Skip to content
City

Changes around Fr. Fred’s retirement prompt ‘mistrust’ among parishioners

fr fred
Fr. Fred Daley of All Saints Catholic Church will now retire next June, the bishop decided. Parishioners said they still feel mistrustful of the diocese and that the incident reflects social changes necessary for the church. Avery Magee | Development Editor

Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.

Parishioners at Syracuse’s All Saints Roman Catholic Church experienced a wave of emotions over the past week following the controversial forced retirement of Rev. Fred Daley.

One week after announcing he would be unexpectedly retiring, Daley informed parishioners at his 4 p.m. service Saturday that he’ll remain as pastor through June 30, 2027. He’ll co-pastor alongside Rev. John Manno beginning Jan. 2. Bishop Douglas J. Lucia first wrote in a letter to the diocese on Nov. 5 that he was accepting Daley’s retirement.

“I feel that this was just wonderful news,” Daley said. “January 2 would have been very painful, not only for the community, but I think even the greater community.”

Daley said with the holiday season approaching, he was unsure what his next steps would be, including his living situation. In Catholic dioceses, priests serving a parish typically live in buildings provided and paid for by the diocese on the church property. Many parishioners contacted the diocese and sent letters to Pope Leo XIV in hopes of helping Daley’s situation.

A Friday release from the Roman Catholic Diocese of Syracuse announced that Bishop Lucia had “altered his original appointment” after “prayerful reflection,” that would create a smooth transition for both parishes.

The diocese received countless letters, emails and calls in the week since the Bishop previously announced Daley’s retirement. Although Lucia revisited his decision, parishioners expressed that the incident damaged their trust in the diocese and in the church at large.

Parishioners at All Saints

Parishioners at All Saints react to Daley’s announcement that he will now retire in June instead of January. Avery Magee | Development Editor

“The total lack of transparency, the rush to make a decision… it just leads to a lot of mistrust,” parishioner and Chair of the LGBTQIA+ Task Force Jeff Wright said. “It leads to a belief that Fr. Fred was isolated in this incident, that he was a mark, let’s say for this whole process, and it didn’t need to be that way.”

Daley emphasized that he was originally going to resign as pastor on June 30 and assume the position of parish life director, in accordance with the ongoing Costello Project. He had no intention to officially retire. The bishop’s new decision follows that timeline, although Daley will retire in June. Catholic priests are never officially considered to be retired from the priesthood, but they can resign from acting as pastor of a parish, Daley said.

“We heard a statement, but we need to see him,” Wright said, referring to the bishop. “He needs to hear us, and we need to hear from him. Not just in writing, not just delivered by someone else. We need to see him, we need to hear him and he needs to hear us, and that’s the process that a synodal church should be following.”

Parishioners previously requested a listening session with the bishop, which they said did not happen. Lucia acknowledged the request on Nov. 9, but didn’t discuss his thoughts.

Also present at Saturday’s service was Nico Lang, author of the book “American Teenager: How Trans Kids Are Surviving Hate and Finding Joy in a Turbulent Era.” That morning, many parishioners attended Lang’s workshop, held off the church property.

Lang said the event, which they had been coordinating with Daley, is part of their book tour. They said the event was originally supposed to be held at All Saints, but were later informed Lucia disallowed All Saints from hosting the event.

Lang said they’ve held events at all kinds of churches all across the country.

“In two years of doing this,” Lang said, “I’ve never had a bishop cancel one of my events, so that’s a first.”

Parishioner Joe DeBottis and Wright both emphasized a need for change in the church at large.


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

Amid Fr. Fred’s sudden retirement, All Saints parish carries on his mission

Article description. Parishioners said Daley’s retirement is “unprecedented,” suggesting he was being forced into retirement because of his outspoken attitude and unique ways of teaching Catholic faith.


“There are factions within the diocese that have an extreme right point of view, and in many cases, they see the Catholic Church needing to go back to pre-Vatican II times,” Wright said. “There’s a lot of work to do. That mistrust is huge with the bishop. If we can’t trust him, where do we go?”

DeBottis said he empathized with Lucia, explaining the difficulties of trying to please many constituencies and parishes, but that he disliked Lucia’s previous decision, saying “it just didn’t make any sense,” even though it followed Canon law.

“For Bishop Lucia to say, ‘Well, politics has nothing to do with it,’ it’s ridiculous because the church has always been about politics,” DeBottis said. “The history of the church has always been about the politics of the day and he can’t just ignore it.”

He also said Lucia is “probably one of the best people to handle this.”

DeBottis and Wright said the incident with Daley’s retirement signals that change needs to come to the Catholic Church. DeBottis said since Daley arrived at All Saints in 2008, the parish has grown substantially, which he credits to Daley’s inclusive environment that drew many marginalized people back to church.

They said Daley’s ministry is a step in the right direction for the church’s future.

“I think the key to the future will be dialogue,” Daley said.

Daley said Manno has taken interest in the church’s various task forces and issues, especially the LGBTQIA+ Task Force. Daley highlighted Manno’s experience working with marginalized groups and the poor and said his interest in All Saints’ mission is “great news.”

“Anytime there’s a change, there’s a lot of fear,” Daley said. “Unfortunately, in many places, in our own diocese, in the Catholic Church, LGBTQ folks are not welcomed, or even worse.”

He said the ministries will flourish with new ideas under new leadership.

Daley said he’s now able to picture what retirement might be like, though he’s said he has no intention of “hanging (his) boots up” and will continue to assist the parish in any way he can.

For him, retirement will allow him to continue to try to usher in the change that he believes needs to be done.

“It might give me more time to devote myself to Catholic social teaching on peace and social justice issues within the church and within society,” Daley said. “In some ways, I’ll be even freer to continue getting into a little bit of good trouble for the sake of the gospel.”

membership_button_new-10