City concedes fight to remove Schine Student Center’s tax-exempt status
Have you had an experience with Syracuse University’s Title IX office? Share your story with The Daily Orange’s anonymous tip line.
The city of Syracuse is no longer fighting to remove the tax-exempt status of Syracuse University’s Schine Student Center, syracuse.com reported Monday.
The decision comes after a four-year legal battle that ended on June 5 after the New York State Supreme Court ruled Schine shouldn’t be taxed, despite having public restaurant options, because the center is primarily used for educational purposes. The tax bill would’ve cost SU roughly $60,000 annually, syracuse.com reported.
Syracuse Mayor Sharon Owens made the decision to drop the matter due to “legal strategy” that her administration did not elaborate on.
After the ruling, the city’s legal department asked the court to reconsider the decision or take it to a higher court. The request was denied on Oct. 2.
WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT
Syracuse auditor deems SU’s city tax payment insufficient in 62-page report
Syracuse auditor Alexander Marion published a Sept. 14 report of the city’s financial relationship with Syracuse University.
Corporation Counsel Susan Katzoff faced criticism over the lawsuit, as she fired attorney Trevor McDaniel nine days before oral arguments began, preceding the June decision. The city did not send anyone to the argument even though the university did.
Syracuse Common Councilor Corey Williams, chair of the taxation and finance committee, pushed for the case to go through. Williams represents the district that SU resides in and has advocated for the case to be seen by the Court of Appeals.
“We’ve been fighting this for so long,” Williams told Syracuse.com. “It feels like we should exhaust every opportunity.”
Schine isn’t the only tax battle between the city and the university. SU’s Payment in Lieu of Taxes agreement expired in June and arrangements are being made for a renewal.
Syracuse City Auditor Alexander Marion called on the university to pay the city $16 million a year in taxes to the city and an additional $19 million to the Syracuse City School District under the new PILOT agreement in a report. SU previously paid the city $2 million as part of its services agreement.

