KJ Apa’s charisma is sole spark in mediocre James Stewart biopic ‘Jimmy’
Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.
Actor James Stewart’s 1946 classic “It’s a Wonderful Life,” the story of an angel showing a down-on-his-luck man the beauty in his life, is bursting at the seams with heart.
Director Aaron Burns’ “Jimmy” is a biopic that explores Stewart’s life in the 1940s. Thanks to his soulful portrayal of Stewart, actor KJ Apa captures that same heart. But the film itself, which is littered with cliches and overacting, rings hollow.
Released on Friday, Burns’ third feature film spans approximately five years based on Stewart’s real life, leading up to his work on “It’s a Wonderful Life.”
“Jimmy” primarily follows Stewart’s experience as a fighter pilot for the United States Armed Forces during World War II. In 1941, Stewart brought home an Academy Award for his role in “The Philadelphia Story,” further solidifying himself as a Hollywood star.
Shortly after the Oscar win, he enlisted in the U.S. Armed Forces. In the film, this challenged expectations — of both the media and his father — that he wasn’t cut out to serve his country.
Louis Mayer (Jason Alexander), co-founder of MGM Studios, suggests Stewart can make war propaganda movies at home instead of risking his life. But Stewart ended up flying 20 combat missions as a pilot before the end of the war.
Upon returning home, Stewart experienced severe post-traumatic stress disorder and guilt because of the men that died serving under his command. Stewart wasn’t sure if he’d ever act again, until his friend and collaborator, director Frank Capra (Max Casella), asked him to play the lead in his movie “It’s a Wonderful Life.”
Don’t get me wrong, as a Stewart fan, this flick had me tearing up more than I expected. But holistically, “Jimmy” is largely forgettable. The common denominator in the film’s few moments of authenticity is Apa’s heartfelt performance.
Apa successfully recreates Stewart’s winsome voice — elongated vowels and drawl included. Channeling Stewart’s charisma is a tall task that Apa aces, but what really impressed me was Apa’s ability to quickly flip a switch from a controlled composure to an emotional state.
Halfway through the movie, Stewart delivers an inspiring, hopeful speech to dispirited pilots during a mission briefing. After he rallies the troops, he turns away from them, and with anguish in his eyes, tears well up. Throughout the film, Apa makes it easy to empathize with Stewart’s struggles.
While I applaud Apa in this scene, his speech reflects the film’s main flaws: It’s overly sentimental and sensational. The speech is filled with overbearing rah-rah patriotism that’s present across “Jimmy.”
Plus, in what felt like every scene depicting Stewart’s military service, you’re reminded that he was, in fact, an actor, even through heavy-handed sequences. For example, Col. Terrill (Rob Riggle) informs Stewart that pilots must fly 30 required missions in Europe, instead of the previous 15. When Stewart asks Terrill how he should approach his men about the added missions, Terrill tells him he’ll figure it out because he’s a good actor. On-the-nose moments like these, which are embedded throughout the film, become forced.
WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT
‘Wicker’ ropes you in with erotica, then breaks your heart with woefulness
Alex Huston Fischer and Eleanor Wilson’s “Wicker” is an emotional ride filled with deep, nuanced characters, our columnist says.
One sentimental aspect that works in “Jimmy” are the tasteful biblical references. Stewart’s dad, who was also a veteran, gives his son a pocket-sized Book of Psalms. After Stewart — who was a devout Presbyterian — uses it to get through his military service, he passes it on to a fan and fellow veteran.
The fan showed up to an event honoring Stewart’s return to his hometown of Indiana, Pennsylvania, after the war. The two share a moment together, recognizing their war traumas, and Stewart gives him the book. Stewart was even supposed to speak to the crowd, but a camera flash triggers his PTSD — a scene reminiscent of the homecoming sequence in “Born on the Fourth of July” and the gymnasium speech in “Oppenheimer.”
Another pitfall of “Jimmy” is the subpar acting. The exceptions are Apa and Kara Killmer, who plays Lady Julia — a composite character and overseas love interest that shares emotionally raw scenes with Stewart. The rest of the ensemble, specifically Riggle and Alexander, are unsatisfactory. Riggle’s deadpan tone has never worked for me outside of his comedies, to be fair to him. But Alexander’s over-the-top theatrical performance is an annoyance.
Also, Burns and his crew were accused of using artificial intelligence, which I wasn’t surprised to learn. During the plane sequences, the birds-eye-view shots of Europe reminded me of Snapchat’s Snap Map. Whether those sequences used AI or not, they didn’t look good.
The “It’s a Wonderful Life” reenactments are what drew me to the theater for “Jimmy,” and they didn’t disappoint. Burns does a fantastic job demonstrating how the film was therapeutic for the real-life Stewart.
One of the most memorable scenes from “It’s a Wonderful Life” is when George Bailey (Stewart) prays to God about his struggles at a bar. The real script didn’t have George crying, but Stewart actually broke down. A common fan theory is that Stewart cried because of the overwhelming PTSD he experienced during filming.
Toward the end of “Jimmy,” while watching Apa’s reenactment of “It’s a Wonderful Life,” a viewer sitting next to me in the theater mouthed Apa’s lines. Seeing how much that “Jimmy” scene resonated with another spectator distracted me from any of the film’s gimmicks.
Even with several nostalgia-coded issues, “Jimmy” does its job. The film shines a light on Stewart’s heroism and presents an emotionally uplifting story that perfectly coincides with Veterans Day.

