Skip to content
City

City leaders dissect what ‘Being a Woman in Central New York’ really means

Mayor Sharon Owens at a CNY Now event
Mayor Sharon Owens and other female city leaders spoke at a panel titled “Being a Woman in Central New York” on Wednesday. The panelists discussed resources like Vera House and outlined an ideal future with CNY’s women at the center. Cole Christopher | Staff Photographer

Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.

CNY Now, in collaboration with the NAACP of Syracuse and Onondaga County and the Onondaga County Young Democrats, discussed economic security, racial justice and women’s rights at a Wednesday panel event.

The panel, titled “Being a Woman in Central New York,” took place at the CNYPhilanthropy Center. Panelists included Syracuse Mayor Sharon Owens, Director of Public Affairs at Planned Parenthood of Central and Western NY Meredith Ouderkirk, President and CEO of Central New York Community Foundation Melanie Littlejohn and CEO of Vera House Tricia Matthews.

Madeline Thibault, lawyer and Syracuse University College of Law alumna, moderated the event and began by asking panelists to provide historical context for issues facing Syracuse, including Robert Moses’ impact on central New York and the I-81 highway project.

Owens said she doesn’t feel that Syracuse’s roads were built for people of color, but rather to ease traffic for people entering and exiting the city. The roads “ironically” destroyed “the very neighborhoods comprised of the very people that they were not built for,” she added.

Regarding Robert Moses, a former urban planner whose designs have faced controversy, Littlejohn said his designs were made to “hamper” movement, rather than push it forward.

“When we talk about systems and how systems have been designed intentionally to keep people out, Syracuse is a manifestation of that intentionality,” Littlejohn said. “And unfortunately, the intention of blocking and keeping out people who are black and brown hasn’t changed.”

Matthews and Ouderkirk then spoke about the creation of Central New York Community Foundation, Vera House and Planned Parenthood in Central New York. Ouderkirk detailed Planned Parenthood’s “rich history” in Syracuse, as it is home to the first freestanding abortion center in the United States. Planned Parenthood is crucial for people to access important healthcare options, Ouderkirk said.

Vera House, Matthews said, was formed as a way for people, not just women, to find a voice, get access to safety and feel like “there was hope for whatever they were going through.”

“We’re still fighting the same fights, and so I really hope that someday we’re not looking at a smaller version of what the issues are nationally being replayed over and over again,” Ouderkirk said. “And that we’re seeing some really some extensive progress.”


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

Advocates hope Syracuse remains landmark in fight for reproductive rights

Syracuse’s Planned Parenthood location became the first freestanding abortion clinic in the U.S. over 55 years ago.


Thibault transitioned to the current state of affairs in Syracuse and what it says about the current state of womanhood in CNY. She asked Owens how it informs what projects, initiatives and actions she takes on.

Owens spoke about poverty in the city and said that “children are poor because the caregiver is poor.” She said the city is not addressing poverty, but rather its symptoms. Owens argued that lasting progress requires improving household income through living wage jobs, not only addressing poverty’s effects.

Owens shared an example in which she designed a targeted recruitment effort for women to obtain commercial driver’s licenses and earn jobs that pay livable wages. Around 25 people came through the program, she said, but half couldn’t be hired because they failed the federally required drug test.

She also shared how the I-81 project currently employs its first heavy equipment foreman.

“(Women) just see things differently and understand the impacts of things differently,” Owens said. “Code enforcement, our fire department, our police department. When the water main breaks, I want to see a woman down in that hole fixing it. These are high-paying, very high-need positions that need to not continue to be male dominated.”

Ouderkirk echoed Owens’ sentiments, saying there’s no reproductive freedom without economic stability. People should also have the freedom to decide when, if and how to make a family, she added.

The majority of the patients who come to Planned Parenthood, Ouderkirk said, are already parents and cite concerns about being able to provide for additional children as the reason they’re there.

“I think that’s really, really heartbreaking because when we’re providing the freedom of choice to people, we want it to come down to whether or not they want to be parents,” Ouderkirk said. “Not a difficult decision that they’re having to make because they simply cannot afford to have children.”

At the CNYCF, even entry-level positions pay livable wages because they can’t talk about the “eradication of poverty and then promulgate it,” Littlejohn said.

In addition to paying livable wages and pushing women to pursue nontraditional jobs, Littlejohn emphasized the importance of education and keeping people informed. That’s how policy agendas and advocacy campaigns are developed, she added.

Thibault shifted to New York State’s Equal Rights Amendment, and discussed the case for federal constitutional protections. The federal ERA hasn’t been ratified. If enacted, the amendment would strengthen protections against sex discrimination, support reproductive freedom, help ensure pay equity, bodily autonomy and legal equality federally, not just on a state-by-state basis, Thibault said.

New York’s ERA amends the New York State Constitution to prohibit discrimination based on race, color, creed and religion. It also explicitly prohibits discrimination based on ethnicity and national origin, age and disability and sex, which includes sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, pregnancy, pregnancy outcomes, reproductive health care and autonomy, Thibault added.

Owens responded by sharing a story about a grant from the U.S. Department of Justice that stipulated she must report any undocumented immigrants in Syracuse, and would’ve held her personally liable, which she declined. She pointed to another grant that was worth $4 million, but with the same provisions.

“There is right, wrong and then just evil, and that’s what that is,” Owens said. “I can’t say no to $4 million, but I have to figure out how…to take this money and not sacrifice my community at the same time.”

To close out the panel, Thibault asked panelists what they would like to see central New York do in the future. Owens said she wants a town where people “fundamentally feel safe.” Littlejohn added that ideally there would no longer be a need for advocacy groups or the need “to have these conversations.”

Similarly, in Ouderkirk’s ideal world, her line of work no longer necessitates helping people overcome barriers to “get basic human rights,” but instead consider how people can thrive rather than survive.

“I hope (my daughters and niece) have never lived in a world where whether or not they could get the care they needed was in question,” Ouderkirk said. “I hope that they get to decide whether or not they want to be parents based entirely on whether or not they would like to be parents, and not based on their fear of maternal health disparities, and not of their fear of economic insecurity.”

membership_button_new-10