Phantom brides, dorms on cemetery grounds and more myths haunt Syracuse lore
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.
People can know a place by its curves or old architecture and yet still know little about what actually happened there. Across Syracuse and central New York, there are still buildings whose histories remain unclear.
“I grew up around here, and there has always been an ominous past in this city,” Fayetteville resident Amanda Dunlap said. “This time of year especially, you can get a shiver from thinking about what has happened, who knows?”
Dunlap is well acquainted with the many Syracuse urban legends and the subsequent explanations offered for them. Depending on who’s telling them, details can shift, but stories continue to creep in.
One of the area’s best-known legends follows the bends of Cedarvale Road, 10 miles southwest of Syracuse University’s campus. Known as the “13 Curves,” the stretch is said to be haunted by a bride who died in a crash on her wedding night.
According to the legend, she wanders the road in her wedding gown, searching for her husband, yearning for the journey they started together.
The circumstances of the crash are difficult to pin down. It isn’t clear if it took place in the early 1900s or later, or if it occurred in a car or on a motorcycle, Dunlap said. There are also no official accounts of a fatal crash taking place on the road.
The real explanation is less fright and more bite. Syracuse.com reported that a local woman and her daughter staged the widowed ghost to frighten teenagers, with the daughter playing the apparition to deter reckless driving.
Still, the bride has acquired something more concrete than her tragedy. A roadside Legends & Lore Marker commemorates her search near Cedarvale Road and West Seneca Turnpike. Keep your eyes out the next few days if you plan on driving through, Dunlap said.
WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT
How to stay mindful, keep yourself and others safe throughout Halloween
As Halloween nears, The Daily Orange has compiled safety tips to help SU students responsibly navigate the weekend.
Five miles north at Split Rock Quarry, the disaster behind a ghost story is actually documented.
During World War I, the Semet-Solvay operation converted a limestone quarry into a munitions factory producing TNT. On July 2, 1918, a fire and explosion killed 50 men. Rumor is that locals have seen apparitions of patric acid-stained workers on-site, and time goes by slower in the area surrounding the old concrete-and-stone rock crusher.
Syracuse resident Jonathan Michael passes by the abandoned quarry every day on his way to work. Nearby residents have reported hearing distant voices and the sound of the crusher’s engine revving.
“While I haven’t heard any of it myself, I am also driving to work, so who knows,” Michael said. “It’s a good time now if anyone wants to get close and check it out.”
The sound of what used to be everyday work still goes on if you get close enough to hear it.
But history also complicates this classic ghost tale. Before the current paranormal accounts, Split Rock Quarry was known for a real incident. The explosion left families mourning real deaths, not just a supernatural story to tell kids at night, Michael said.
Whether you decide to take the trip or not, you can still get a glimpse of ghost stories on campus.
Brewster, Boland and Brockway Halls stand on the former site of Old St. Mary’s Cemetery. Since the residence halls opened in 1968, accounts of unexplained music, voices and footsteps have become a part of the lore, retired SU custodian Jimmy Taylor said.
Taylor, who lives in Cortland, worked at SU on and off for over 20 years. He spent most of his time in BBB, though he jumped around residential halls and had a short stint at SUNY Buffalo. Spending time on the other side of student life felt like a one-way mirror, Taylor said.
“We are on top of the cemetery. It’s messed up for the people down there.” Taylor said. “I think all I heard was students talking, but I never thought too much. I was working.”
A student told The Daily Orange in 2009 that classical music began appearing in nighttime recordings she and her roommate made in Brewster Hall. In the basement, the eerie hallways echoed everything, Taylor said.
While the stories still go unexplained, a freshman residence hall isn’t the quietest place to be — roommates moving furniture, music from someone else’s room and footsteps you can hear through the door. Still, knowing what was there before the dorm went up gave the same sounds another meaning.
Other buildings across SU’s campus have similar tales. After the 1921 murder-suicide in Slocum Hall, students turned the history into a famous campus-ghost rumor. Meanwhile, students living in Butterfield House — home to the Alpha Gamma Delta sorority — have reported experiencing terrible nightmares and sleepwalking. And let’s not forget about supposed closed-off underground tunnels that run from Lawrinson Hall all the way to the Shaw Quadrangle, which have sparked their own share of haunted urban legends.
From Cedarvale Road to Split Rock Quarry to a student dorm, locals and college students alike bring these stories closer to life. By the time you read this, the footsteps may just be down the hall.

