Skip to content
Food and Drink

Thanos Import Market blends Greek, Italian enclaves from 1 family to another

Soula Carni (left) and Joe Carni stand behind the counter at Thanos Import Market. After Peter Copanas was preparing to retire and close the store, Soula purchased it.
Soula Carni (left) and Joe Carni stand behind the counter at Thanos Import Market. After Peter Copanas was preparing to retire and close the store, Soula purchased it. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

Get the latest Syracuse news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.

In 2008, Peter Copanas planned to retire and close his family’s Syracuse grocery store, Thanos Import Market, the store his family had run since 1919.

Soula Carni, 64, had been shopping there since 1986 when she immigrated to the United States from Tripoli, Greece. When Soula heard about Copana’s plans to close Thanos, she said she couldn’t bear to see another city staple close.

So, she bought it and has been working at the market nearly every day since.

“I’ve been going to Thanos my whole time in Syracuse, and businesses like these have kept us fed and getting what I want,” Soula said. “It was the Greek choice to make.”

Greek immigrant Christ Thanos founded the market in Syracuse’s North Side in 1919. In 1947, the 424 Pearl St. location was passed to his daughter, Sophie Copanos, and her husband, Peter, who ran the spot for over 60 years. By 2008, the market was at its North Celina Street location.

When it came time for Sophie and Peter to retire, Soula decided to purchase the family-run business. Her son, Joe Carni, who worked nights and weekends at the store while attending high school and SUNY Plattsburgh, now runs the establishment alongside her.

Since 2016, the mother and son duo have run Thanos together, Monday through Saturday, coming in as early as 6 a.m. and leaving after 6 p.m. (5 p.m. on Saturdays.)

The shop moved to its current spot on Green Street 10 years ago, but it kept the same offerings, Joe said. The storefront acts as a grocery store and sandwich shop, serving longtime neighborhood customers as well as Syracuse University students and athletic teams.

Soula, 64, recognizes members from SU’s sports teams by their orders. Whether it’s the rowing or lacrosse team, Soula knows what to do. While she said it’s not her place to name names, she knows who wants their chicken cutlets cold, with pesto or with extra mozzarella.

Aside from cheese, Baklava, canned stuffed grape leaves and 12 specialty cheeses, including feta, gorgonzola, kefalotyri and kefalograviera, line the shelves and refrigerators of the shop. Its sandwich menu has ten options, including The Thanos, made with mixed Italian meats and aged provolone, and The Green, with tomato, mozzarella and basil pesto. Among SU students, Joe said Thanos’ sandwiches with chicken cutlets are the most popular.

Joe Carni slices a Thanos Import Market sandwich called The Green. It includes tomato, mozzarella, pesto and chicken cutlets. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

The history behind the store reflects the Greek and Italian communities that shaped its offerings, Joe said. The previous owner, Peter, hired retired Italian butchers from Syracuse’s North Side, which brought in products such as salami, capicola and prosciutto, adding Italian specialties to the market’s Greek roots.

“It’s funny to think about because when the previous owner brought in the butchers, they brought their own culture to Thanos,” Joe said. “And what would we be without our capicola?”

While many students now think of Thanos as a sandwich shop — thanks in part to the fresh bread and pesto it gets from Pastabilities — Joe said it remains primarily a grocery store, serving longtime residents and children of customers who came to the store’s previous location. Specialty stock alternates from halva to Cuse Salt Co., though it keeps classic staples like dried figs and pastas stocked.

Along with its signature bread, there’s an olive bar with black and green olives imported from Greece — the black ones being Soula’s favorite — as well as olive oil and prepared foods like eggplant Parmesan and chicken with broccoli.

But the house-aged provolone, which is in The Thanos and other sandwiches, is what sets the market apart, Joe said. At $17.99 per pound, it’s also his favorite item.

The shop ages its provolone using the same proprietary method passed down from earlier generations. The provolone is sharp and has a kick to it, while remaining soft and creamy, Joe said.

After moving to its current storefront, Thanos’ business grew even more. About a mile away from SU’s campus, the relocation brought more clients from SU, starting with fraternities and sororities.

Sorority members, like SU sophomore Clare Payson, a member of Delta Delta Delta, visited Thanos for the first time last week after a recommendation from her fellow sorority sisters.

“I didn’t know what to expect, but it’s a cute shop in a great location,” Payson said. “The Thanos, though, with extra banana peppers, was seriously delicious. And we love Soula.”

The way Payson found Thanos is the way Joe said most clients from SU hear about the market. After the Greek life exposure, word spread to the student-athletes.

SU’s Lacrosse team even catered chicken cutlet sandwiches before a game last year. Joe said the chicken cutlet sandwich has become especially popular among students, while the Thanos has drawn attention through local media coverage and TikTok posts.

Thanos Import Market owner Soula Carni slices the shop’s house-aged provolone. The market sells other speciality cheeses, like feta, gorgonzola, kefalotyri and kefalograviera. Eli Schwartz | Asst. Photo Editor

For SUNY ESF junior Paul Cuneo, who attended SU last year, Thanos was the spot all his rowing teammates talked about. It’s the spot he drives to with his friends and just when he’s feeling hungry, even if he has food at home.

“I ordered Thanos, and it was extremely good, and the ingredients seemed to be of the highest quality,” Cuneo said. “My only disappointment was that the Mad Titan himself wasn’t the one who made my sandwich.”

Student traffic has grown over the last 10 years, with lunch now being busy all week long, Joe said. It gets so busy that the market has seven staff members on rotation to cover rush hours.

While the rush is great, Joe also said meats and cheeses are sliced to order, which can take longer than ordering at a chain sandwich shop. But the extra wait is what the shop is all about.

“Things are probably a little bit more expensive than other places, but I think that’s just a testament to our quality,” Joe said. “It might take a little bit longer to get a sandwich than you might at Jersey Mike’s, but it’s gonna be a lot better, and this is not Jersey Mike’s.”

The Carnis also try to work with other regional markets, Joe said. Rather than viewing one another as just competitors, they sometimes buy from wholesalers together to get better prices. It’s all a competition with big-box stores, especially the largest Wegmans store in America, which is 20 minutes away, he said.

For now, Soula and Joe plan to focus on preparing for the busiest stretches. This semester, they added a third sandwich press, because on some Saturdays two just wasn’t enough, he said. He is now considering adding a fourth.


WHAT YOU SHOULD READ NEXT

Columbus Bakery upholds 4 ingredients, rises through 5 generations of Retzos

Syracuse’s Columbus Baking Co. has been kneading dough and baking fresh, Italian-style bread on Pearl Street for more than 130 years.


A larger location with a kitchen could let Thanos prepare more food, including chicken Parms, Joe said, which are “ordered by the truckload.” Customers ask for it, but the current store’s layout doesn’t have enough space for a full kitchen. If the option for a larger storefront in the same area appears, Joe said it would be a good opportunity to expand the market’s offerings.

For now, he said the family is working to understand the busiest times and make the most of the store they have. More importantly, they haven’t lost the goal of serving fresh groceries and food to the community that Thanos has served for over a century, Soula said.

“We’re making the best of what we got,” Soula said. “Hopefully I’ll be here for 100 more years.”

membership_button_new-10