Rep. Mannion’s policies, background make him right choice for NY-22
Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.
This election season illustrated a shift in the political pendulum unlike anything we’ve seen before. After two years of a Republican-controlled Congress with President Donald Trump at the helm, the midterms ushered in a blue wave, with Democrats now holding a majority in both chambers. This nationwide standoff was reflected in Onondaga County’s race between Democratic Rep. John Mannion and Republican challenger Kailee Buller.
A former teacher and labor leader, Mannion flipped New York’s 22nd Congressional District from Republican control in 2024 when he defeated Brandon Williams by 9.1 percentage points. This marked a major shift in a historically Republican-leaning district. Mannion’s first term was viewed as a mixed bag, with supporters praising his opposition to the Trump administration and critics questioning his effectiveness in working across the aisle to tackle affordability concerns.
This doubt is where Buller gained popularity. She criticized Mannion for partisan voting and his “failure” to deliver meaningful results for the district. She also secured major endorsements from Republican leaders such as Trump, Speaker of the House Mike Johnson and Rep. Mike Lawler. Despite this praise, Buller entered the election as a major underdog.
For Republicans hoping to flip the district, the predicted Democratic victory unfortunately came true. Mannion defeated Buller with 58.3% of the vote, compared to her 41.6%. Over 270,000 votes were cast, with 159,032 going to Mannion and 113,377 going to Buller. Onondaga County experienced slightly higher turnout at an impressive 57%.
Several key reasons contributed to the results turning out in the Democrats’ favor. Arguably the most important advantage Mannion had was his incumbency and experience. Reelection rates for House incumbents sit in the mid-90s, highlighting the difficulty challengers faced in unseating established representatives. For Buller, who’d never held elected office, defeating an incumbent with years of public service and established name recognition presented a significant challenge.
Similarly, Mannion’s experience and name recognition also opened doors for campaign spending. He reportedly raised over $3.2 million, compared to Buller’s $464,688. He spent $2.3 million while she spent $304,550, resulting in Buller being outraised and outspent by over seven times as much. This significantly larger war chest enabled Democrats to spend more on advertising, voter outreach and other factors that made a difference on Election Day.
Most considerably, one of Buller’s greatest endorsements actually turned into one of her largest burdens: Trump. The president’s approval rating in New York state is 30%, with 60% of likely voters viewing him unfavorably. It’s possible Trump’s endorsement alienated some of her voters while breaking her image as a moderate Republican. This, alongside her frequent association with Trump and his policies, potentially made her a casualty of growing anti-Trump sentiment reflected in the most recent election.
Winning back Congress is one thing; convincing voters they deserve to keep it is another.Jude Magnotti, Columnist
While both candidates had compelling arguments for their campaigns, I ultimately believe the people of New York’s 22nd Congressional District made the right decision in electing Mannion. My reasoning lies not in partisanship, but in the candidates’ respective backgrounds and policy priorities.
Mannion has not only two years in Congress under his belt, but 30 years as a public school teacher, eight years as a union leader and four years in the New York State Senate. He has firsthand experience in education, labor negotiation and the challenges that face working-class families. Similarly, he’d clearly defined policies centered around investment in education, affordable health care and lowering utility costs — all issues that matter tremendously to central New York voters.
On the other hand, Buller had more of a specialized background in agriculture, lacking experience in public office or with working-class citizens. While her experience matters particularly to rural voters, it’s less relevant to economic concerns, and there’s little to no sample size on how she’d act or behave in Congress. Her policies were also indecisive on immigration, foreign policy and health care while lacking a clear central identity.
Mannion’s victory gave Democrats another foothold in Washington D.C., but it wasn’t a blank check from voters. The same electorate that helped deliver control of Congress to Democrats in 2026 can just as easily take it away in 2028. If Mannion fails to deliver on the affordability, health care and economic promises that helped secure his reelection, his large margin of victory could quickly become a distant memory.
Winning back Congress is one thing; convincing voters they deserve to keep it is another. Mannion now has two years to prove his victory and the blue wave that helped make it possible isn’t simply an overcorrection in response to a dissatisfaction with Republicans, but an indication of a nationwide shift toward better days. Only time will tell, but come 2028, voters won’t be asking what Democrats stand against; they’ll be asking what they actually accomplished.
Jude Magnotti is a freshman majoring in public relations and political science. He can be reached at jpmagnot@syr.edu.

