half his appearances, before transferring to Utah after the 2024-25 campaign. Kiyan Anthony and White, who headlined SU’s freshman class last year, had their moments but were largely disappointing offensively. White scored just 6.1 points per game.
This year, the Orange built an almost entirely new roster again with transfers like Doty, Tobiason and Garwey Dual. Yes, the team is under new leadership, but if history signals anything, SU’s fresh talent won’t mean anything until it hits the court.
Syracuse was predicted to finish 11th in the Atlantic Coast Conference Preseason Poll. So, while this looks like a roster that can end SU’s streak of missed tournaments, there’s also a real chance it fizzles out again.
Ryan Moesch leads team in assists
Hot Take Meter: 3/5
Though Ryan Moesch didn’t start SU’s exhibitions, he led it with five assists in each. Dual will likely play more to start the year due to his defense, but there’s a world where Moesch, the four-star freshman who flipped from Siena to SU, takes ball-handling duties.

SU guard Ryan Moesch dribbles along the perimeter in an exhibition against UConn on Oct. 13. The freshman posted consecutive five-assist performances and could carry his passing prowess into the regular season. Zoe Xixis | Asst. Photo Editor
Moesch spent the first three years of high school at local Chittenango High School (New York), where he averaged 3.4 assists overall and 4.8 as a junior. Moesch’s calling card was shooting, but now he has more room to facilitate since he’s not the top offensive guy.
He’ll need to work for his reps early while sitting behind Dual. But if the exhibitions showed anything, Moesch can earn and make the most of those opportunities.
Garwey Dual makes All-ACC Defensive Team
Hot Take Meter: 4/5
Syracuse’s defense was a problem last year, and McNamara brought in Dual to help with that. At McNeese last season, Dual was named to the Southland Conference All-Defensive Team, finishing sixth in the conference in steals per game (1.6).
Per EvanMiya, Dual sits 39th in the country in Defensive Bayesian Performance Rating, which measures a player’s defensive value while on the court. He was also a top-five projected defender among portal guards.
Dual isn’t at SU to be a scorer — that’s what Doty, Tobiason, White and others are for. He’s here to handle the ball and lead the defense. The All-ACC Defensive Team might be a high ceiling for him, especially with other standout defenders in the conference, but his resume makes him an early consideration.
Kiyan Anthony works into starting 5
Hot Take Meter: 5/5
Kiyan’s freshman season was underwhelming. The son of SU legend Carmelo Anthony, Kiyan entered with large expectations, ones that were probably unrealistic. He averaged 8.0 points and shot 25.4% from 3 across 18.7 minutes per game. He only started two matchups but saw increased minutes due to others’ injuries.
To make a sophomore jump, Kiyan needs to wiggle his way into the starting five. McNamara ran with White, Tobiason, Doty, Dual and Tasman Goodrick against UConn, but Kiyan was first off the bench once Tobiason went down in the second minute with a hamstring injury.
McNamara said at SU’s Media Day he’s working with Kiyan to improve his effective field goal percentage, which measures shooting efficiency and weighs 3-pointers more heavily. Kiyan mentioned he’ll likely play more off-ball this year after Syracuse added Doty and Tobiason, a role he last filled in high school with other talented scorers around him.
It’ll be tough getting Doty and Tobiason off the court, but Kiyan could still find a way to earn a spot in the starting lineup.

