Skip to content
Food and Drink

Glazed & Confused earned ‘staple’ moniker with 10 years of quality, charity

Paul Valenti, the 55-year-old owner of Syracuse’s Glazed & Confused, holds a box of doughnuts. The business was launched in 2016 after his family visited The Fractured Prune Doughnut in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware.
Paul Valenti, the 55-year-old owner of Syracuse’s Glazed & Confused, holds a box of doughnuts. The business was launched in 2016 after his family visited The Fractured Prune Doughnut in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware. Sparrow Lieu | Staff Photographer

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

UPDATE: This story was updated at 11:33 a.m. EST on Nov. 5, 2026.

Syracuse’s Glazed & Confused, a nationally recognized doughnut shop on North Clinton Street, launched as a pop-up stand at the Taste of Syracuse festival on June 3, 2016. Coincidentally, it was National Doughnut Day.

Over 10 years, Glazed & Confused has undergone changes, like moving to its brick-and-mortar location nearly nine years ago and adding a food truck. But some aspects haven’t changed, including an over 100-year-old doughnut recipe and the shop’s pillar: giving back to the Syracuse community.

“I’m just kind of wired that way. My dad was an immigrant from Italy. He didn’t have a lot of money,” Glazed & Confused owner Paul Valenti, 55, said. “It was always ‘Be kind to people, help out as much as you can.’ This just happens to be our vehicle.”

Valenti has greeted locals and celebrities like Sam Smith and Post Malone with classic and specialty doughnuts. From Churro, Milk ‘n Cookies and the Fruity Pebbles-inspired Cereal Killer doughnuts, Glazed & Confused — a play on words of Led Zeppelin’s “Dazed And Confused” — celebrated its 10-year milestone in June. Plus, Nov. 17 marks nine years since the business settled in the Clinton Square area, near downtown Syracuse staples like Dinosaur Bar-B-Que and Apizza Regionale.

Valenti never thought he’d own a permanent storefront. Now, he’s earned the nickname “Paulie Donuts” — a nod to Paulie “Walnuts” Gualtieri, a character from “The Sopranos.”

The idea for the fried-dough joint was sparked by a family vacation to Rehoboth Beach, Delaware. After a visit to The Fractured Prune Doughnut, Valenti said his daughter and son — ages 13 and 8 at the time — asked why there wasn’t a similar shop in Syracuse during their car ride home.

Thus, Glazed & Confused.

From the start, it was a family effort. Valenti said his kids worked the pop-up stand and donated 10% of the proceeds to local charities. Valenti’s kids were involved with the business until leaving for college (Valenti’s daughter is a Syracuse University alum), but both still help out some weekends and in the summer.

Valenti’s son even acted as an entrepreneur for the spot in middle school by handing out free doughnut coupons, customer Tabitha Cleveland said. She first visited the shop in 2020 because her daughter received a coupon, and Cleveland’s returned often over the years.

Early on in the business’ inception, Tommy Lincoln, a graphic designer who founded Syracuse design agency Stay Fresh in 2014, collaborated with Valenti on the business’ logo: a doughnut featuring a handlebar mustache and dripping purple icing. Lincoln said he showed Valenti some logo options, but Valenti was intrigued by a mustache drawing — based on Lincoln’s Sicilian grandfather’s push broom mustache — in Lincoln’s sketchbook. So, they made it happen.

Lincoln said he’s created doughnut icons for nearly every flavor Valenti launches. Some icons are based on real people or pop culture figures, like Jim Boeheim and Clark Griswold from “National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation.” Lincoln also designed Glazed & Confused’s food truck, doughnut boxes and painted the shop’s interior and exterior.

“When you go into it or if you see it out, you see this little universe of doughnuts coming at you, or you step into this universe of these confused doughnuts,” Lincoln said.

Paul Valenti lines up specialty doughnuts on Glazed & Confused’s counter. Valenti never thought he’d own a brick-and-mortar shop; now, his nickname is “Paulie Donuts.” Sparrow Lieu | Staff Photographer

Valenti said the same employee has fried the doughnuts in an old-fashioned kettle fryer around 12 a.m. for close to eight years, so they’re fresh for customers each morning. Glazed & Confused is now a “downtown staple,” so despite new doughnut icons, the logo doesn’t need to change, Lincoln said.

“That’s the Glazed & Confused doughnut,” he said. “It’s been 10 years. It’s embedded in people’s brains now.”

Cleveland appreciated Glazed & Confused’s contributions to the Syracuse community — something that’s not advertised, she said. Instead of trying to make a profit from leftover doughnuts, the shop gives them to people in need.

“Rather than just toss them in the garbage or try to resell them the next day, they’re giving them to people who are hungry, which is a wonderful thing,” Cleveland said.

Leftover doughnuts from the day get dropped off at local businesses, the Samaritan Center, Catholic Charities of Onondaga County or given to homeless people, Valenti said. He also added that Glazed & Confused donates gift cards for raffles or giveaways, benefiting organizations from the Liverpool High School volleyball team to Vera House.

“It’s an important part of the equation,” Valenti said. “And I just thought it was important for the kids to see at an early age, like giving back is part of a good DNA.”

As an associate broker at Keller Williams Realty, Cleveland picks up dozens of doughnuts for client appreciation events. She said clients love the sweets and look forward to them every year.

Some of Cleveland’s top picks are the Pardon My French Toast and “Fill It” Friday doughnuts — this week’s is a blueberry pie filling-stuffed doughnut — but her favorite part about Glazed & Confused is the customer service. She said the staff is incredibly friendly; even if there are three people ahead of you in line when you walk in, employees still greet you.

“It’s really kind of old-school customer service,” Cleveland said. “There’s a lot of places you just don’t find that anymore.”

Valenti said online customer orders have grown to around 40% of Glazed & Confused’s business. Many SU students order on the weekends and game days through DoorDash or Grubhub, but students’ families usually stop by the shop when they’re visiting Syracuse, he said. Valenti’s clientele isn’t only expanding online — the business also caters weddings, parties and even former Syracuse Mayor Ben Walsh’s inaugural ball.

Glazed & Confused rotates flavors every quarter and introduced mini doughnut platters for catering last spring, but outside of that, a lot of aspects haven’t changed. The spot still just focuses on doughnuts and beverages.

“We’re not adding bagels or nothing. We’re not adding cookies,” Valenti said. “(We’ll) stay in our wheelhouse.”

The best-selling doughnut, The Dizzy Pig — a maple glaze and bacon combo that Homer Simpson would probably die for — was sold at the original pop-up stand in 2016. And, the prices have even remained the same since opening.

“We were like the (New York) Yankees for a while. We were so busy in the beginning that they either loved us or hated us,” Valenti said. “We haven’t raised our prices since the day we opened. So people that once perceived us as an expensive doughnut shop, now we’re less expensive than Dunkin’.”


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

Owners infuse Italian flavors, pizza passion into new Westcott spot ioli

Co-owners Jonathan Durand and Damian Vallelonga launched Westcott Street’s ioli pizza, an eatery selling Neapolitan pizza, on Sept. 9.


Glazed & Confused was set to expand, but the COVID-19 pandemic hindered those plans. Valenti said he’s currently looking into a possible expansion to Binghamton or Rochester, though.

But for now, Glazed & Confused continues giving back to the community, one doughnut at a time.

“People were like, ‘There’s no way you can make it just selling doughnuts.’ I was like, ‘All right, we’re gonna give it a run,’ and here we still are,” Valenti said. “So it means a lot. That’s why we give back to the community. Because if it wasn’t for them, we’d be in a lot of trouble.”

membership_button_new-10