Skip to content
Football

Beat writers agree Syracuse will lose 5th ACC contest vs. No. 19 SMU

Running back Ahmad Miller celebrates in Syracuse’s 31-30 overtime win over North Carolina last Saturday. Miller had 125 rushing yards in the victory.
Running back Ahmad Miller celebrates in Syracuse’s 31-30 overtime win over North Carolina last Saturday. Miller had 125 rushing yards in the victory. Tara Deluca | Photo Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

Following Syracuse’s first conference victory since September 2025 — a 31-30 overtime thriller against North Carolina — the Orange welcome their biggest test of the 2026 season. No. 19 SMU comes to town for a Halloween contest, Syracuse’s first ranked opponent of the season.

Quarterbacked by longtime star Kevin Jennings, the Mustangs rank third in the Atlantic Coast Conference in yards per game (470.1) and fourth in points per game (36.4).

They’ll be a worthy adversary for the Orange, which now have their first hint of ACC momentum in over a year.

Here’s how our beat writers think Syracuse (3-4, 1-4 ACC) will fare against SMU (6-1, 4-1 ACC) Saturday at the JMA Wireless Dome.

Noah Nussbaum (6-1)
Back to reality
SMU 36, Syracuse 20

I was the only one of us to pick Syracuse to win last week. That means I’m now eligible for a bowl game. Unfortunately, Syracuse is not, and its prospects won’t improve against SMU.

I had a feeling SU was on par with North Carolina and could get that final play head coach Fran Brown wanted for weeks. First it was Ahmad Miller with under two minutes left, then it was Cavin Russell III in overtime. SMU is a different beast, though.

The Mustangs just dropped 59 points on Cal, a team Syracuse scored 18 against in September. Brown called fifth-year SMU quarterback Kevin Jennings a “Heisman contender” at his Monday press conference, and he’s proved his worth with 2,062 and 21 total touchdowns through seven games. SMU is right behind Miami as one of the ACC’s best offenses.

Syracuse barely scraped by UNC, and that wasn’t without the usual issues — a crucial missed kick, penalties and inconsistent defense. It also faced one of the conference’s worst offenses.

How is SU meant to compete with SMU, then? It’s not. And it won’t.

So, let’s talk about the circumstances here. If Syracuse loses Saturday, its goal across the last four games is simple: clinch a bowl game before a clear impending loss to Notre Dame in its regular-season finale. That requires SU to beat Clemson, NC State and Boston College — hard but doable.

So, a win over SMU wouldn’t just turn the season around; it’d make the Orange’s path to a bowl game much more manageable. But that’s unrealistic.

Nicholas Alumkal (5-2)
Halloween horrors
SMU 33, Syracuse 23

SMU is scary. It’s 26-8 since joining the ACC in 2024. This year, it’s on a heater. It has serious money backing up the athletic program — so much that it’s starting a men’s lacrosse team in 2028 that aims to be an instant national championship contender and conference foe to the Orange.

Come Saturday in the JMA Wireless Dome, the Orange will experience some Halloween horrors against the Mustangs, who will come galloping into upstate New York like the cloaked figure in Sleepy Hollow on Halloween. I won’t expect an SU decapitation, but certainly a defeat.

That’s because SMU scored 42 unanswered points versus Cal last week. That will carry over against Syracuse. I know the Orange corrected their tailspin Saturday in Chapel Hill. They have some rhythm with Steve Angeli back and Russell hosting his coming-out party in the North Carolina end zone in the latter stages of Saturday’s game.

However, SMU has even more impetus. It’s in the top three of the ACC in most yards per game and fewest passing yards allowed per contest. Jennings has been certain as a sunset through his college career sticking with the Mustangs and just as good at ruining the opponents’ night. The most spooky notion for SU this Halloween game is that the Mustangs sport the best pass defense in the conference. Angeli may get some nightmares if his early-season struggles and interceptions resurface. He could be handing out picks like a neighbor handing out candy.

To win, the Orange better come dressed as a well-rounded football team — with fewer penalties, more accurate kicking and a reliable quarterback. That costume better be convincing. SMU showing up as itself is already a comprehensive team.

Don’t expect SU to put together a convincing costume.

Harris Pemberton (5-2)
The horse is here
SMU 38, Syracuse 28

The drought is finally over for Syracuse, and deservedly so. The Orange still had their share of flaws in Chapel Hill but did just enough to walk away with their first conference win in 13 months.

There’s undoubtedly some talent on this roster that can rise to the occasion. Saturday proved that, notably with Russell’s breakout and Angeli’s relatively sharp return. Now that SU has some momentum, it’s unfortunate that it now gets its toughest matchup of the season.

SMU has one of the top offenses in the ACC, averaging about 470 yards per game, with 313 of those coming through the air. The Mustangs also allow the fewest passing yards per game in the ACC, which will make Angeli’s job even more important. He looked sharp against North Carolina, but we know he’s prone to mistakes. And there isn’t much room for error against the nation’s No. 19-ranked squad.

One way or another — like most of SMU’s games this year — I think this one will be a shootout. But in the end, I’ll have to trust the team that’s won those games more consistently this season. And that’s the Mustangs.

banned-books-01